Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 March 2020

T-Mobile USA is assessing O-RAN to help achieve 5G merger goals

Now that T-Mobile USA’s merger with Sprint looks set to be finalized within two months, the company can start to discuss, publicly, the challenging process of combining two very different networks, and delivering the many 5G promises the companies made to justify their marriage to regulators. One approach may be to adopt O-RAN architectures to try to reduce the cost of migrating two networks to a common 5G system and expanding this rapidly to compete with AT&T.

The two operators have very different histories and cultures when it comes to their mobile networks. Sprint has been more focused on engineering and on bold technical decisions, although that has backfired in recent years as it has gone through some unnecessarily complex and expensive network migrations which have hit profitability.

TMO is less precious about being seen to be cutting edge and is more inclined to opt for well-proven, well-priced solutions which can be deployed relatively quickly and easily. However, to deliver the 5G speeds, services and coverage it promised – as it argued that a combined entity would be a better competitor for AT&T and Verizon than two weaker ones – it will need to combine Sprint’s hugely valuable 2.5 GHz spectrum, and its dense 4G/5G network, into its own coverage-focused 5G roll-out in 600 MHz. It also has some millimeter wave assets and its own LTE network to consider.

When the merger was originally proposed in April 2018, TMO promised to invest $40bn over three years to combine the two networks and achieve a 5G platform that would provide nationwide average speeds of 450 Mbps.

One way to help achieve that at affordable cost, which was not available two year ago, is to adopt an O-RAN architecture. Karri Kuoppamak, TMO’s VP of network development and strategy, told LightReading that the operator is doing technology due diligence on O-RAN “to be able to quantify and understand its benefits relative to the classical network architecture. Where it makes sense and provides some benefits, we will be looking at potentially implementing it.”

He added: “As a company we’ve always embraced and supported open interfaces. That’s what this industry is based on. We already have a network in place today, and so you have to also consider where in the network and how open RAN might provide benefits over what’s in place today.”

TMO will no doubt have its eyes on Rakuten’s claims that it could deploy a 5G network with 40% lower capex and 30% lower opex by adopting a combination of cloud-native and open architectures. But those claims are yet to be validated, and the technology is immature. It is one thing for a greenfield provider, whose network vendors are eager to help enable, to adopt new platforms – far harder for an established operator with not one but two legacy networks to integrate.

Closer to home, TMO will also have its eye on Dish Network, another greenfield mobile operator which has said it will adopt the Rakuten template and reduce its costs by deploying open and cloud-native architectures, including a 5G Standalone RAN with 5G core, from day one.

On Dish’s earnings call last month, chairman Charlie Ergen said: “Rakuten is important in the sense that we’ve learned a lot from them, but they’re really the first company to start embracing kind of an O-RAN open architecture system, and it’s been pretty incredible the amount of progress they made in 18 months.” He added: “It’s always a little easier to be the second person, not the first person. They’re going to get a lot more arrows in the back than hopefully we will.”

Rakuten has suffered inevitable setbacks during its ambitious journey, including the challenges of deploying systems from many vendors (about a score in all), many of those offering products that had not been implemented at scale by anyone else. Tuning up cloud infrastructure for demanding functions like virtualized RAN and ensuring end-to-end orchestration are among the processes which will certainly have used up a great deal of the operator’s inhouse and supplier skills and resources.

This makes the Rakuten roll-out very far from being a blueprint for others. Indeed, in a research note to clients, Wall Street analysts at New Street Research wrote that the MNO’s vRAN was “not generating the cost disruption expected” because it has been more difficult to build than expected. “While macrocell build is back on track we think, the company is far behind their initial target of 100,000 microcells at launch,” the analysts wrote. “This means their own network capacity is lagging their initial plan.”

They added: “As we expected, vRAN works and we still see Rakuten creating value through its mobile entry, but the risk of Rakuten proving unable to provide a service at a low enough price that gains material numbers of customers is rising.”

Dish has set aside between $250m and $500m this year for its 5G build-out, which will kick off once the Sprint/TMO merger is completed – a condition of that merger was that Sprint would divest its Boost prepaid brand and customer base to Dish, along with some spectrum and site assets, and the satellite TV player would receive a favorable MVNO arrangement from ‘New T-Mobile’ to fill the gaps while it builds its own 5G network. The thinking was to make Dish – which has a patchwork of spectrum but has never rolled out a network on any scale – viable as a fourth national MNO, and mitigate any reduction in consumer choice as a result of the merger.

Dish continues to maintain that it will spend only $10bn in total to build 5G network across the USA, though many Wall Street observers are sceptical.

Indosat Ooredoo pledges support for O-RAN:

On the other side of the world, the latest recruit to the O-RAN brigade is Indosat Ooredoo of Indonesia.

It plans to conduct trials of open RAN technology in remote parts of the dispersed island nation, working with the GSMA and with Telecom Infra Project (TIP), both of which have initiatives to help bring mobile connectivity to underserved areas using new open architectures.

Indosat also plans to set up a TIP Community Lab in Indonesia in the second quarter, in which TIP members and Indonesian operators will be able to test products.

“Indosat Ooredoo has a similar vision with the government to create an effective and equitable digital ecosystem throughout Indonesia and encourage the emergence of local players,” said Ahmad Al-Neama, CEO of the operator.

“We hope this collaboration will accelerate the creation of a healthier industry and improve the digital economy and better life for the people of Indonesia.”

The company’s parent has not yet announced any O-RAN plans in its home market of Qatar, though Etisalat, another operator in the Gulf region of the Middle East, is deploying O-RAN systems in the United Arab Emirates.