News that Qualcomm had been granted permission to sell 4G chips to Huawei was significant but a far smaller surprise than the licensing agreement signed over three months earlier in late July 2020. After all, similar permission had been granted to Intel in September for chips covering PCs and laptops, although the Qualcomm move was more noteworthy given that US action against Huawei was focused on the mobile communications arena.
Both moves reflect the reality that China is the world’s biggest market for chips alongside the US itself and its major players have been lobbying hard to maintain access in areas not seen to conflict with the primary focus on 5G. Indeed, Qualcomm is still prohibited from selling its 5G Snapdragon chips to Huawei.
It was not clear though whether the permission will extend to versions of Qualcomm’s entry level Snapdragon 4 chips enhanced for 5G, planned for release early in 2021. That would be significant because it would give Huawei access to lower cost 5G chipsets aimed at affordable phones designed to accelerate 5G adoption, which would certainly seem against the grain of earlier US intentions. Qualcomm was unable to confirm or deny this in time for publication, but whatever the case this further apparent relaxation, combined with Joe Biden’s victory in the US presidential election over the more mercurial and anti-China Donald Trump, has helped take the heat off Huawei.
The Qualcomm move does seem to match quite nicely the other major development around Huawei this week, the sale of its Honor midrange smartphone business to a Chinese consortium for an undisclosed sum, as we reported las week. According to Reuters, Honor has been valued at $15.2bn but that does sound rather high even though all assets including R&D were included, considering that the brand’s main distributor, Digital China, was reported to have tabled an offer of just $2.9bn only a few weeks ago.
As we reported, Huawei has acted to work around some of its embargoes, and to improve its own costs, by offloading the Honor handset brand and R&D activities to a consortium including rival Chinese handset makers Xiaomi and TCL, as well as Honor’s main distributor in China, that is Digital China, along with the government of Shenzhen.
This comes seven years after Huawei launched the Honor brand in 2013, focusing on the middle and lower end of the handset market. In the company’s most recent quarter ending September 2020, Honor accounted for 26% of Huawei’s 51.7m cellphone shipments, a number that was placing strain on supply of critical components, chiefly chips, resulting from the US ban on companies using American technology doing business with the company.
That US pressure really began to bite in August 2020 when Huawei announced it would stop making its flagship Kirin chipsets the following month. We interpreted that move as a direct consequence of pressure on Huawei making it impossible for the company’s HiSilicon chip division to continue making the chipsets. This appeared to be confirmed by Richard Yu, CEO of Huawei’s Consumer Business Unit, at an event in Shenzhen.
That HiSilicon division relies on software from US companies such as Synopsys and Cadence Design Systems for the logic of many of its chips whose fabrication is then outsourced to foundry TSMC. This company in turn uses equipment from US companies, which made it exposed to the US Huawei ban. The smallest 5-nanometer fabrication process required for the very latest high performance chips that will go into 5G handsets, for example, requires advanced manufacturing capability that only TSMC and Samsung possess. For example, in October 2019 TSMC started sampling 5nm A14 processors for Apple, destined for its latest iPad Air and iPhone 12 handsets.
The sale of Honor helps resolve this chip deficit by cutting its demand and at the same time creating a supply chain for Huawei in China through local dealers and distributors, reducing reliance on imports from companies restricted by US measures. However, relief from the Qualcomm ban will expand this supply chain further for midrange phones, although with that question remaining over Snapdragon 14 and 5G.
Meanwhile, other chipmakers are queuing up for exemption from that US technology ban on exports to Huawei, including Micron Technology, Samsung, SK Hynix, Macronix International and China’s largest foundry, Semiconductor Manufacturing International (SMIC).