Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 July 2015

Avago to bid for Marvell as well as Broadcom?

Only last week we were speculating that Marvell might be the latest company to be forced out of the ever-smaller modem field. Now rumors have surfaced that the firm may have bigger decisions to make, as it could be the latest acquisition target for Avago, which is already in the process of buying Broadcom for $37bn.

At first glance, this looks counter-intuitive, since Marvell and Broadcom overlap in so many product areas, from network infrastructure switch-chips, to WiFi, Bluetooth and home broadband, to developing businesses in the internet of things. There are differences too – Marvell retains a modem presence, though under some pressure, while Broadcom exited that sector; Marvell was an early mover in ARM-based server processors, which could fit well with Avago’s storage chip activities (the result of other acquisitions, of Emulex and LSI), while Broadcom has deep presence in data center switches as well as carrier networks.

But if a bid emerges, this will be a consolidation move, increasing Avago’s scale and allowing three firms, all with significant exposure to the rise of Chinese rivals in various markets, to huddle together for warmth. In fact, in a recent research note, Credit Suisse semiconductor analyst John Pitzer picked out Marvell, Avago and Broadcom, along with Intersil, as the vendors most vulnerable to the move for Chinese firms to buy more of their chips at home.

A deal would also be part of an accelerating trend towards consolidation in the semiconductor industry, partly prompted by the rise of Chinese competition. This has seen Intel bidding for Altera, NXP for Freescale, and potentially Tshinghua for Micron, among other recent deals.

Meanwhile, vendors in another hotbed of the industry, Taiwan, are expressing concern at being marginalized by the global M&A wave, and by the rising tendency for US majors to invest in China. MK Tsai, chairman of Taiwan-based MediaTek, told a shareholder meeting last month: “Intel, NXP and Qualcomm have more advanced technology than (companies in) Taiwan. They are continuing to invest in China. If Taiwan companies are restricted…they’ll be marginalized.”

He, and executives from other firms in the island state, want their government to relax its restrictions on investment in China, designed to protect the domestic industry by keeping skills and technologies out of the hands of Chinese firms. But these rules just make Taiwanese companies less competitive, argue critics, and do not prevent a brain drain to the mainland.

Taiwanese companies are starting to be allowed to invest in China – for instance, both TSMC and UMC have built fabs there.