Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 February 2020

USA vs EU to decide Amazon’s smart thermostat acquisition

By Rafi Cohen

Last week, Riot observed that Tado and Ecobee were clear frontrunners in the painfully slow race to become Amazon’s smart thermostat. Ecobee edged slightly ahead in our minds, mainly because it offered a smoother acquisition, with Alexa heavily integrated into many of its offerings. This week we decided to zoom out further, looking into the utility partnerships held by both companies. When compared with Google’s Nest utility partnerships, the individual advantages of both companies became clear.

Ecobee’s links with utilities seem to be entirely in North America, while Tado’s are far better established in Europe. Whether Amazon acquires either ultimately depends on exactly where it feels compelled to take on Google. Riot Research’s Smart Home Devices Forecast 2019-2023, compiled last year, shows that North America’s smart home device market is a fair way ahead of Europe’s and will remain so for the next 5 years.

The forecast found that by 2024, out of a global projected global total of 1.33bn smart home devices, North America will have 560.8mn devices (42%), while Europe will have 384.9mn (29%). Europe is still a considerable contributor, so there is no reason Amazon could not acquire both in order to maximize the competition it poses to Nest in both regions.

If Amazon decides that it wants to compete against Google in the US, then Ecobee is a necessary acquisition. Many of Ecobee’s official utility partners are regional competitor’s to firms that are partnered with Nest, giving Amazon a chance to compete face to face. Furthermore, there are some regions where Ecobee appear to be ahead of Google.

Tado, on the other hand, is well connected in Europe, while it appears Ecobee has no links to utilities on the continent – although we have yet to receive its full list of partners.  Tado provided us a list of 11 European utilities with which it has some form of partnership, as well as several smart home and domestic appliance companies.

Ecobee already has a footing in Texas, where Nest is partnered with United Cooperative Services and CoServ Electric, both of which serve the North of the state, as well as Reliant, which provides many urban areas. One notable exception on Nest’s map is Austin, where Austin Energy is partnered with Ecobee.

Another potential frontier for Amazon to rile up Google is the North West of the country. Avista, one of Ecobee’s official utility partners, provides energy to areas of Washington, Idaho and Oregon. Operating nearby are Rocky Mountain Power and Vectren, both of which became Nest partners in 2016.

There are also some regions where, surprisingly, Ecobee seems to be better footed than Nest. For instance, in the North East of the US. Ecobee has partnerships with National Grid (which has that Centrica-Hive link) and Northeast Utilities, which collectively operate in New York, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire. Although not a utility, another official partner is Efficiency Maine, an initiative to improve grid efficiency in the state. Nest, however, appears to have no partnerships with utilities in the North East.

Ecobee also has a far better hold on California, perhaps the most important US market, with four official utility partners as oppose to Nest’s one. These are Southern California Edison, SoCalGas, San Diego Gas & Electric and Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E).

PG&E is the one utility where both Nest and Ecobee are on one another’s turf. As part of Nest’s partnership with San Francisco-based energy distribution firm, Leap, all PG&E customers have been offered Nest Hub if they sign up for the Rush Hour Rewards program. No doubt Amazon will relish the opportunity to compete with Nest among the same customer base of a single utility.

Among Nest’s other partnerships in the US are Evergy (East Kansas and West Missouri), Commonwealth Edison (North Illinois), Santee Cooper (South Carolina), and Georgia Power.

If Amazon does acquire Ecobee, such a financial boost will likely inspire far more utility partnerships. In 2016, two years after the $3.2bn acquisition by Google, Nest reached the milestone of holding partnerships with over 50 energy providers.

Across the pond, Tado has partnerships with many companies that collectively operate across Western Europe, and much of East and Central Europe. These are SSE, E.ON, Ovo, Naturgy, Essent, Octopus, Iren Mercato, Enovos and Vattenfall. Tado also has partnerships in Romania with Engie, as well as Czech conglomerate CEZ, which supplies much of Central and Eastern Europe, reaching as far as Turkey.

As mentioned last week, Tado’s versatility in being able to adapt to 95% of domestic heating appliances in Europe would make it ideal for Amazon to conquer the continent.

Tado revealed they currently had no partnerships with North American utilities, although did indicate that this could change. Amazon could certainly provide the muscle necessary to achieve this, but we can’t see why they would when Ecobee have already done much of the legwork.

At present, Amazon does have some utility partnerships, but these are mainly using the Alexa voice assistant to perform mundane tasks such as paying bills. If Amazon wants a keystone part of electricity infrastructure, a smart thermostat is a necessary acquisition.

High value, mission critical applications such as smart thermostats are one of the few smart home device markets which won’t be flooded with cheap products. Whichever Amazon chooses will become an emblem of its role in the smart home, so its unsurprising it’s taken its time.

Another benefit offered by Ecobee, as noted last week, is a far more seamless installation than Tado, which requires a scheduled visit. Ecobee’s quick self-installation would click far better with Amazon’s brand of convenience and efficiency.