Some operators see open industry initiatives like the O-RAN Alliance as a chance to encourage a broad base of suppliers, and contribute knowledge to the common pool via open source cooperation. Others see them mainly as a way to reduce inhouse development cost while reducing reliance on major suppliers – and indeed, putting pressure on them to reduce prices.
UK incumbent BT seems to fall into the latter camp. Its chief architect, Neil McRae, told FierceWireless that its membership of the O-RAN Alliance is mainly justified by the access it gains to the group’s work on next generation MIMO antenna arrays. He said: “When you look at O-RAN it’s still not clear to me that’s there’s a really strong single direction for the parties involved … O-RAN for us is a way of getting access to some of the radio capabilities in MIMO so we can use some algorithms to get much more capacity from a MIMO platform.”
This is part of an inhouse project to develop an ‘Ultra MIMO’ radio for 5G. The aim is to use the capabilities of Massive MIMO, but enhance performance still further using custom algorithms, signal processing and interference management. These are being developed internally to enhance the radio/antennas BT buys on the market, and so to give its next generation 5G network a clear differentiation.
McRae said in the interview: “Ericsson and Nokia are fantastic partners. We also use Huawei, also a fantastic partner. But we feel like we need more choice and capability. Our goal is to work with O-RAN and others to drive next requirements in radio technology to ultimately give us more capacity.”
BT also sees open alliances as a way to broaden the ecosystem, and it has incubated three generations of start-ups, focused on new ways to deploy networks, under Telecom Infra Project’s TEAC (TIP ecosystem acceleration centers) program. But despite being one of the most active telcos in the early days of migrating telecoms functions to OpenStack, it is now cautious about full network virtualization – perhaps partly because its early moves in that direction came with very high inhouse skills costs to integrate the new systems.
McRae said BT was not “religious” about virtualization for its own sake and that this could introduce more complexity to operations, as could multivendor networks. He added: “Today I talk to my supplier and they resolve it. In a disaggregated network, I have to talk to more than one supplier. I have to have a programmer on my own staff to de-bug it. We’ve got a lot to learn in how to operate the infrastructure.”
And he sounded almost heretical, at a time when many operators are talking about fully disaggregated, multivendor networks, when he said that BT’s cloud-native 5G core will come from a single supplier. “In cost terms, do we see any benefits of disaggregation in the mobile core? No, we see the opposite,” he said. “It’s more costly to run and with greater likelihood of problems.”