Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 June 2015

Consolidation looms at last in India as Jio prepares 4G launch

The Indian market has been waiting for operator consolidation for years, as ultra-low ARPUs, meagre allocations of spectrum and corruption scandals have all damaged carriers’ ability to compete on anything but price, especially in the overcrowded 2G space. With Reliance Jio set to launch its 4G services in November, adding yet another provider to the mix, the creation of fewer, more viable operators seems urgent, and the other Reliance – Reliance Communications – may set the ball rolling, with the news that it is in merger talks with Sistema Shyam TeleServices, which uses the MTS India brand.

According to sources, a stock swap is under discussion, which would leave Russian-owned Sistema with a 10% stake in the enlarged RCom, India’s fourth largest MNO. A deal would bring RCom additional spectrum for LTE. Sistema has been talking up plans to move directly from its CDMA-based 2G network to LTE by refarming its spectrum in 800 MHz (although it has seen some of its licences cancelled). It is the only CDMA-only provider left in India, but RCom does also have a CDMA side to its business, and has also been looking at repurposing that spectrum – in 800 MHz and 1.8 GHz, both global LTE bands – for 4G, in addition to airwaves it has secured for LTE in recent auctions.

Acquisition would certainly be a good option for Sistema, which lacks the scale to make an overnight leap from its ageing CDMA network into LTE. It has a heavily data-driven business model, dating to India’s pre-3G days, when CDMA was the best data network. However, it has since been overtaken by 3G and early TD-LTE roll-outs, and despite its talk about 4G, its only real response to date has been to offer WiFi services via various partners, notably Railtel, which provides hotspots at major railway stations.

Meanwhile, it will be hopelessly left behind once LTE deployments gather pace. India’s journey to 4G has been a slow and jumpy one, but Reliance Jio is finally poised to fulfil its disruptive potential as a new national wireless operator. Five years after securing the only nationwide licence to operate TD-LTE services in the 2.3 GHz band, Reliance Jio will launch commercial services in December, and can also harness its recently acquired 800 MHz and 1.8 GHz airwaves for FD-LTE.

Jio aims to achieve coverage of almost 80% of the population by launch, and 100% coverage by the end of 2018. It also promises to connect onem homes with fiber in the same timeframe.

Like new entrants in other markets, such as France, Jio knows it needs to be aggressive if it is to stand any chance of disrupting the incumbents. It will offer voice and data services at half the current average market price, said chairman Mukesh Ambani, who said he aims to play a significant role in transforming India into a top 10 nation by internet penetration (it is currently in 142nd place). The company said it will offer a range of LTE handsets priced below INR4,000 ($62) and price its services at INR300-INR500 (from $4.5).

This will be unwelcome news to the other players, which have relied on 3G and 4G to enable them to offer higher value services and start to haul themselves out of India’s intense 2G price war, which puts massive limitations on profit potential. However, Reliance’s purchase, last year, of a majority stake in TV and video provider Network 18, could point to a more creative approach once Jio has used high profile price deals to win consumer attention and a seed user base. It could see free TV and online content bundled with 4G subscriptions, for instance. In April, the operator also launched an over-the-top voice and messaging application, Jio Chat, to help build brand recognition and offer voice services in the absence of full mobile coverage to support cellular voice.

When Reliance Industries (RIL) bought ISP Infocomm – which had gained the only national allocation of 2.3 GHz spectrum in the 2010 auction – there were expectations that the company would move quickly to launch broadband wireless services and exploit its headstart over the established mobile operators. But it has waited all this time – and indeed, by delaying by a further six months to December 2015, it will violate the terms of its licence.

The long wait indicates that the hurdles in the way of challenging the incumbents have been higher than Jio expected, despite India’s huge pent-up demand for broadband services. However, rather than leaping into headline-grabbing but insubstantial roll-outs, the company has spent five years steadily building up the wherewithal to be a top tier contender. This was despite shareholder pressure on its parent company – which has invested 19% of its total capital in a telecoms comeback, despite garnering no revenue from Jio yet – to kickstart sales.

However, as India’s second largest public company, and its most profititable, RIL has the resources to take its time on building the foundations of its wireless adventure. The telecoms activities of the Reliance conglomerate were split off in 2006, after an acrimonious break-up of the company which led to its division into RIL and Reliance Communications. The non-compete clause of that deal expired in 2010, leading to speculation that the two firms might reunite.

For now, however, RIL has been going it alone (though it has roaming and other agreements with its former subsidiary). It has had several challenges. One was to build up a more mixed bag of spectrum. Being a 4G-only new entrant had some advantages, with no legacy to defend, but also meant Reliance lacked low frequency spectrum, which is essential for achieving broad coverage at the low cost levels required in India, where ARPUs are among the smallest in the world.

It has been in talks with other operators about roaming and spectrum sharing – as have most of the large MNOs, which have been hampered in 3G and 4G by fragmented regional spectrum holdings and by regulatory restrictions on roaming and sharing.

These factors made it essential for Jio to acquire other spectrum of its own – it gained about 5 MHz in the 1.8 GHz band in the February 2014 auction, and a year later, it was

the fourth largest winner of airwaves in India’s biggest multiband 4G-focused sale. It said at the time: “With this investment, in addition to pan-India 2.3 GHz spectrum, Reliance Jio Infocomm has spectrum in either 800 MHz or 1800 MHz or both, in 20 out of total 22 circles in the country. This combined spectrum footprint across frequency bands provides significant network capacity and deep coverage.”

It secured 49 units of 800 MHz spectrum in 10 of India’s 23 telecoms operating ‘circles’, although it still has coverage challenges, since these are largely non-contiguous (they are contiguous in only four circles – Mumbai, Madhya Pradesh, Assam and Northeast).

“It remains to be seen how Reliance Jio deploys 800 MHz since it has contiguous spectrum or ‘full 5 MHz slots’ in only four out of the 10 circles where it has added such bandwidth,” wrote HSBC analysts in a recent client note. “A lot will depend on approval to spectrum trading rules which will be critical for such spectrum to be availed of by deep pocket players and 4G entrants like Reliance Jio.”

So while Reliance theoretically now has a dream combination of 2.3 GHz capacity and 800 MHz coverage, it still has work to do to create a nationwide patchwork, and will also be dependent, if it wants to take full advantage of its 2.3 GHz assets, on rapid evolution of the TDD/FDD LTE ecosystem. This is being boosted heftily by the Chinese operators, which are deploying dual-mode LTE networks, but prices and device availability may still lag behind that of mainstream FD-LTE.

That will be harnessed by other major spectrum winners – Idea cellular, Bharti Airtel and Vodafone were the top three in the 2015 auction, and they have other advantages, notably large existing investments in active and passive infrastructure; large customer bases and brand recognition; the ability to fill in 4G gaps with 2G or 3G hand-off. Reliance Jio has spent a lot of the past few years negotiating deals to share infrastructure and other resources – it now has five tower sharing agreements, with Reliance Communications, Bharti Airtel, Infratel, ATC India and Ascend Telecom.

But its challenge is not just about catching up with established rivals in terms of network infrastructure, but about differentiating itself in terms of services. As it lacks 2G or 3G networks for coverage and optimized voice, it needs to provide added value services if it is not to rely entirely on price disruption in fixed and mobile broadband, which will make 4G profits elusive.

It may, of course, want to participate in the expected wave of consolidation to pick up some readymade infrastructure and customer bases. One of the smaller providers which is exciting M&A attention is Videocon, which said last week that “large international telcos” have expressed interest in making a strategic investment in the company, according to India’s Economic Times. Videocon, which has less than 1% market share, is reported to have held talks with Telenor’s Indian subsidiary, Uninor, and with Mexico’s America Movil. The latter has been looking for expansion beyond its Latin American base but this would be its first signs of interest in Asia.

Meanwhile, the largest mobile operator, Bharti Airtel, is close to finalising a deal to acquire Augere Wireless Broadband for about INR1.5bn ($23.5m) to help it broaden 4G coverage.