Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 November 2020

Progress to a diverse smart home ecosystem appears to have stalled

As we head towards holiday season, it would be remiss of us not to turn our attention to the smart home – as is tradition. However, it feels like we are singing from last year’s hymn sheet, which itself was heavily based on the year before, as there has been very little progress in the market – despite what organizations like the Connected Home Over IP (CHIP) group would have you believe.

Black Friday and Christmas have always been popular times to sell smart home gear, with CES capitalizing on the hype and giving us a vision of the future. This year, it goes without saying, will be quite different, but smart home slingers may well have benefited from the general home improvement uptick we have seen.

But for the video world, there has been very little progress on the smart home front in the past year, and it seems that CHIP is not something we’re going to have to pay particularly close attention to.

For a brief recap; the operators had a collective opportunity to become major players in the smart home realm, by bundling devices and services together as part of a monthly broadband and TV package. This would have been a very easy way to expand to a quad or quint-play offering, using a very sticky bundle.

However, Amazon and Google have stormed to the fore, becoming a complete duopoly from an ecosystem perspective, facing very little competition from the operator-led B2C channel. Instead, the off-the-shelf consumer channel now seems unmovable, and we have seen how the Orange-DT Djingo-Magenta rival fell apart on arrival.

One of the main reasons for Amazon and Google’s success has been the way that they solved one of the earliest, and longest lasting, problems in the smart home – device interoperability. Instead of trying to solve that at the radio layer, they focused instead on cloud-to-cloud integrations, to ensure that devices from different vendors could talk to each other.

To cap it all off, the voice-based interactions, from Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, sealed the deal. This is all despite the operator crowd having all those capabilities in their toolboxes, or at least available to them via licensing, and so that door seems to have closed on them. The Smart Home as a Service (SHaaS) opportunity is the one that got away, it seems.

But there is hope. After all, the TV is still a central device in the home, and one that is well placed to become a hub for many of the most popular smart home use cases – home security, doorbells alerts, HVAC controls, and lighting.

The crossover between Google and Android TV means that tight integrations are likely imminent, and Amazon’s desire to get its retail experience into as many channels as possible means that it has a strong motivation to get Alexa and ‘would you like to buy another pack of connected lightbulbs’ onto as many devices as possible.

So then, surely we’re excited by developments at a standards organization that counts Google, Amazon, and Apple as members? Unfortunately, for CHIP, little has changed in a year. The latest news is that it has set up a team dedicated to the development and promotion of its standard for commercial markets – something that is a bit farcical, because it still hasn’t finished this ‘super standard’.

CHIP’s lack of progress is discouraging. When first announced, in December 2019, it saw the three main consumer-facing smart home vendors take seats at the same table. Ostensibly, this would indicate that they had put aside differences to work on CHIP, a standard that would act as a rising tide to lift all boats. With Ikea coming on board, one of the most influential home improvement and furnishing outlets was also throwing considerable weight behind the initiative.

But there was already a standards group doing the same thing, and the Open Connectivity Foundation (OCF) was somewhat blindsided by the announcement. Wireless Watch’s sister service, Faultline, which provides weekly analysis of digital video and home markets, covered the OCF’s Universal Cloud Interface launch, back in August, which sees the OCF ticking along.

Further complicating things is the fact that CHIP is technically part of the Zigbee Alliance, and Zigbee-rival Thread Group is also a CHIP member. There is no sign of Bluetooth or WiFi involvement either, but Z-Wave owner Silicon Labs is a prominent member.

Speaking of membership, there are a few other relevant ones to mention. Comcast is most notable, and CableLabs would suggest that RDK integrations are on the table. Charter has signed up too, as has Deutsche Telekom, but that signals the end of operator involvement.

There are a number of prominent equipment and software vendors too, including Arris (CommScope), Control4, Develco, LG, Panasonic, Plume, Samsung, TCL, and Vivint, as well as the usual raft of semiconductor outlets too. Facebook is also lurking in the wings, but a number of white goods, lighting, and utility members round out the whole-home focus. The video ecosystem seems quite under-represented.

So, another year has gone by, where Amazon and Google entrench their duopolistic hold on the market, and where the inevitability of slow-moving standards bodies and their labyrinthine bureaucracy means that the likes of CHIP move further adrift. We don’t hold much hope for CHIP, despite its membership, and it seems a bit depressing that anti-competition regulation may well be more disruptive than such a coalition.