The US telecoms market is starting to look like a Depression-era dance marathon as immortalized in ‘They Shoot Horses Don’t They?’ The contenders are engaged in an apparently endless whirl of grouping and regrouping, seizing new partners as smaller players fall by the wayside. AT&T and Verizon, after several years of acquisitions, seem to have reached their fighting weight for now, and the action has shifted to the cablecos, while speculation about the ultimate role of Sprint, T-Mobile and Dish continues to swirl. Behind all this, of course, is the spectre of a brand new competitor, probably Google, which might throw everyone off their step.
Altice buys Cablevision, bringing France’s quad play economics to US
Perhaps the dominant theme of 2015, for the telecoms sector, has been the race to the quad play. French broadband operators Iliad and Altice have established themselves as disruptive fixed/mobile players at home, and are looking to repeat that elsewhere, notably the US, where the bundling model is still immature.
Iliad failed in talks to buy T-Mobile USA, but its rival is having better luck, and has agreed to buy its second US cableco in a few months, snapping up Cablevision, for $17.7bn to add to its previous $9.1bn purchase of Suddenlink. The brace of deals make Altice, overnight, the fourth largest US cableco with 4.6m customers in 20 states (unless Comcast or another firm makes a counterbid for Cablevision and its valuable operating territory around New York).
Cablevision passes around 5m premises and around 65% of its customers take triple play services. It has revenues of $6.53bn. The acquisition also includes the business services unit Lightpath, advertising sales division Cablevision Media Sales, the News 12 Networks, and the Newsday weekly and New York daily newspapers. We suspect that Drahi will sell these off himself subsequently to keep the costs of the deal down.
The deal for the smaller Suddenlink, signed earlier this year, signalled Altice’s interest in taking part in the ongoing consolidation of US telcos and cablecos. However, it backed away from talks with Time Warner Cable, subsequently snapped up by Charter Communications (after a proposd merger with Comcast fell through earlier this year).
Now it plans to pay $34.90 a share for the most disruptive and WiFi-driven of the US MSOs, and Cablevision. Unlike Comcast and others, which repeatedly flirt with acquiring their own cellular spectrum or network partners, Cablevision has remained steadfastly focused on using WiFi to underpin its wireless services. It was the most aggressive MSO in building out hotspots for its subscribers; and recently it announced a WiFi-only smartphone-based service called FreeWheel.
This has clear echoes of strategies which Altice has seen working well in France, where Iliad’s Free Mobile unit has harnessed its hotspots and homespots to achieve wide WiFi coverage. WiFi offload and WiFi-first services have reduced the strain on its cellular networks, thus enabling it to lower its cost of delivery and undercut its rivals’ mobile tariffs, sparking a price war and subsequent consolidation. Netherlands-based Altice was the beneficiary of that, buying up the second French MNO, SFR, to add to its Numericable unit. The two are now working on WiFi/cellular offerings to rival Free’s.
The same process of WiFi-driven disruption, wireless price wars and consequent consolidation is affecting the US, where smaller MNOs have been rapidly disappearing and the cablecos are now engaged in a series of mergers to achieve the scale to compete with Comcast, Verizon and AT&T in the multiplay arena.
Altice expects to finalize its Cablevision deal in the first half of next year and will finance it with a $14.5bn share issue, $3.3bn in cash and cash on hand in Cablevision.
In a recent interview with the Wall Street Journal, Altice CEO Patrick Drahi said that his vision was to take quad play bundles to the US, where the market is far less developed than in France and some other European countries.
What about Dish?
Dish Network remains the wild card in all this frantic M&A. It has a significant amount of spectrum following various acquisitions and auctions – 40 MHz in AWS-4, 25 MHz in AWS-3 (pending FCC clearance) and 10 MHz in 1.9 GHz PCS H block, primarily. However, it has always said that it needs a network partner to make its plan for an LTE-Advanced build-out economically viable, though its network (while initially geared to its own quad play) could potentially revive the disruptive wholesale-only idea once mooted by both Clearwire and LightSquared – especially if backed by a non-telco like Google.
Dish failed to buy either Clearwire or Sprint, losing out to Japan’s Softbank, and has been linked to T-Mobile and Verizon, especially since AT&T’s acquisition of its main satellite TV rival, DirecTV. However, Verizon’s CEO, Lowell McAdam, said this week that he was not interested in acquiring the whole of Dish, but had held discussions about its spectrum.
Verizon is taking a different approach from AT&T’s to building up its content business, centered on its AOL purchase and mobile-first (see separate item), and McAdam told a Goldman Sachs Communacopia conference that Dish’s satellite TV operations were “not consistent with a strategy of where we see the market going”.
However, he acknowledged: “We’ve had discussions about how we could provide [Dish chairman Charlie Ergen] with megabytes and how he could pay for it with spectrum.”
Dish expects to have various uncertainties about its spectrum ironed out by the end of the year. For instance the 3GPP is working to incorporate its AWS-4 spectrum into a new band that would also include AWS-1 and AWS-3, integrating those frequencies more smoothly into the LTE platform. Dish’s AWS-4 spectrum runs from 2000-2020 MHz (for uplink operations) and 2180-2200 MHz (for the downlink), though Dish is likely to convert the uplink portion into downlink.
Through its controversial designated entity partners, Dish acquired 702 AWS-3 licences for around $10bn in the most recent US auction, winning 25 MHz in total, with 13 MHz of that paired. The FCC has ruled that the entities do not qualify for the credits that it had offered to smaller bidders and so they, or Dish, must pay an additional $3.33bn.
Can Sprint resurrect its role as the friend of cable?
As cable and broadband providers in the US start to chase the quad play in earnest, they will be able to harness carrier-grade WiFi to keep costs down and undercut their mobile rivals, but they will not be able to avoid the wide area coverage, high mobility and assured QoS of the cellular networks in every circumstance – especially where the MNOs are also tappin ginto the lower costs of licence-exempt spectrum either with WiFi HetNets or 5 GHz LTE.
One outcome may be for the wireless-only and wireline-only players to pair off, as is happening in European markets like the UK (BT with EE) and France. The other will be closer ties – far richer and more exclusive relationships than classical MVNOs – between these two sides. In either case, that places the spotlight on Sprint and T-Mobile, the national spectrum/network owners which do not have fixed broadband and TV offerings. These could be prey for one of the large cablecos – Comcast, Charter/TWC, Cox or Altice/Cablevision (though the last of these is likely to stick to its heavily WiFi-driven approach). Or Sprint, in particular, could resurrect the role which was tantalizingly in its sights in 2008 – of being the wireless arm for all the major cablecos.
This notion was heavily discussed in the middle years of the last decade when Sprint and four cablecos (Comcast, TWC, Cox and BrightHouse) invested in Clearwire. The cable firms relied on a Sprint MVNO deal to add wireless options to their bundles, via their Pivot alliance; they pooled their licensed spectrum holdings with those of the MNO; and the Clearwire WiMAX roll-out seemed to promise a wholesale-oriented mobile broadband platform on which the MSOs could build more advanced services than those of Verizon and AT&T, in those pre-LTE days. There was even talk of each cableco deploying its own small cells, in dedicated areas of Clearwire’s 2.5 GHz TDD spectrum, to support its own differentiated experience.
None of those ideas was invalid, even if the technology choice eventually proved a dead end, and Sprint’s own management mistakes and internal conflicts ruined the potential of Clearwire. Now, with all that 2.5 GHz spectrum (100 MHz or more in most markets) being converted for use in Sprint’s triband Spark LTE services and its Next Generation Network, the same models could be revived. That would make the MNO, effectively, into a wireless arm for the collective cablecos, ensuring it a far more reliable revenue stream for its LTE investment than consumer services ever can.
Sprint’s potential role as the friend of cable seemed to have been scuppered when the Clearwire quartet defected to Verizon, signing MVNO and cross-selling deals and selling their own AWS spectrum to the giant. Since then, however, the Verizon/cableco deal has weakened and the MSOs, led by Comcast, have become aggressive in building a WiFi-led alternative. But, with the exception of Cablevision, they keep returning to the need for universal coverage and some access to cellular spectrum, so the logic of a Sprint tie-up is clear again.
It is clearer than for TMO, which has less plentiful capacity and less history of supporting wholesale partnerships, with all the conflicts of interest those can entail. Sprint has long been the most wholesale-oriented of the major US mobile players, and has a history of working with the cable sector. Even the MSOs’ WiFi-first plans do not need to be a deal-breaker since Sprint itself has been dabbling in low cost services that rely on WiFi, handing the user off to cellular only when there is no good WiFi signal in reach. Indeed, there has been speculation that one or more MSOs may launch Wi-Fi first via Sprint’s MVNO Scratch Wireless, which said last year that it was working on white label versions of its own service, potentially for adoption by cablecos. Such an arrangement could be the vital bridge to reunite Sprint and its former cable friends.
Success for such an alliance would depend on Sprint finally getting its network right, however. Ever since trying to pre-empt the others in ‘4G’ by using WiMAX instead of LTE, Sprint has had the most ambitious network plan – and the one which has delivered the fewest results. While TMO has been loud and disruptive based on far more limited LTE capacity and coverage, Sprint has been plugging away at its Network Vision plan – for a multi-technology platform which could play host to multiple networks as well as its own superfast 4G services. Beset by delays, and painful transitions for customers whose spectrum was being repurposed, Vision has been superceded by Next Generation Network, a new phase, mainly characterized by densification, under a new CTO.
CEO Marcelo Claure said in a recent interview that the new network would enable Sprint to play a disruptive role because it has so much spectrum. “We expect to be the number one network or number two network in every major market in the next 24 months. That’s my job. In real estate its ‘location, location, location’. In this industry, it’s ‘network, network, network’,” he said. “But people forget that to build a great network, you need spectrum. And there’s one thing that nobody can dispute – we have more spectrum than any other carrier on the planet.”
He is right that a great network is important again, differentiating the user experience in QoS-sensitive areas like streamed video, and particularly important when it comes to attracting wholesale customers with their own brands to protect. The new iPhone 6S provided an example of how much an advanced network could benefit a carrier, since it supports carrier aggregation. That means it will run at 2-3 times the speed on networks with that capability, as Sprint demonstrated in Denver, Colorado. But, while the iPhone may be a boost to the network experience, in contrast to its early days when it was the operator’s nightmare, Sprint only has CA implemented in Denver. For many observers, that epitomizes the frustration with a carrier that has high quality technology and spectrum, but repeatedly fails to execute effectively or on time.
“Sprint’s moving so slowly on network improvements that it’s not even funny,” Roger Entner, an analyst at Recon Analytics, said in an interview at last week’s CTIA conference. “Sprint has awesome assets and is utilizing them the least. As far as carrier aggregation, customers can’t really use it, except in Denver. They’ve been saying it will take two years to upgrade the network since 2005, so they have to do a lot more. If they quickly rolled out carrier aggregation nationwide, they would win the speed crown and nobody else could come close. Speed is everything.”
That speed is enabled by Sprint’s huge spectrum reserves which allow it to aggregate two 20 MHz channels side-by-side – whereas its rivals can only, with current holdings, combine one 20 MHz and one 5 MHz channel. CTO John Saw recently wrote in a company blog that Sprint has about 120 MHz of 2.5 GHz spectrum in 90 of the top 100 US cities and is now implementing CA in this band in 80 markets – but only in “select sites”. He wrote: “Cell sites with the capability are delivering double the capacity and speed in markets like Denver. And you ain’t seen nothing yet. Our engineers are already working on three-channel carrier aggregation, which will deliver even high capacities and speeds, just when the competitor’s networks are starting to congest.”
The danger for Sprint is that such bullish comments just reinforce the ‘always jam tomorrow, never jam today’ experience that investors and customers have suffered for the past eight years. Indeed, former CEO Dan Hesse said in a recent interview: “We knew it would be difficult, but it was even more difficult than any of us had anticipated. Unfortunately, there was no playbook. No wireless company in the world had done something so radical and so aggressive in order to build a great network at the end.”
Saw insists there is a new culture taking over at Sprint and that the great network is now on the horizon. The current densification will “not be a traditional slow and expensive build”, he promised. Instead, the firm will launch new sites, mainly small ones, precisely where they are needed to have an instant effect on QoS. “This will be a progressive build that improves the customer experience as each new site comes on air,” he wrote in his blog post. “We’ll be extremely surgical and efficient, leveraging big data and network diagnostics to determine the optimal deployment of each small cell down to the street corner level.”
This echoed Claure’s comments on the operator’s most recent earnings call, when he said: “In the past, our engineers would design based on theoretical propagation models, but today, there are so many more tools available to enable precision execution.”
Saw did not say exactly how many small cells Sprint will add, but said the plan is “to initially deploy tens of thousands of small cells, with the potential to increase that deployment over time.” However, the macro layer is far from complete. Sprint plans “thousands” of new macro sites, and almost all its existing macrocells will be upgraded to support all three of its LTE bands – 800 MHz, 1.9 GHz and 2.5 GHz – while the 2.5 GHz footprint will be further expanded, alongside “improved LTE coverage with techniques like carrier aggregation and beamforming”. These are moves which the company has been talking about since the initiation of Network Vision, and many analysts are concerned that progress has not been faster.
While a Sprint network partnership would be the best way forward for the cablecos – assuming the MNO gets its network on track – the picture will be different if one of the MSOs wants a wireless company of its own, not just a joint venture. Softbank seems to have got over its wobbles of earlier this year about its high risk investment, and is indicating it no longer wants to sell Sprint – indeed, it is now lending valuable support and input based on its own experience of dense network roll-outs in both FDD and TDD spectrum.
So T-Mobile would clearly be the easier buy, given that its majority parent, Deutsche Telekom, has made no secret of its willingness to sell, at the right price. The Altice deal sparked new speculation that TMO would become an acquisition target, with BTIG analyst Walter Piecyk writing in a blog post: “We believe T-Mobile could be a primary acquisition target of cable operators and today are increasing our price target on T-Mobile to $50 from $42.”
Altice itself might repeat its French pattern and go after a mobile network of its own – TMO, formerly a target for rival Iliad, or Dish would be most likely. Drahi said at this week’s Goldman Sachs Communacopia conference that he could envisage owning a cellular network in the US, but that would happen “not next week”.
Comcast and Charter Communications could also be in the frame for TMO. Charter’s largest shareholder, Liberty Global chairman John Malone, has also hinted at interest in a wireless arm to complement the WiFi-heavy TWC purchase. But as Piecyk noted, “Malone has also echoed [Altice’s] view that the US wireless industry must first experience some incremental pricing pain before acquisitions can occur.” But while the cable sector may regard US wireless pricing – which is among the highest in the world – as too high, ARPU trends have actually gone up in recent months after a period of price war.
The timing is tough though – the cable sector is likely to end up with three major players but there are only two wireless companies realistically on offer (plus Dish), and even Sprint may not be on the table. So the game will be for the cablecos to predict when a rival might make its move and try to pre-empt that – or, given their regional focus, they could once again join forces and make a collective bid or joint venture. Indeed, if quad play is the main goal – as it probably is for Altice – that approach would make sense, as none of the cablecos has very wide wireline coverage (only 5% of the US territory is covered by Cablevision and Suddenlink, for instance).
“Even if the wireless industry struggles, can any of these cable operators afford to wait on the assumption/hope that their fellow cable operators will also wait or agree to join together in a joint wireless effort in the future?” Piecyk said.
Some may choose to stick with WiFi. WiFi-first, and even WiFi-only, as Cablevision has shown, can be disruptive to the established cellcos, by addressing the budget end of the market (where TMO and Sprint have seen most of their growth in recent years) with far lower costs. The success or otherwise of Cablevision’s daring Freewheel WiFi-only offer will be closely watched and will influence future wireless decisions. But it remains true that a cableco with a mobile network would unbalance the MSO segment, securing far more service options, especially at the high-QoS end, than its rivals.
Comcast remains far more cautious than Cablevision about its WiFi-first potential, even though it has by far the largest footprint of hotspots and homespots, now totalling 11m plus those available via the CableWiFi roaming arrangement. At the Goldman Sachs event, CEO Brian Roberts would only say: “We have relationships that can be put together in new business constructs that we have not heretofore done.”
So far, the cableco has not even launched services with its 2011 MVNO deal with Verizon, which is currently being renegotiated, nor from its historical relationship with Sprint (which recently confirmed that it still has “wireless arrangements with Comcast tied to their original investment in Clearwire”).
“We are hopeful that as people make decisions, they are going to want our WiFi and our relationship, our broadband, as part of that,” Roberts said. “And if we can enhance that by someday having an offering, we will see.”
TMO itself is watching carefully. Its CEO John Legere said on the firm’s recent earnings call: “It’s just logical … the consumer says, ‘Hey, wait a minute. I have Comcast and I have T-Mobile. Why don’t these guys do something together to provide a seamless set of capabilities to us?’ … I think that will be, in several years, a big question of not if, but when, and I look forward to that as well, I think it provides great options for our customers.”
Google breathes down Verizon’s neck in new RAN approaches
In many ways, Sprint’s discussions of its new network are already sounding old-fashioned. New technologies in the RAN, better network planning – the modern MNO of 2015 is talking about a whole new range of techniques to improve capacity and efficiency, from dynamic spectrum tools to virtualizing the access network.
Verizon and AT&T are both very public in their visions for the future economics of a wireless network operator, pointing to the flexibility and wide range of services that a multiband, highly virtualized platform, harnessing many sources of spectrum, could enable. They may sometimes be concerned, however, that many of their killer weapons of the future are also being developed by Google, which is poised to disrupt the wireless landscape even more – not, probably, by building a national network of its own, but by harnessing new tools in order to turn the MNOs’ build-outs to its own advantage.
In the past week, for instance, both Google and Verizon have been revealed to be testing LTE-Unlicensed, self-optimizing networks and dynamic spectrum selection, all of them techniques with important potential for helping operators – whether traditional or disruptive – to squeeze the most out of the airwaves available to them.
The flexible use of both licensed and unlicensed spectrum will be a hallmark of future mobile economics moving into the 5G era. Google has provided some early hints of what that future could hold with the launch of Google Fi, a WiFi-first service that keeps costs low by relying mainly on unlicensed frequencies, and which – unlike other such offerings – does not rely on a single MVNO deal for its cellular component. Instead, it uses a proprietary ‘always best connected’ protocol to move users between Sprint’s and T-Mobile’s networks, effectively sidelining the MNO entirely from the value proposition while giving Google increased flexibility to manage the user experience.
Most of Google’s attempts to enhance the value of unlicensed spectrum in the wireless model – thus devaluing the MNOs’ licences as competitive assets – have focused on WiFi. It has built a hotzone around its Silicon Valley headquarters and created a system of business homespots managed from the cloud, for instance. But it is technology neutral, as its support for WiMAX and Clearwire – before the latter became a tool of Sprint – indicated. Now it is interested in LTE-Unlicensed, which is usually perceived as a weapon for the LTE operators themselves. Rajeev Suri, CEO of Nokia, said on the most recent earnings call that his firm is working with Google on tests of LTE-U, though not in its usual 5 GHz band but in 3.5 GHz. “Given our expertise in 3.5 GHz technologies and our approach to small cells, we believe there is great opportunity to be had using a shared access approach,” he said.
Though Google has expressed concerns about LTE-U’s potential negative impact on WiFi in 5 GHz, the 3.5 GHz band is a different matter. Part of this spectrum is being opened up by the FCC for shared access and could be a less controversial location for LTE’s various unlicensed options (LTE-U, LTE-LAA and LTE-LWA) than 5 GHz, widely regarded as WiFi’s natural home. T-Mobile has told the FCC that LTE-LAA is compatible with WiFi and should be considered as the FCC adopts rules for the 3.5 GHz band.
Google has been a major force behind sharing schemes in the US 3.5 GHz band and believes such a system could set valuable precedents for more flexible approaches to spectrum in other bands and other countries (its lobbying for access to the TV white spaces spectrum, and its creation of an anti-interference database there, is another example). Earlier this month, Google demonstrated a Spectrum Access System it had built. This uses software running on Google infrastructure that is capable of dynamically managing the relationships between the three proposed tiers of users in 3.5 GHz – federal and non-federal incumbents, Priority Access licensees, and General Authorized Access licensees.
Such indications suggest the operators may not have 5 GHz LTE to themselves. The US operators are some of the most enthusiastic supporters, partly because they could use LTE-U – an implementation which is already standardized in Release 12, whereas the other versions will have to wait for Release 13. LTE-U can only be used in countries, like the US, which do not insist on ‘listen before talk’ mechanisms to avoid interference in 5 GHz.
AT&T’s SVP of wireless network architectures, Tom Keathley, said in a recent interview that his firm would trial LTE-U later this year or early in 2016, although he also hinted that, if there were any issues with WiFi coexistence, AT&T might wait for LAA, which will incorporate listen before talk.
T-Mobile says it will deploy LAA in 5 GHz spectrum in 2016 and is already testing LTE-U, based on small cells provided by Alcatel-Lucent. Because of the power limitations in the 5 GHz band, LTE-U and –LAA will be almost entirely confined to small cells. Verizon has said it will deploy LTE-U in 2015 in both the 5 GHz and 3.5 GHz bands and is trialling small cells from Samsung and others.
These moves to shift seamlessly between licensed and unlicensed spectrum, and engage in sharing in many bands, are just baby steps towards a fully dynamic future. Google has talked for years about its vision of a huge pool of spectrum, operated as a wholesale resource, with thousands of service providers accessing airwaves just when they need them, with fees calculated on a pay-as-you-go basis or using a marketplace mechanism. Verizon, to judge by a patent filing made public this week, also plans to help drive the industry in these long term directions. Its invention relates to “dynamic auctioning of unused network capacity” and would allow service providers to sell unused capacity to subscribers for a pre-determined amount of time.
“Systems and methods described herein enable wireless service providers to identify, offer, and monetize unused network capacity that would otherwise be wasted,” the filing says. The auction system would allow customers to change QoS levels dynamically for a short time, through a self-service interface – for instance, a subscriber on a low level service might want to upgrade temporarily for an important videoconference. Even more interesting models could be envisaged using this approach for MVNO customers, which could support the sort of model Google envisages.
The filing continues: “At the network layer, adjusting Differentiated Services Code Point (DSCP) markings may be used to control packet flow. In another example, at the data link layer altering 802.pq priority markings may be used to adjust packet flow. Additionally, in the RAN, QoS class identifiers may be adjusted to control packet flow.”
Improving capacity at affordable cost is not just a matter of harnessing different spectrum resources more efficiently. The network itself must behave differently, and one of the critical tools for MNOs will be SON (self-optimizing networks) which will make dense small cell roll-outs viable by automating most of the planning and optimization work, and will enable carriers to make far more effective use of their capacity.
Verizon said last week that it had completed trials of SON systems from Cisco and Ericsson prior to starting on densification using small cells and distributed radio technologies. But here too, Google may be hard on its heels. Recently, the company advertised for a wireless systems engineer with SON experience, to help create “novel network management systems, in particular, SON” for LTE systems. This sees Google seeking to understand and shape the future of the cellular platform, not just WiFi, as all the wireless access technologies start to converge in the prelude to 5G. SON and similar techniques will be important for Google to optimize the experience of its services on wireless devices – Facebook is taking a similar interest in mobile RAN tools – and if it looks to extend its Fi concept towards a far broader wireless platform, which could ultimately deliver its long-held vision of the fully dynamic, on-demand network.