Microsoft and Huawei are both companies which, arguably in Huawei’s case, should steer clear of devices. The reasons for a software company to stay out of low cost hardware have been listed many times and were all too apparent in Microsoft’s results. In the case of an infrastructure supplier, devices seem like a distraction, with a pattern of sales, margins and supply chain which is so different from that of network and data center equipment.
The Chinese firm’s main wireless networking rivals have all got out of the handsets business over the years – Alcatel sold its unit to TCL; Ericsson went into a joint venture with Sony and then exited that; Nokia, of course offloaded its devices to Microsoft. Cisco was often rumored to be planning a smartphone but was wise enough to resist temptation, and has also backed away from other devices such as its Flip camera. Of the majors, only Huawei and ZTE stay in the smartphone game.
For them, it seems to be working, for now at least. Indeed, Huawei is defying all the smartphone market’s downward trends and seeing higher growth in that business than in its core infrastructure activities.
For the first half of 2015, the company said its smartphone sales rose by 39% year-on-year despite a slowdown in its home market. It shipped 48.2m units and saw a 70% increase in midrange and high end models. The handsets are part of its consumer business group, which now accounts for almost one-third of total sales. Total first half group sales were up 30% to CNY175.9bn ($28.3bn) while the consumer division contributed $9.09bn, up 69% on the same period in 2014. Handset revenue was up 87% to $7.23bn.
Huawei said a refocus onto higher end smartphones has helped it turn in such a strong performance. It said it was well on track to hits its target of 100m smartphone shipments this year, and despite the low margins in devices, it has an overall gross margin of 20%, more than twice that of most of its infrastructure rivals.
In recent years, the company fallen short of its stated goals for handsets – for instance, for 2014 it set a target of 80m units, but shipped 75m. However, its ability to predict its market and control its supply chain has improved, and so its forecasting has become steadily more accurate – while it was 5m units off in 2014, that was far better than a shortfall of 28m in 2012, when Huawei had predicted up to 60m smartphones but actually shipped 32m.
This year, it looks like getting it right, according to Richard Yu, head of the consumer business unit, who wrote in the memo that Huawei had shipped more than 10m units every month since May. According to Gartner estimates, Huawei was fourth largest smartphone vendor in the first quarter with 18.1m shipments and 5.4% share (Samsung, Apple and Lenovo were ahead of it). Yu’s memo suggests shipments have picked up dramatically in the second quarter, and that Huawei can boost its growth further in the second half. CFO Meng Wanzhou said in her results statement that the midrange Mate7 and high end P8 models had performed particularly well, as well as the Honor family.
Over time, ZTE may do well to consider evolving into a devices and services supplier, as – like Samsung, to an even greater extent – it is being dwarfed by its competitors in the increasingly unforgiving infrastruce game. In 2014, ZTE reported smartphone shipments up by more than 50% on the previous year. In the first half of 2015, it announced this week, it shipped 26m smartphones worldwide, plus an additional 20m tablets and smart home products.
It is no longer the low end, China-focused vendor of the past, with 39% of its shipments being high end models, and with US sales up 41% year-on-year – though it has pushed back its goal of being a top three US supplier from 2017 to 2020, reflecting the high levels of competition in developed markets. The firm is now targeting 60m smartphone shipments worldwide for the full year.
Meanwhile, at the other end of the spectrum, Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella clings onto smartphone hardware, the Nokia adventure has been a disaster. As analysed in last week’s issue, the software giant is writing off the entire value of its acquisition. It duly took an $8.44bn charge in its fiscal fourth quarter (to June 30), $7.5bn of that related to the Nokia deal, and leading to a net loss of $3.2bn.
The company will continue to make a reduced number of smartphones, some of which may be useful to showcase the mobile version of Windows 10 and convince developers and users that the OS really will span all kinds of environments, as promised. Others will be for the enterprise heartland or, more bafflingly, will target the overcrowded budget market, where Nadella said he will seek greater efficiencies. The fact is, a huge software firm is never going to achieve anything close to the efficiencies required to compete with Chinese OEMs, and Microsoft should just stop now and concentrate on its core task, launching W10 as a convincing platform for all kinds of activity, including mobile.
CFO Amy Hood said on the earnings call that the changes in the handset business would cause “significant revenue declines year-over-year in the phone segment each quarter. With the proactive measures we’ve taken to reduce our cost structure, overall losses will also decline for the fiscal year. We would expect the majority of that improvement in the second half of the year once the restructuring efforts are materially complete.”
Microsoft’s Devices and Consumer business unit saw its revenue fall by 13% year-on-year to $8.7bn. Within that, phone revenue was down 38% to $1.23bn – Lumia unit sales were up to 8.4m but average selling prices fell and gross margin was negative $104m. Looking forward, the company expects handset hardware revenue of $900m, “reflecting our change in approach”, but improved gross margins. Microsoft also blamed the end of the Windows XP refresh cycle, and the wait for W10, for the unit’s poor performance. But there was one bright spot in its hardware landscape – the Surface tablets, whose revenue was up 117% to $888m, driven by the Surface Pro 3 and the launch of Surface 3.
“Our approach to investing in areas where we have differentiation and opportunity is paying off with Surface, Xbox, Bing, Office 365, Azure and Dynamics CRM Online all growing by at least double-digits,” Nadella said. Commercial cloud revenue increased by 88% on the year-ago period and now has an annual run rate of $8bn, supporting Nadella’s strong commitment to focus on this business (which he previously headed up) and indicating why he should cut the smartphone ties more decisively than he has.
The firm’s total revenues in fiscal Q4 were down 5.1% year-on-year to $22.2bn, though this was slightly ahead of analyst predictions. It made an operating loss of $2.05bn, compared with a year-ago operating profit of $6.48bn. For the full fiscal year, Microsoft reported earnings of $18.2bn, or $1.48 a share, on revenue up 8% to $93.6bn.