Google may not have learned the lesson of its failed smartphone venture, and that of Microsoft. The search giant is rumored to be planning to buy a 35% stake in LG Electronics, which would make it the firm’s largest shareholder.
LG’s share price recently hit a 12-year low because of a lower than expected Q2 forecast and reports that it had sold only 250,000 units of its new flagship, the G4. The share price rebounded by 11% on rumors of a $2.3bn Google investment.
LG denied the reports, but its stock rose nonetheless, and certainly the Korean firm has been getting closer to Google in recent months. It provides premier models in the Nexus family of co-branded smartphones, whose main function is to showcase the latest Android developments. The LG Nexus 5 is set to receive the upcoming new OS release, Android M, during the third quarter.
Also, LG Display and Google recently announced an alliance around OLED TVs, apparently geared to a Nexus-like co-branding to promote Google TV on high end screens.
However, all this cooperation does not mean Google needs to own or control the hardware itself. LG needs the US firm’s support for its flagging smartphone and TV activities and so will, in effect, be a tame OEM – just as Nokia was for Microsoft once it opted to support Windows Phone. Microsoft’s mistake in deciding it needed to own the handsets as well as the software was clear in its results this week, as the write-off of its Nokia Devices drove it to its biggest quarterly loss ever.
Google, having sold its own Motorola smartphone unit to Lenovo, should take heed, though it is still not averse to buying hardware, from the Nest thermostats to the Boston Dynamics robots. But those products are in emerging segments where Google wants to create new categories – not in the saturating mobile and TV markets where LG has floundered in recent years.
In that context, Google’s real interest may be in LG Display – not just the TV cooperation, but in helping drive new mobile screen technologies. This is a critical area of differentiation for device and platform vendors, and has seen Qualcomm and Apple backing Japan’s Sharp, and of course, significant breakthroughs at Samsung. LG said in a regulatory filing last week that its Display affiliate would invest KRW1.05 trillion ($902m) in a new factory line to produce plastic OLED screens. These are particularly targeted at flexible displays for smartphones, smartwatches and other emerging device categories. LG already supplies plastic OLEDs for the Apple Watch.