Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2015

Digital India Week highlights the battle royal brewing between MNOs

If anyone doubted the scale of Reliance Industries’ (RIL’s) ambition in re-entering the Indian telecoms market, those whispers were silenced at this week’s launch of Digital India Week. Reliance Jio Infocomm, the conglomerate’s youthful wireless operator subsidiary, shared top billing at the event with the largest Indian mobile carrier, Bharti Airtel. Huge sums were bandied around – $39.2bn by RIL, $15.7bn by Airtel, much of that earmarked for 4G.

While the two companies’ CEOs were full of smiles on the day, Airtel has a challenge to respond to the launch of Reliance Jio’s 4G services this year, and to defend its lead in a market which has been suffering from over-competition and razor-thin margins for years, even without the entry of a deep-pocketed new player.

Taking center stage at such a high profile launch certainly made RIL’s ambition to be a leading national mobile and broadband provider clear. Skeptics could dismiss Digital India Week as the latest in a series of government broadband initiatives which have tended to become mired in bureaucracy, dithering and in-fighting, delivering far less than they promised. Anil Ambani chairman of the ‘other Reliance’ – Reliance Group, which retained the telecoms businesses when the group split in two in 2005 – said pointedly that the Indian story so far had been driven by “3 Ds – democracy, demographics and demand” but had been badly in need of a fourth D – “decisiveness”.

Ambani claimed that prime minister Narendra Modi had introduced this element, and the premier certainly knows that the success of his government will rely on channelling India’s skills base and economic potential more effectively through technology. In front of a crowd of 15,000 in a Delhi stadium, he gathered the leaders of the Indian telecoms community together and made a very public appeal to domestic and foreign companies to invest in a program that would connect 1.2bn citizens and create 100m new jobs. Among the concrete announcements were plans for a high speed digital highway, a center of excellence focused on the internet of things (IoT), accessible government services with digital lockers to store documents, and e-hospital systems.

Such services, and the wider aim of creating fully digital systems across all government activities, are currently hindered by the lack of infrastructure. Although teledensity and internet access have grown more than sixfold since 2006, internet penetration is still only 20% and the bulk of that usage is still at low speeds. Fixed broadband penetration was 1.1% (122nd in the world) at the end of 2014, according to Deloitte, while mobile broadband penetration was 4.9%. The dichotomy between the two broadband figures indicates why much of the focus of real world Digital India plans is on mobile networks – 3G expansion and, most importantly, LTE acceleration – with fiber infrastructure to support them.

These are the areas where the big sums of money will be invested. RIL will invest its $39bn-plus (INR2.5 trillion) in “an all-IP next generation wireless broadband infrastructure across all 29 states in India, which will be amongst the best in the world”, said the firm’s chairman, Mukesh Ambani (brother of Anil) at the Delhi event. As well as its LTE services, – which will go live later this year in the nationwide TDD spectrum it acquired along with ISP Jio Infocomm – RIL is setting up a distribution network based on about 150,000 small retailers which will sell and service smartphones and other internet devices.

There are many hurdles to cross, not least coordination of Digital India with other major programs such as Smart Cities, and identification of sound business models amid the grandiose visions. It is likely that the separate National Optical Fiber Network (NOFN) plan will need to be fast-tracked to support mobile broadband expansion (it has been delayed for the past four years); that the future of the state-owned operators, BSNL and MTNL, will finally need to be decided; and that the roll-out of digital exchanges and WiFi hotspots will need to be accelerated to complement the broadband roll-outs.

Modi said in his speech: “I dream of a digital India, where government services are easily available to citizens, where access to information knows no barriers. I dream of a digital India, where government is open and governance is transparent. I dream of a digital India where the world looks to India for the next big idea.”

Behind the fine words, another agenda is clear – to ensure that Digital India underpins the creation of a homegrown electronics industry and reduces the country’s dependence on foreign technology and IPR. The aim is to end the import of nearly all electronic products by 2020, which would be a significant contributor to the goal of 100m new jobs. Most of the major suppliers, such as Nokia on the infrastructure side and Xiaomi in handsets, are investing in Indian manufacturing capacity in order to qualify as local vendors, though a significant proportion of purchases will have to be from Indian-owned companies by 2020 – an easy task in devices, where firms like MicroMAX are growing rapidly, but tougher in infrastructure, where no local firm has emerged as a mainstream player.

Indian operators have suffered from the politics of local supply, when these have hindered their ability to choose the best or cheapest kit for their needs – there were heavy delays to some 2G and 3G projects a few years ago when the government imposed new security checks on imported equipment, and limited procurement from Chinese firms. However, the 3G and 4G goldmines are opening up now, with Bharti Airtel, the two Reliances, Tata and Vodafone all investing heavily.

This week, Airtel was reported to be planning a spend of $1bn on 3G expansion during the current financial year, having acquired new spectrum in March. It aims to use 900 MHz and 2.1 GHz frequencies to offer 3G in 21 of India’s 22 telecoms circles or operating regions. About one-third of its sites are now 3G-capable, up from 22% a year ago. In addition to the 3G sums, Airtel also plans $1.3bn in network capex, to be split between its African subsidiaries, and other domestic projects such as TD-LTE.

This will help it maintain its newly won position as the world’s third largest mobile operator, by subscriber numbers, after China Mobile and Vodafone. The Indian leader has 303.1m subscribers across 20 countries in Asia and Africa, according to the latest numbers from World Cellular Information Services (WCIS). This means it has narrowly overtaken China Unicom, with 299.1m, though it is still well behind the two leaders, which have 626.7m and 403.8m respectively. Airtel became the world’s fourth largest MNO in October 2012 and since then it has added over 53m net new customers. Almost three-quarters (73%) of Airtel’s subscriber base is in India.