Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2015

US tariff wars should prompt a new approach based on bandwidth

AT&T and Verizon look troubled by the actions of the US’s third and fourth MNOs, T-Mobile and Sprint, as the pair become increasingly disruptive in the handset game. Thankfully for the two incumbents, they have diversified their portfolios into triple play, the smart home and even the connected car, as well as more traditional M2M offerings, in order to generate new revenues and improve margins. But nevertheless, the latest bundles in T-Mobile’s series of ‘Uncarrier’ launches, as well as Sprint’s adherence to unlimited data plans, are encroaching on the top two players’ market share.

The T-Mobile announcement, made this week, sees the company launch the Jump! On Demand feature, which provides subscribers with the option of paying an additional monthly fee that allows them to upgrade their handset three times a year for no further charge.

That monthly Jump fee can be put towards paying off the handset, with users allowed to keep the phone at the end of the contract if they don’t choose to upgrade. Currently, most mobile contracts charge a flat monthly fee to lease the handset for the duration of the contract. With Jump! On Demand, T-Mobile is stressing that, in the time it takes a Verizon customer to get one upgrade, a Jump On Demand customer could get six upgrades.

“While the carriers are breaking every promise they’ve ever made with their knock-off upgrade programs, we’re racing full speed ahead, making one of our most popular moves even better,” said John Legere, TMO’s outspoken CEO. “Jump! On Demand is the best way to get a new smartphone whenever you want. Zero out the door. Zero at upgrade. Zero fees. Zero wait. Zero BS” (his usual red-blooded fighting talk).

It’s not clear how much the monthly fee for the new service is, but it looks likely to vary depending on the contract.

It’s worthwhile understanding how the new option has grown out of the Jump program that was initially launched in 2013. That is essentially a handset financing plan that requires a down payment and then 24 monthly fees. Once six monthly payments have been made, users can upgrade their phone twice in any given 12-month period – without having to finish paying off their current phone, and buying the new phone at a subsidized rate or simply the advertised down payment price.

That plan is now being rolled into Jump! On Demand, and will also include T-Mobile’s Premium Handset Protection insurance packages. The bigger change is the fact that the service now (apparently) requires no upfront fee and then only 18 equal monthly payments.

Removing the upfront fee is likely to attract more customers to the service – those who are willing to hand in a phone at the end of a contract in return for always having the latest flagship. For those who would like to pass on their phone to a friend or family member, they simply have to avoid upgrading – somewhat defeating the main attraction of Jump! on Demand but benefiting from the lack of a down payment.

Meanwhile, Sprint is currently the only major US MNO to offer an unlimited data bundle, for $80. AT&T has recently been slapped with a $100m false-advertising fine from the regulators for throttling heavy users of its own ‘unlimited’ offerings in an attempt to grandfather the deals, but for the time being, Sprint has a marketing trump card enabled by its plentiful spectrum.

All that could change though, judging by comments from CEO Marcelo Claure, made in a TV interview, in which he said: “For the next few months, unlimited continues. We might increase prices towards the latter part of the year,” and warning that Sprint might end the offering in the future.

The unlimited offering was initially used as a key differentiator with which to entice customers of AT&T and Verizon after most carriers abandoned ‘all you can eat’, because rising usage levels were killing network quality, or forcing them to invest in large amounts of extra capacity to support unprofitable ‘bandwidth hogs’. But despite its plentiful spectrum capacity, Sprint has struggled to build out its network to match the big two, and appears to be falling behind T-Mobile too. To make matters worse, TMO has now begun offering an unlimited plan for $80 per month too.

Following the passing of the new FCC rules that prohibit throttling of connection speeds, Sprint has publicly stated that it will stop throttling the connections of its heaviest data users – who are taking full advantage of the unlimited connection, apparently at Sprint’s expense.

Sprint evidently tried to counter this issue in the terms and conditions of its latest unlimited bundles, by burying a clause that said it would restrict video streaming speeds to “600Kbps at all times” – almost enough to stream a 360p YouTube video (which requires 750Kbps), but nowhere near enough to manage a HD title (1.5Mbps). After a plethora of internet uproar, Sprint has now backtracked on the restriction, but it shows a remarkable level of disregard for modern usage habits.

Sprint has also taken the time to outline its All-In bundle, which includes the cost of the device rental. For $80, customers can receive the unlimited usage deal ($60) and pay the $20 device leasing fee for a base-model smartphone – the example used being the 16GB iPhone 6. Sprint claims its rivals like to obfuscate the cost of the phone while singing the praises of their low-cost service.

Sprint and T-Mobile’s CEOs have also traded blows via Twitter. In a fairly heated series of tweets, Sprint’s Claure accused TMO of obscuring the fees it charges in the small print – which begs the question of whether Claure, or any other MNO chief for that matter, is aware that he is throwing stones in glass houses.

Why bandwidth and not total volume should be the billable unit:

Fundamentally, carriers seem to have their attitude to data all wrong – or at least twisted. It’s not the size of the monthly usage that is the bottleneck, but rather the total bandwidth available. Instead of a monthly data cap, the more sensible approach is to offer a guaranteed minimum bandwidth, and make that unlimited – that is, offer a 5Mbps plan instead of a 20GB per month plan.

Such an approach would allow MNOs to build their networks in such a way as to limit the total bandwidth that can be drawn by any one user at a time. Those users can be throttled down to that guaranteed minimum when the network is at capacity, but boosted up to the full potential of LTE when there is enough space to do so – guaranteeing a good or acceptable minimum but offering the potential of very fast speeds at quiet moments.

Such an approach takes account of smartphones’ inherent limitations – a 1080p, sometimes 1440p, screen on which users will want to stream video, but not necessarily download a film to watch later, due to the small sizes of local storage.

Those videos are likely going to be the upper threshold for guaranteed required bandwidth, as web browsing or VoIP take up less bandwidth than video streaming, and if operators really want to shake things up, they could begin moving to this model and restructuring the networks to accommodate the reality that bandwidth is the bottleneck and not the total billable throughput tallied at the end of the month. Of course, peering charges are still determined by the volume consumed, but the user experience is focused on the immediacy of content being available, and not a retrospective view of the total volume.