There’s two ways to view Wyze; the first is that it is a leader, bringing properly smart capabilities at previously impossible price points, and the second being that it’s a shameless reseller of cheap Chinese gear (usually Xiaomi) that does mild tweaks to the firmware. Until now, we’ve definitely been in the former camp, but its decision to launch a wearable has confused us.
A few years ago, there was a vision that the smart home would be able to track its occupants via smartphones and wearables, picking up on Bluetooth signals to know where people were and then trigger behaviors accordingly. Now, the interaction is most frequently voice, with a user shouting commands and questions to a smart speaker, that is effectively blind to how occupants are actually using the home.
In the tracking vision, there would in fact be some level of intelligence in the smart home hubs, as they would have to process incoming location data and then make decisions on that information. Now, with voice, the smart home hubs are simply an interface for some cloud-based AI tool, which parses the input, thinks a little bit, and then spits out an answer, which then filters through the cloud-to-cloud integrations between the voice provider and the smart home device brand in question, which then kicks off the action.
This is not a ‘smart’ process, and nor is the way that routines or scenes are added and then acted upon. People don’t like using their smartphones to control smart home gear, and the complaint that they have to have a folder of apps on their phones in order to navigate their devices is proof of this. The smart speaker sort of solves that problem, but it is not in any fashion ‘smart,’ in the way that it can find and automate integrations between these devices.
Wearables simply don’t fix that problem – they don’t add anything to the table, in this regard. And so, Wyze’s decision to launch a fitness tracker with Amazon Alexa capabilities is a waste of time, if the goal is creating an actually smart home. We have long-maintained that the key device is a light that integrates two-way audio capabilities, with some kind of occupancy sensing capability. That way, a whole home could be covered by a low-power network capability, with two-way voice services to intercom and speak to these voice platforms, as well as a way to track how people move through the home, so that you can actually create some level of ‘smart’ capabilities.
But our shouts have been ignored. There are a few companies that have such devices on the market, but none of them have gained traction, and the rise of the cheap small-form-factor speakers means that they have become the preferred solution for adding more coverage to a house.
So, sure, a wearable is a good idea for a company that sells consumer electronics, especially if it conforms to what we would expect from Wyze – chiefly, being considerably cheaper than flagship rivals, while being much better in the user experience terms than its similarly priced competition. But in terms of advancing the smart home concept forward, we are not at all enthusiastic.
“We haven’t talked much publicly about this product yet. Wyze Band is a wrist-wearable smart home assistant and activity tracker. Wyze Band will allow you to control Wyze devices with a tap and using Alexa Built-in, any number of Alexa-enabled devices. It also tracks steps, heart rate, and sleep. Wyze Band just completed a round of hardware testing,” reads a company blog post.
Beta testing will be complete soon, and then Wyze will open up the wearable to early adopters, in much the same way it has done for its cameras, lights, plugs, sensors, and locks. Based on an FCC filing, it will offer ‘a jogging app, alarms, weather, step counter, sleep tracker, heart rate sensor, side-mounted mic array, and a touchscreen.’ There’s no mention of pricing, or availability, and Wyze seems unlikely to launch this outside of the US.