Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 February 2020

USA launches new two-pronged attack on Huawei

Although the US Department of Commerce has not fully enforced its ‘entity list’ rules, imposed last April against Huawei, it is already considering more stringent measures to limit the Chinese firm’s ability to buy chips from US companies.

The entity list forces any US company to apply for a special licence in order to sell to Huawei, though vendors complaint of being caught in limbo – there have been  postponements of the deadline to enforce the rules, but those applying for licences say none has been awarded yet. Now the DoC, according to the Wall Street Journal, wants to add to the isolation of Huawei from US technology by expanding the existing ‘foreign direct product rule’. That restricts any foreign company’s use of US technology for military or national security products, but now the DoC wants to expand the rule, in Huawei’s case, to any products it might make using American semiconductors.

As with the entity list, this could backfire in two ways. One, it will wipe out the revenues from one of the USA’s biggest exports to China, semiconductors. And two, it will increase the determination of Huawei, and of the Chinese government, to end any reliance on US technology and to invest heavily in building a homegrown chip powerhouse – which, in time, could threaten US firms like Intel and Qualcomm on a global basis.

The rules would also create problems for foundries, even in China itself, since they rely on a lot of equipment made in America, and could be forced to choose between retaining Huawei as a customer, and keeping access to American technology. Taiwan’s TSMC, the world’s largest foundry, is said to generate over 10% of its annual revenues from Huawei’s chip design subsidiary, HiSilicon – but the USA’s Apple and Qualcomm are also leading customers.

Huawei CEO Ren Zhengfei claims the ban has not prevented the firm from obtaining components for its network equipment. It stockpiled key components ahead of bans taking effect; it has been reorganizing its supply chain to rely more heavily on its own inhouse developments or on suppliers in China or allied nations; and anyway, it claims  many US suppliers have got around the restrictions by exporting from offshore subsidiaries.

The DoC wants to squeeze Huawei still further in other ways too. Currently, chip firms can usually get out of requiring a special licence to sell to the Chinese firm, if they can prove that less than 25% of the value of the end product would be American-made. Now, that threshold is proposed to be reduced to 10%.

And while the DoC works on new regulations, the government has added a new weapon to its attack on Huawei, with the FBI and Department of Justice (DoJ) filing 16 charges, including racketeering, against the company. Some charges related to alleged violations of the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) law, which has mainly been used against organized crime in the past – for instance, against the Gambino and Lucchese families.

The allegations say that Huawei and some of its affiliates have used confidential agreements with US companies to access trade secrets and misuse intellectual property, over the course of two decades. There are also some other allegations of industrial espionage.

Most of the indictment is based on repeating accusations that have been made in the past about alleged technology and IP theft by Huawei. As Huawei said in its response: “These charges do not reveal anything new. They are based largely on resolved civil disputes from the last 20 years that have been previously settled, litigated, and in some cases, rejected by federal judges and juries.”

Examples include:

  • Stealing source code and manuals for routers from ‘company 1’ in 2003 – this almost certainly relates to a legal battle with Cisco in that year, which led to Huawei modifying its products the following year to remove Cisco IP.
  • Violating an NDA with ‘company 4’ in 2009. That appears to relate to another lawsuit that was subsequently settled, this time from Motorola.
  • Engaging in a scheme to “misappropriate robot technology” in 2012 or 2013 from ‘company 5’. That is likely to be T-Mobile USA, which won a $4.8m judgement against Huawei in 2017 over accusations of stealing IP associated with a robotic phone testing system.

Another multi-page section rehashes the accusation that Huawei has illegally traded with Iran and North Korea, and that some of these alleged activities constitute bank fraud. These were at the heart of the arguments that originally led the USA to place Huawei on its entity list last spring, and to arrest its CFO in Canada the previous December.

In response to further claims that Huawei has ‘back doors’ into telecoms networks round the world, which can be used for Chinese government spying, the company was more robust in its language, saying in a statement: “As evidenced by the Snowden leaks, the United States has been covertly accessing telecom networks worldwide, and spying on other countries for quite some time. The report by the Washington Post this week about how the CIA used an encryption company to spy on other countries for decades is yet additional proof. US allegations of Huawei using lawful interception are nothing but a smokescreen – they don’t adhere to any form of accepted logic in the cybersecurity domain. Huawei has never and will never covertly access telecom networks, nor do we have the capability to do so.”

The Chinese firm then pointed out that it implements lawful intercept standards embedded into standards such as the 3GPP TS 33.107 specification for 3G networks, and TS 33.128 for 5G, as do all vendors, but added: “This is where Huawei’s obligations with regards to lawful interception end.”

Indeed, the Wall Street Journal’s story, which cited the usual unnamed sources, did admit that no concrete evidence of the back doors had been found.

Huawei added: “For quite a while, the US government has been using the strength of an entire nation to come after a private company. It has used every tool at its disposal … to disrupt our normal business operations. Rarely has this kind of attack been seen before in history. The US Department of Justice’s new charges against Huawei are part of this campaign. This is political persecution, plain and simple.”

In its response to the DoJ’s new charges, Huawei also argued that, if just being accused of IP theft was enough to make a company into a criminal enterprise, indictable under RICO laws, Apple or Samsung could also be indicted. It wrote: “According to public records, from 2009 to 2019, Apple was involved in 596 intellectual property lawsuits and Samsung in 519. Huawei was involved in 209. The US Department of Justice has insisted on filing a criminal lawsuit against Huawei over the kind of civil intellectual property disputes that are common across the industry. The US government’s sole purpose for this is to attack, discredit, and smear the reputation of Huawei’s leading technologies. They want to damage Huawei’s competitive edge in the global market.”