Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 November 2020

6 GHz WiFi and diluted neutrality – contrasting legacies of chairman Pai

The legacy of outgoing FCC chairman Ajit Pai will be defined by two policies in particular – the unravelling of net neutrality and the opening of 6 GHz spectrum for wireless broadband use, which is mainly impacting WiFi.

Anyone in Pai’s position would have seen the clear and obvious benefits of expanding the unlicensed spectrum available to WiFi, and this was reflected in the unanimous FCC vote in favor of the bill in April this year.

However, it takes a special sort of FCC chairman to go about replacing Title II with some form of voluntary code that benefits only the powerful operator gatekeepers, essentially allowing these companies to create their own fast lanes to the detriment of other Internet services, and in particular the start-up community.

Pai held to the belief that no regulation is good regulation, claiming that net neutrality was over-regulating the Internet and therefore discouraging investment. He underestimated the fact that ISPs were actively under-investing in network infrastructure while they waited for a presidency, and an FCC, that would push plans to give ISPs additional powers over Internet-based services, to maximize profits.

Pai’s greatest argument against the introduction of net neutrality in 2015, was that these laws had driven reduced investment by operators like AT&T and Verizon (where Pai was a former attorney). That argument, of course, was – and continues to be – highly controversial. The two big telcos had indeed reined in their capex, but there were many factors behind that, including the near-completion of their 4G networks, and the suspension of intensive mobile build-out until 5G networks rolled out, and in AT&T’s case in particular, a sharp shift towards software-driven networks, which are less capex-intensive.

Pai claimed, in his early days in the chair, that without Title II, broadband would become slower and more expensive. Broadband prices were rising anyway, but speeds have not got any slower, with DOCSIS 3.1, MoCA Access, G.fast, not to mention FTTH and FTTC/B, 5G fixed wireless access, and newer initiatives like Space X’s Starlink satellite broadband, all rolling out in the USA.

Pai’s longer legacy is that subsequent FCCs will have power to question the way things are run at ISPs in the USA. Pai has effectively changed the way the Internet is used as a political tool, forever.

One policy in which Pai showed virtually zero interest as the Open Set-top Initiative, which had been pushed hard by his predecessor, Tom Wheeler. Pai was pressured to close it down by fellow Republicans on the House’s Energy and Commerce Committee, who stated in a letter to Pai that the initiative was “an unnecessary regulatory threat to the content creation and distribution industries and will limit high quality video programming.”

The clock is now ticking for Pai, with a 3-2 majority swing meaning the FCC will revert to Democratic control as of January 2021. With just two months to go until a new FCC chairman is appointed, the controversy continues, amid growing concerns that Pai is continuing to work on debatable items despite Trump’s election defeat, according to an Ars Technica report doing the rounds last week.

Democrats have called for Pai to immediately down tools concerning any partisan rulemakings that he might attempt to rush over the finish line, ignoring the tradition of clearing the field in recognition of a new era. Ironically, four years ago, Pai made no hesitation in telling his predecessor Tom Wheeler to “halt further action on controversial items during the transition period” – and then proceeded to spend every day of his chairmanship attempting to airbrush Wheeler’s policies from the history books.