Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 July 2015

Nokia and Cisco: very different fates for their SON acquisitions

Two major networks vendors, two SON (self-optimizing networks) acquisitions – with very different outcomes. Cisco is rumored to be slashing its RAN team, which includes its Intucell acquisition; while Nokia has already launched the first product since completing its takeover of Eden Rock.

Just two months after that deal was finalized, Nokia has unveiled the Nokia Eden-NET product, which integrates features from the Finnish vendor’s existing iSON Manager with Eden Rock’s existing Eden-NET. This sees the company making good on promises to acquire strategically important technologies to strengthen its LTE-Advanced and software-driven platforms, while strengthening its readiness for 5G and full virtualization.

Of course, the proposed takeover of Alcatel-Lucent is a giant, and risky, example of this quest for advanced technology, especially software, but the results of Nokia’s smaller deals are more immediate. When it bought most of the assets of multivendor SON specialist Eden Rock, it said its prey’s technologies were “highly complementary” with its own. At Mobile World Congress in February, Nokia unveiled a multivendor centralized SON platform called iSON Manager, which can be delivered as a hosted, cloud-based system within its CEM/OSS portfolio.

Peter Patomella, VP of customer experience management and OSS at the Finnish firm, said: “With this combination of capabilities, we will effectively address a key customer pain point – automated optimization of heterogenous networks in a multivendor environment.”

With the resulting converged solution, Nokia said it is offering an open framework in which operators can create their own SON modules and features. It also supports OSS interoperability with third party platforms as well as its own, as the OEMs start to recognize the need to offer vendor-independent software in order to compete with software and services specialists like Amdocs (which has made its own SON acquisitions in Actix and Celcite).

The more operators move towards implementing heterogeneous networks (HetNets), with large numbers of densely packed small cells or WiFi access points, the more critical it becomes to automate the planning and optimization of all those elements to ensure a high quality user experience. This is stimulating operator interest in SON, which replaces many of their manual processes when these become impractical for dense HetNets.

This was the driver behind Cisco’s purchase of Intucell in 2013, and arguably it had seized the real prize, given that the start-up’s technology was already deeply embedded in AT&T (a route into the US operator was seen as a significant motivation for Cisco). It seemed that the vendor was behaving highly strategically, snapping up key elements of an automated, small cell platform (it also bought small cell pioneer Ubiquisys) which could be complementary to its enterprise WiFi offerings in the short term, and give it a way into carrier HetNet business in the medium term.

But now, according to LightReading sources, Cisco is to lay off about half the staff of Ubiquisys and Intucell. At MWC, the firm announced a deal to resell another small cell platform, Spidercloud’s E-RAN, which is more specifically enterprise-focused than Ubiqusys/Intucell. This raised fears that the company would leave the Ubiquisys platform stranded, in an echo of its purchase of mobile broadband start-up Navini – another mishandled move into the 3GPP RAN world (a foreign country to Cisco).

The LightReading and Channel Register reports say that Ubiquisys struggled to move from “start-up mode to operational mode” within the huge and sales-driven Cisco machine. Cisco would only say that it “remains committed to driving innovations across our entire service provider mobility portfolio – including small cell technologies.” A spokesperson told the reporters that Cisco was responding to customer RFPs with a full portfolio of small cells – residential, small enterprise and large enterprise, with only the last one being Spidercloud-based. Cisco’s main activity in this area, of course, revolves around its dominant WiFi platform, but it has sought various ways to integrate cellular into that, including a ‘snap-on’ 3G/4G module for its Aironet access points.

Some of the leading lights of Ubiquisys have already turned up elsewhere. Former CTO Will Franks and CMO Keith Day, for instance, are at smart city start-up Telensa. However, that is normal practice for senior executives of an acquired firm, once an earn-out period has been completed, and job cuts may reflect the reorganization of resources around a more integrated and focused RAN unit, rather than a move to back away completely. Nevertheless, having spent $310m on Ubiquisys and $475m on Intucell two years ago now, Cisco would do well to emulate Nokia and start to show clear returns on its purchases. For now, Nokia’s superior understanding of the mobile RAN market, and the MNO customers, is showing through in the early HetNet world.