Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 July 2015

Special Report: Changing Smartphone Landscapes

The new smartphone landscape, where Chinese alliances are vital

 

There is something of a theme to this week’s issue. As China (and soon India) become the engines behind the mobile market, US and European firms must partner, and even merge, with rising stars from those countries – not erect protectionist walls or try vainly to keep global leadership with their own efforts alone. This is why a rumored Tshinghua-Micron deal would not be all bad news for the US, particularly for Intel, which partners both.

In the smartphone world, Google services are effectively shut out of China, meaning that a specific Chinese ecosystem is being created around Android, but with Baidu and Alibaba offerings at their heart, not Google’s own. This is what happens when companies don’t bite the bullet of working with Chinese partners. Increasingly, the mobile market, from chips to devices to operating systems, will be shaped by Chinese-western cooperation, and those which don’t think global will be marginalized.

There are opportunities for non-Chinese companies to ride the wave of that country’s smartphone and IoT growth – homegrown suppliers still lack some of the brand power and mature technology of their older western rivals.

India may prove even more lucrative for firms willing to make alliances and investments. India is set to overtake the US as the second largest smartphone market in 2017, according to recent forecasts, and despite its government’s attempts to insist on local suppliers, it has a far less developed hi-tech base than China. Therefore, it will be a big opportunity for outside vendors – from China or elsewhere – which are willing to set up manufacturing plants and local joint ventures, as Xiaomi is already doing.

Microsoft and Nokia battle on separately in smartphones

The factors outlined above are why Nokia is highly likely to make a success of its return to the smartphone business – probably a far bigger success than it made of direct smartphone sales, once Apple changed the rules. It will cast off the burdens of direct marketing, supply chain management and distribution, and of supporting its own OS, concentrating on what lies at the heart of its history – strong engineering, leading to strong IPR; global alliances; and a constant willingness to transform its business model.

This week, Nokia executives officially confirmed what they had alluded to before – that the Finnish firm will not become just an infrastructure vendor with a patents licensing arm. It will turn the latter business into a full IP business, licensing its brand along with reference designs and technologies from its labs, not just its patents. That will enable it to turn the right companies (Nokia stressed this will be about a carefully chosen and capable partner, not a licensing free-for-all) into stronger handset makers.

The obvious partners will be in Greater China or India because those countries have strong device makers which have the scale, cost efficiency and reach that Nokia had in the featurephone days, but often lack experience in developing cutting edge features to differentiate their products. Nokia also brings them a still-powerful brand, as Alcatel did when it sold its handset business, and its name, to China’s TCL.

Nokia, of course, has already tested the waters of this new approach to the devices market it once ruled, partnering with Foxconn of Taiwan to deliver the Nokia N1 tablet. From next year, its non-compete deal with Microsoft on handsets will expire and it will be able to do the same with smartphones. Microsoft, of course, was the first brand licensee, as part of its acquisition of Nokia Deices & Services, but has stopped using the name for its own handsets now, though it still uses the Lumia brand.

This week, in the wake of Microsoft’s write-off of that acquisition, Nokia Technologies issued an official statement about handset futures, saying: “The right path back to mobile phones for Nokia is through a brand licensing model. That means identifying a partner that can be responsible for all of the manufacturing, sales, marketing and customer support for a product.”

The statement added: “If and when we find a world-class partner who can take on those responsibilities, we would work closely with them to guide the design and technology differentiation, as we did with the Nokia N1 Android tablet. That’s the only way the bar would be met for a mobile device we’d be proud to have bear the Nokia brand, and that people will love to buy.”

This confirms what CEO Rajeev Suri said a year ago at the launch of the N1, that Nokia would consider licensing its brand and some technologies in handsets, but also in other markets such as security systems and set-top boxes.

A new Nokia smartphone will not be seen until at least the fourth quarter of 2016, because of the Microsoft agreement, but also because the kind of selective, possibly exclusive licensing pacts Nokia will look to do in each product segment will be long and complex to finalize. Suri said: “It will take time for opportunities to come to fruition – 18-month negotiations, with litigation can take longer. I would suggest caution when it comes to timing.”

Meanwhile, Microsoft still clings to the handset business, despite writing off the entire value of the Nokia acquisition last week and laying off 7,800 people, the majority of them in the handset space. At the time, CEO Satya Nadella said Microsoft would continue to launch and sell a reduced portfolio of handsets, targeting enterprises as well as premium and value segments. The main reason not to back away entirely from an acquisition which Nadella is known to have opposed is presumably to provide a bridge to Windows 10, though establishing the essential base for that OS in mobile and IoT devices scarcely seems to require Microsoft to continue to offer its own hardware.

Nevertheless, Microsoft is reported to be readying a low cost Windows 10 smartphone for the fourth quarter, working closely with Qualcomm, which has replaced Intel as the software giant’s best buddy, in the mobile world at least.

According to Digitimes, Microsoft is planning to release a $80 handset, initially in China, in Q415. To get to that price point, Microsoft is harnessing the alliance between Qualcomm and Chinese firm Allwinner (see Wireless Watch July 9 2015). In a deal reminiscent of Intel’s with Rockchip, Qualcomm is working with Allwinner on entry level phones and tablets based on its Snapdragon 210, with its partner providing integration and distribution to local OEMs.

In an interview with ZDnet’s Mary Foley, a long time Microsoft analyst, Nadella enlarged on some of his mobile strategies and insisted his company was not getting out of mobile or even devices. He said: “We will do everything we have to do to make sure we’re making progress on phones. Even today Terry (Myerson, the head of Windows and Devices) reinforced, that yes, we will have premium Lumias coming this year.”

But he was clear about two things – Microsoft only needs to make devices where there are too few OEMs for its operating system, in order to kickstart the market; and its mobile strategy is all about the apps (preferably running on Windows, but not necessarily). On the former point, Nadella said: “If there are a lot of OEMs, we’ll have one strategy. If there are no OEMs, we’ll have one strategy. We are committed to having the phones in our three segments.” That strategy made sense for Surface and the new Surface Hub (and for HoloLens), which were designed to showcase Windows in a new category and excite OEM, developer and user interest.

As with Microsoft’s own WiFi hardware, a decade ago, the logic is to inspire third parties to develop these gadgets and build scale, and then step back itself, to focus on its core strengths and avoid conflicts of interest. None of that applies to Windows Phone, which entered an already mature market, though it will to Windows 10 – but only if that OS is showcased on interesting new form factors, not just conventional smartphones which will continue to be also-rans regardless of their software platform.

Microsoft does not need to make mainstream devices, and Nadella knows that, as his more passionate comments always signify. It needs to get Windows onto every device, so that Windows 10 will be truly multi-device and ‘universal’ – or failing that, get its apps on every device. He said in the interview: “The reason why anybody would want to write universal apps [spanning Windows PCs, handsets etc] is not because of our 3% share in phones. It’s because a billion consumers are going to have a Start Menu, which is going to have your app.”

He added: “The fundamental truth for developers is they will build if there are users. And in our case the truth is we have users on desktop.” Of course, his challenge is to get those users, on the dwindling desktop platform, onto newer devices and screens, and W10 will live or die on how it performs in that respect.

Nadella said: “I want to be able to be present on every mobile endpoint. That’s a very explicit core goal. It’s not (just) the notion of having our application endpoints, Skype, Outlook, Wunderlist, Sunrise, on every one of the 2bn devices. We want to have Microsoft experiences, because to me that’s a platform play. It’s not like, oh, they’re just application endpoints. Guess what is behind those applications? It’s One Cloud. It’s Office 365, either for the consumer or for the enterprise. There’s MSA (Microsoft Account) in there. So to me it’s very important to think of our operating system more broadly than some old definition of an operating system.”

He added: “When I think about our Windows Phone, I want it to stand for something like Continuum … where you can have a phone and that same phone, because of our universal platform with Continuum, can, in fact, be a desktop. That is not something any other phone operating system or device can do.”

 

Cyanogen hires heavyweights to counter Google’s Android

 

It is not just in China that Google faces challenges to its control of the mobile software platform. There are many vendors which manage to layer their own distinctive user experiences and services on top of Android, denying the search giant the means to monetize its OS. And there are several firms which are digging more deeply than that, creating full Google forks (Amazon, Baidu) or even entirely different Linux-based mobile platforms (Firefox Mobile, Jolla, Ubuntu and so on – see below).

An interesting player in this fragmenting landscape is Cyanogen. This is a company with a very clear goal: to create a Google-free version of Android that is true to its open source roots but just as functional as the Google-augmented version of Android. To this end, the company’s efforts have been boosted recently, with the hiring of two notable employees from Microsoft and Qualcomm.

The company has now welcomed Stephen Lawler, formerly Microsoft’s CTO for Bing Maps and Amazon VP, who will join as SVP of Engineering, and Karthick Iyer, former Qualcomm VP and Android Engineering Lead, who will become VP of Global Systems.

The new staffers will add valuable experience of managing largescale projects, with valuable connections to mapping and chipsets – two key requirements of providing a compelling user experience on smartphones.

Firebrand, some might prefer ‘loudmouth’, CEO Kirt McMaster said “Lawler brings a wealth of technical leadership in mobile, mapping, location, search, and cloud services. Iyer has deep expertise in end-to-end Android development. Both understand how to optimally scale engineering organizations.”

McMaster is confident that Cyanogen can seize 25% of global Android installations in 5 years, with the correct ability to scale – now hopefully provided by the new hires. According to Strategy Analytics, 37% of all Android shipments currently use a non-stock or forked version of Android, which gives Cyanogen a lot of potential devices to compete for.

But Cyanogen has recently lost the business of OnePlus, which ditched the OS after an exclusivity deal with India’s Micromax meant OnePlus was not able to sell its handsets in the Indian market. Chinese deals have reportedly been signed, targeting the significant amount of vendors that already use heavily forked versions of Android, and the company has also partnered with Smartfren in Indonesia to launch a handset.

Not much attention was paid to the scrapping of the US launch of the Alcatel OneTouch Hero 2+ recently, which would have added another Cyanogen-powered handset to a rather short list. The pair said that the device launch was cancelled because it didn’t have a clear upgrade path to Android 5.1 – which is widely being attributed to its underlying MediaTek MT6592 chipset.

It’s not entirely clear from the outside why the octacore SoC won’t be able to support 5.1, and is probably attributable to lack of future support in the underlying open source Android framework, but the pair have confirmed that they intend to launch a flagship handset using Cyanogen in the near future – rather than the mid-range Hero 2. This would likely be using Qualcomm hardware, and therefore be included in the upgrade roadmaps for Android, unlike the MediaTek chip –which illustrates the tradeoff for the cheaper BOM cost.

Microsoft also signed a deal with Cyanogen in April, to place its applications as default apps on the OS, including its Office, OneDrive and Xbox apps. Given the ongoing adoption issues that Windows on mobile faces, Microsoft recognizes the value in a mobile OS in which Bing and Outlook could be the default apps instead of Google Maps and Gmail – all powered by its Cortana digital assistant.

Staying with Microsoft, Bloomberg’s reports that the company had declined from investing in Cyanogen turned out to be false, and it is now thought that Cyanogen has secured around $110m in funding to date – including the $80m round in March, in which Microsoft participated.

Cyanogen emerged as a popular alternative OS for users looking to root their Android phones in an attempt to bypass carrier-imposed functionality restrictions by gaining root access to the underlying software – with device tethering a commonly cited feature that Cyanogen users wanted to access, after MNOs began disabling the function in order to charge a premium for it.

The other more practical reason that users and operators turn to Cyanogen is because of Google’s restrictive licensing deals for its apps and services. While the underlying framework, the Android Open Source Project (AOSP) code, is open source, if a carrier or developer wants to include a single Google application (Maps, Now, Gmail, YouTube) then Google requires a license to be signed that bundles all the Google apps onto the device.

Unsurprisingly, not all developers are happy about the requirement, hence the demand for projects like Cyanogen – which also aims to redesign the proprietary drivers that are found in Android.

Yet another mobile OS joins the race, with Tshinghua’s $100m behind it

As if Jolla, Firefox, Ubuntu, Alibaba, Tizen – not to mention Windows Phone – were not enough to eat away at the Android/iOS axis, a new challenger has emerged. Acadine Technologies is the latest start-up in the race, with its new H5OS mobile platform.

Success for any of these firms will rely on Chinese and Indian support, and Acadine has that to an impressive degree, having raised no less than $100m from a subsidiary of Tshinghua Unigroup – the same Chinese state-controlled company which is expanding rapidly in hi-tech industries, owning Spreadtrum, RDA, HP’s Chinese enterprise business, and reportedly bidding to buy Micron (see separate items).

The Hong Kong-based start-up is led by founder Li Gong, previously president of Mozilla, whose Firefox Mobile OS is one of the most credible challengers to Google, with carrier backing from Telefonica and others. Li Gong parted ways with Mozilla in March and has now re-entered the space with a platform that takes Firefox OS – which is open source software – as its starting point. Acadine has brought expertise away from Mozilla as well as a CEO and the code – 40 of its 70 engineers, based in Hong Kong, Taiwan, China and the US, are from the Firefox organization.

Acadine expects to diverge from the Firefox OS project where it makes sense and could eventually have an entirely different OS. “Firefox OS, for which project I was the owner and primary driver in my last job, has definitely broken fresh ground in mobile operating systems and has demonstrated the viability of a new web-centric approach in a field dominated by Android and iOS devices,” Gong said in an interview with CNET.

Acadine secured its funding from Hong Kong-based Tsinghua Unigroup International, a subsidiary of the Chinese holding company. “I am very excited to support Dr. Gong and the team he has assembled to establish a truly open mobile operating system,” Tsinghua Unigroup chairman Zhao Weiguo said in a statement. So he should be – previous attempts to create a ‘Chinese Android’ have largely failed, so Tshinghua could significantly increase its local and global power base if it could add a successful OS to its chip and other platforms. The Chinese government has pushed for a homegrown mobile OS as part of its wider drive to reduce China’s reliance on foreign technologies and patents, and to make it both self-sufficient at home and a global leader. However, Alibaba’s Aliyun has limited presence and Baidu abandoned its Cloud OS for its own interpretation of Android.

Gong insisted Acadine will be independent of its backer, saying: “We are not a China company, we are not a US company, we are an international company.”

Taking a global view will be vital to success. As for other new platforms, the key is not to try to eat away at the entrenched markets of Android but to target newer segments where the lines are more fluid. These include underserved smartphone markets, such as Indonesia and India, where carriers and consumers may not yet be wedded to Android; and new device form factors from post-PC gadgets, to connected TVs and cars, to wearables and the wider internet of things (IoT).

H5OS is suitable for all these purposes, says Gong, and he insists that, while some argue the real power lies in the upper layers of apps and services, it is still a competitive advantage to own the OS itself. “Owning an OS is extremely important if you can do it,” Gong told CNET. “It’s very profitable if you can do it.” He sees revenue streams in charging fees to promote services like search and m-commerce as well as revenue share from those services; as well as the usual advertising and content sales.

However, all those depend on an OS having sufficient uptake to create a wide developer and user base, and plenty have failed to make much impact, even with more than $100m at their disposal (Microsoft and Samsung, to state the obvious). “To achieve market success … we must move and scale up at the supersonic speed of the mobile industry, be pragmatic and flexible, and look beyond Silicon Valley for inspiration,” Gong said.

Web/browser-based OSs like H5OS, Firefox and Chrome OS have a scaling advantage because theyn run web apps written in standard Javascript/HTML/CSS, tools which have a huge developer base and are, theoretically at least, far more portable across platforms than native apps, reducing the risk for a programmer to try a new OS.

However, the challenge of finding a chink in Android’s armor is one which the main implementation of the Firefox OS sourcecode, Mozilla’s own, is finding tough, despite launches with Telefonica in Latin America and Spain, and other successes. In the spring, Mozilla CEO Chris Beard decided that the strategy of targeting low cost smartphones for emerging markets – which was largely Gong’s creation – had failed and he is now focused on an OS which users can install themselves on unlocked Android devices. This was the signal for Gong to leave, along with CTO Andreas Gal, who went to a different start-up, still in stealth mode.

India’s second largest smartphone maker backs Sailfish OS

Meanwhile, if Acadine has looked to China for its launchpad, Finland’s Jolla is turning its eyes to India. Jolla – founded by a group of former Nokia employees who used that firm’s MeeGo Linux-based OS as their starting point – initially said Chinese partnerships would be the most important way to get momentum behind their Sailfish operating system and associated devices. But India’s second largest homegrown smartphone maker, Intex Technologies, has emerged as the first licensee for the Sailfish OS, which has just been enhanced with release 2.0.

Recently, Jolla split off its device activities into a separate business and is now fully focused on licensing Sailfish OS, a decision which should avoid some of the conflicts of interest which its progenitor, Nokia, suffered in the days of trying to license Symbian – or which Microsoft took on when it acquired Nokia’s handset business. Now Jolla is not competing with its own potential licensees, and Intex is the first of a series of sign-ups, it claims.

The Indian vendor plans to launch Sailfish products later this year, including an affordable smartphone priced at around INR10,000 ($158). The Indian smartphone market is still immature because of the relatively recent roll-out of 3G and only nascent 4G – which means there are still opportunities to gain support for a new OS, especially as the Indian handset market is shaping up quite differently from others. Although the big names are there – Samsung is still the market leader – the homegrown vendors such as MicroMAX and Intex are increasingly dominant, and are often looking for ways to differentiate themselves from the Android-based giants such as Xiaomi or Samsung.

This is the chance for a new OS like Sailfish, but it entails more than just a licensing deal – a start-up also needs to convince OEMs that it can help them leap other hurdles, such as building developer bases, brand and ecosystem (major challenges for most low cost hardware makers). Jolla and Intex will cooperate, they said, on creating that ecosystem, integrating content and services with Sailfish, including the Snapdeal Indian online marketplace and the Times Internet content portal. Release 2.0 makes such efforts easier with PartnerSpace, a premium location directly in the OS for third party and localized. This is another lesson perhaps learned from Nokia, which was – in its heyday when it was almost unbeatable in the Indian market – far more focused on localized content and services than its rivals.

Jolla has also unveiled reference design platforms to help its licensees get to market more quickly and cheaply. These are based on Qualcomm Snapdragon 200, 600 and 800 SoCs with LTE.

Another echo of Nokia – moving away from making full devices but offering licensable reference designs and software instead. Of course, the dream would be for Nokia’s licensing unit (see separate item) to adopt Sailfish, instead of (or alongside) Android when it seeks partners for its smartphone brand and designs next year. It would be a neat outcome for the former Nokia engineers in Jolla, but perhaps Nokia has been burned too often by the attempt to promote a distinctive OS.

Partners in India and China, in handsets and IoT devices, may be less battle-scarred and more enthusiastic to license an OS over which they will have a lot of influence. They are protected from the risk of a brand new platform by Sailfish’s Android application compatibility, though of course Jolla claims its own web apps run optimally.