Some US policy makers have leapt onto the emergence of open RAN architectures as an opportunity to provide smaller operators with a low cost way to expel Huawei from their networks, and simultaneously to support the rebirth of a homegrown industry.
The latter died when European companies acquired North American RAN suppliers, Lucent, Nortel and Motorola Networks. But some of the leading lights in the open RAN movement, including Mavenir, JMA, Parallel Wireless and Altiostar, are US-based.
A group of senators have gone as far as to propose a bill which would offer funding to help operators rip out Chinese network equipment, but would make this contingent on their networks being certified by the O-RAN Alliance within seven years.
However, witnesses at a hearing before the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation warned of the dangers of such an approach. It insists on adoption of equipment and interfaces that have hardly been deployed at scale yet, and puts the risk of that onto small operators with limited engineering resources or financial cushion to help with the migration.
And it would end government technology neutrality, robbing operators of their own choice not just of vendor, but of technology.
Mike Murphy, CTO for the Americas at Nokia – which has contributed to O-RAN Alliance specs – nevertheless pointed out that fully compliant O-RAN interfaces have not been deployed anywhere yet. Even early O-RAN roll-outs like Rakuten’s involve considerable customization and inhouse heavy lifting – of a kind a tier two rural US carrier would not be able to do.
“Fully compliant O-RAN products are few and immature” and it would be “perhaps unreasonable” to turn small carriers into early adopters, Murphy said – “thus, a technology neutral approach might be more appropriate.” He added: “Likewise, virtualization, an orthogonal technology to O-RAN, that can also facilitate open systems, has only been deployed by one carrier globally in a 5G RAN. In short, there is limited maturity in both O-RAN and RAN virtualization.”
The bipartisan Utilizing Strategic Allied (USA) Telecommunications Act would provide over $1bn to encourage US competition with Huawei and use auction proceeds to create an O-RAN R&D fund. However, the policy makers seem confused about their terms. In the bill, the term ‘O-RAN’ refers to standards adopted by the O-RAN Alliance, Telecom Infra Project or 3GPP, “or any similar set of open standards for multivendor network equipment interoperability”. But of course, current RANs use 3GPP standards – the problem arises when some of its specs, such as X2, are implemented differently by each vendor.
Murphy pointed out that, while O-RAN has the greatest momentum now among open RAN efforts, “it is uncertain whether the most critical interface specified by O-RAN will be deployed widely, as alternatives are already being proposed by several contributing, significant members.”
Steve Berry, CEO of the Competitive Carriers’ Association (CCA), which represents smaller US operators, told the hearing: “O-RAN presents exciting new opportunities, with the potential to disaggregate functionality to increase efficiency and reduce costs”, and highlighted Dish Network’s plans to deploy a 5G NR Standalone network with O-RAN interfaces.
But he added: “Policy makers should not mandate which technologies are used in wireless networks, but instead should encourage research into new, secure technologies to enhance customer choice, innovation, and cost savings.”