In some ways Apple is an anomaly in the smartphone industry, and immune to some of the sector’s current vicissitudes, particularly its margin erosion. A recent study said the iPhone takes home 92% of the smartphone business’s profits, and in its third fiscal quarter, Apple’s gross margin nudged 40% (HTC and Xiaomi are closer to 20%, while Microsoft’s handset adventure yielded negative margin last year).
In other ways, the company’s quarter – and Wall Street’s reaction to it – reflected the same trends that are seen everywhere. In particular, investors are losing confidence in smartphones themselves, and need to know that companies have new devices up their sleeve to compensate for saturation in the phone market. So despite record iPhone sales – up 35% year-on-year to 47.5m units – and results that any other company would kill for, Apple’s shares fell by as much as 8.8% after it announced its figures on Tuesday night.
Analysts had projected higher iPhone sales of 48.8m, and were also disappointed by a revenue forecast of $49bn to $51bn for the current fiscal Q4 (the average forecast was $51.1bn). For Q315, net income was $10.7bn, or $1.85 a share, while revenue was up 33% year-on-year to $49.6bn – both figures ahead of expectations, as was gross margin at 39.7%.
The despondency was all about the difficult transition which lies ahead for the device business as a whole. Smartphone growth is slowing, even for Apple – both iPhone shipments and its Q4 revenue outlook fell short of Wall Street’s expectations. That may indicate excessive excitement about Apple, but it also reflects genuine concern that iPhone growth will slow, and that other iDevices will not be sufficient to make up for that.
The iPad had a glorious couple of years as the savior of growth for the iDevice family but in recent quarters it has slumped, the victim of longer replacement cycles than those of handsets, fewer available subsidies or financing deals, and the fact it remains a luxury item rather than an essential (Apple’s applications alliance with IBM is all about changing that last factor).
The new focus of investor hopes is the Apple Watch, but Apple CEO Tim Cook did not break out figures for the product, even while claiming that it had sold more quickly in its first weeks than the original iPhone or iPad.
Beyond the iPhone, the ‘other’ revenue category, which includes the Watch, saw revenue up 49% to $2.64bn. The growth figure should provide some reassurance that Apple can secure growth in new categories but of course, the actual revenue is a drop in the ocean. This unit also includes Beats headphones, iPods and other items.
Analysts read between the lines and estimated shipments of between 2m and 3m units, but while that would be a decent showing for a new and not particularly useful category, it hardly makes it the new iPhone in revenue terms – and would be below Wall Street predictions of 3.4m. There have already been indications that, after a flurry of first-week purchasing, demand slowed fairly rapidly, which may mean the Watch has an even briefer honeymoon period than its tablet stablemate.
The hunt for the new ‘must-have’ device continues, then, at least in investors’ minds – a more realistic view of Apple’s future opportunities lies in a transition away from reliance on a single hero hardware product, towards a combination of increased revenue from service platforms (content, cloud and smart home, plus the IBM deal), plus a reinvention of the Mac family. The successor to both the PC and the smartphone will surely be a diverse group of converged products. Apple may have hoped that convergence would be all about the tablet, but in fact, other form factors are likely to catch light too. A converged iPad/Mac might be its new flagship device.
The resilience of the Mac is seen in the Q3 results. While the iPad suffered its sixth consecutive quarter of shipments decline, falling 18% year-on-year to 10.9m units, Mac shipments were up 8.7% to 4.8m units, hitting their target.
For now, the iPhone remains the engine of its business, at 63% of total revenue, and the short term fears are whether Apple can continue to inject sufficient innovation and buzz into its products to fend off the increasingly high end activities of Huawei and others, especially in the key markets of China and India. Last year it did succeed in rejuvenating the iPhone with the larger-screened version, but it becomes increasingly hard for even Apple to differentiate. Abhey Lamba, an analyst at Mizuho Securities, summed up the nervousness, telling Bloomberg: “A lot of people jumped to the larger-screened iPhones, now that we’ve gotten to the point where the innovation in the next release is not going to be as massive as we had last year.”
But Cook insisted: “We think the phone has a lot of legs to it. Many, many, many years.” Speaking on the earnings call, he added: There’s ton of innovation left in the phone. I think we’re in the early innings of it, not in the late innings.” There was strong growth for the iPhone, particularly in western Europe, Greater China (where overall revenues more than doubled to $13.2bn even in a slowing economy), and Samsung’s homeland, South Korea. Cook added that only 27% of iPhone users have so far upgraded to the iPhone 6 or 6 Plus, suggesting a large number of new converts, plus “a lot of headroom left for upgraders”. He also claimed that Q315 marked Apple’s highest rate of defection from Android handsets to iPhones, despite the competition from rising stars like Xiaomi.
Cook summed up: “We’re very confident that this quarter’s going to be great. How the future looks, we’ll take it one quarter at a time.” His challenge is that, in a smartphone business which is coming near the end of its growth period, he needs a crystal ball which will allow Apple to see a lot further out than that.