Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 November 2020

Vodafone deploys DSS even though CEO seems sceptical

Vodafone Group CEO Nick Read has added a European voice to the band of MNOs criticizing DSS (dynamic spectrum sharing), even though one of his operating companies, Vodafone Ziggo, is already using the technology in The Netherlands.

Such cases look curious at first case because the groups voicing doubts have have often deployed DSS somewhere in their own infrastructures already, which is the case for Vodafone and also for Deutsche Telekom, which still owns a large share of one of DSS’s chief detractors, T-Mobile USA.

Vodafone employs DSS in Germany and the Netherlands, while Deutsche Telekom also does in its domestic operations. Furthermore, the latter singled out DSS as the key enabler for rapid rollout of 5G across half the German population, that is 40m people. Vodafone similarly pointed out that it is using DSS to introduce 5G in the low 700 MHz band previously dedicated to 4G.

This begs the question of what is going on here. The answer is that operators view DSS according to their footprints and spectrum allocations, tending to regard it with greater disdain when they do not need it. There is also a distinction between commercial and technical considerations. Vodafone’s CEO was criticizing DSS on the commercial count, for being just a short term fix for operators seeking to claim they can offer 5G over a substantial area when the actual performance offered is little if any superior to the existing 4G service over that same spectrum. That tends to apply particularly when that spectrum is in a low band under 1 GHz.

T-Mobile in the US however has cited technical concerns for opposing use of DSS in its network. The starting point here is that DSS was designed to allow operators to begin deploying 5G NR quickly alongside LTE in existing spectrum to allow optimum use of capacity through dynamic sharing of the bands on demand. Usually this can be done via a software upgrade to the existing LTE radios, coupled sometimes with changes to antenna configurations. T-Mobile’s president of technology Neville Ray contended earlier in 2020 that this software led to inefficiencies that have turned out to be worse than anticipated earlier.

He pointed out that T-Mobile had been an early advocate of DSS technology, with its partial parent Deutsche Telekom deploying it elsewhere, but found that it sucked up capacity over the shared radio through inefficiencies in the control plane in the re-allocation of bandwidth between LTE and 5G.

Some other operators disagree, but any argument can only be over degree. It is impossible for any technology to allow sharing of spectrum between different services without some compromise over performance, or capacity, or both. The same applies incidentally to network slicing for sharing of different use cases over common 5G  infrastructure.

In the case of DSS, care has been taken to avoid impact on LTE users in designated channels from reference signals used for synchronization and downlink measurements for example. This is done by transmitting those signals in time slots that avoid any collision with LTE signals.

But this comes at a price, with the risk that overall spectral efficiency may be impacted as a result of additional management overhead traffic generated by DSS. Compromises may also have to be made optimizing overall traffic management to balance capacity against the user experience. T-Mobile’s view is that this compromise has significantly reduced capacity and therefore DSS is not worth deploying unless strictly necessary for commercial reasons. That is not too far from Vodafone’s view, although there the emphasis was on failure of DSS to enable sufficiently good 5G.

That depends though on whether DSS is being used in low or mid band spectrum, noting that it will rarely be required for mm Wave frequencies because these have only become available for 5G. This brings us back to the US, since T-Mobile was questioning why Verizon was so keen on DSS while at the same time promoting its 5G service over millimeter wave spectrum as the only real deal because of the high bit-rates on offer.

The answer to this dichotomy comes down to two overlapping factors. Firstly, the short range of mmWave meant that the reach of Verizon’s high speed 5G service was very small, in fact just 0.5% of the US population, or 1.8m people, according to a recent report from financial analysts at New Street Research. That was quite close to the 0.6% figure for Verizon’s ‘super-fast’ 5G service derived earlier by Ookla via its web-based performance measurement service called Speedtest.

This deficiency was compounded by the second factor, the Covid-19 coronavirus pandemic, which triggered a dramatic shift in mobile usage patterns as so many people abandoned offices to work from home. Most importantly from Verizon’s perspective, this shifted large amounts of mobile traffic from those urban areas within which the fast 5G service was available if you were lucky, to rural and suburban areas where it almost certainly was not.

There is not so much that can be done to boost mmWave range in the immediate future given that signal loss and susceptibility to environmental conditions increase with frequency. It is true that mmWave has the one advantage that as wavelengths are shorter, around 10 millimeters at 30 GHz, antennas are more compact, making high density beamforming possible to mitigate that signal degradation. However, line of sight, or near-line of sight, between transmitter and received will be required.

In the meantime, Verizon was faced with a capacity crisis and had to hurriedly add many more 4G carriers than had been planned, as well as recruiting private CBRS spectrum. Verizon admitted that DSS did impose a capacity tariff but argued that additional spectrum found meant that it was able to deploy it in midrange spectrum to launch 5G. Verizon had spent more heavily than anticipated to the tune of $1.9bn playing catch up over midrange 3.5 GHz spectrum in the auction whose results were announced by the FCC in September 2020. This allowed Verizon to start deploying higher-speed services that can also span longer distances in this so called sweet spectral spot, albeit not as fast as LTE.

But Verizon was still relatively short of spectrum and so required DSS to enable 5G to be unleashed over this capacity without depleting 4G. T-Mobile was by contrast quite spectrum rich in the midband through its earlier acquisition of Sprint in a $26bn all shares deal finally completed on April 1 2020.

This gave T-Mobile 317 MHz of spectrum in the 2.5 GHz band, which it has been quick to harness for launch of 5G in almost 200 new locations at the end of October 2020, aiming to cover 100m people with midband 5G by the year end. With over twice as much spectrum in the midband as AT&T or Verizon it did not need to employ DSS and so could afford to be more disparaging about it.

In this context it will be interesting to see how intense bidding will be for the C-band spectrum between 3.7-3.98 GHz coming up at the FCC auction due to start on December 8.