Just when we thought the long saga of T-Mobile USA’s bid to acquire Sprint was almost over, TMO’s parent Deutsche Telekom is reported to want to renegotiate the price.
According to the UK’s Financial Times, DT thinks it should pay less for Sprint than was originally agreed, because the fourth US MNO is less financially robust than it was two years ago, when the deal was first mooted. The reports surfaced only days after TMO had put out a triumphant statement that the last legal or regulatory obstacle – a lawsuit by a group of states, trying to block a deal they claimed would reduce consumer choice – had been removed when a federal judge decided in favor of the operators.
The FT’s sources, however, say that DT is concerned about the fall in Sprint’s share price, and various business setbacks that have befallen it, over the past two years. But they also indicate that Masayoshi Son, chairman of Sprint’s current owner, Softbank of Japan, is unwilling to negotiate.
Under the original terms, the deal will leave Sprint’s shareholders with one-third of the ‘New T-Mobile’ entity, but while TMO’s earnings per share have risen by about 20% since that was agreed, Sprint’s have remained flat. Sprint’s shares were down nearly 6%, to $8.10, on the reports. They leapt by 78% on February 11, after the court ruling against the states, but were trading at just $4.80 when the week began, down from $5.27 two years ago. By contrast, TMO’s share price has risen by 45% over the two-year period and rose another 13% last week, to $95.67.
Some of the arguments the two US operators and their parents have used to justify their merger to antitrust regulators could, ironically, give weight to DT’s case – they effectively said that Sprint would not remain a fully viable competitor if left on its own (though Sprint’s managers did not take that line), and put a strong case that the combined entity would be the only one capable of providing a full alternative to Verizon and AT&T, and building out 5G at the optimal pace.
Going further than that, Judge Victor Marrero, the federal judge who ruled against the states, implied in his ruling that Sprint would not survive without the merger, writing:
“While Sprint has made valiant attempts to stay competitive in a rapidly developing and capital-intensive market, the overwhelming view both within Sprint and in the wider industry is that Sprint is falling farther and farther short of the targets it must hit to remain relevant as a significant competitor.”
Such comments certainly helped to get the proposed deal over the line, but could also reinforce DT’s argument that it should no longer be paying full price for a declining asset. Further delays will prolong uncertainty for many parties – for Nokia and Ericsson, both of which are suppliers to the two MNOs, and both of which said the long review process had hit their US sales figures in the most recent quarter; Dish, whose plans to roll out nationwide 5G depend on getting divested customers and spectrum from Sprint as a condition of the merger; and of course, US consumers and businesses, waiting to see what their 5G options will be.