With Ajit Pai due to vacate the FCC chair on January 20, Wireless Watch’s sister service, Faultline, which provides weekly analysis of digital video markets, explored the frontrunners to replace the man we recently described as the FCC’s most divisive leader to date – and what the next four years of Democratic FCC could mean for technology and communications.
Whoever takes the helm, one thing is certain – each FCC chair is under markedly more pressure than the last. With technology permeating lives in ways even the best forecasters could never have fathomed this time last year, the FCC’s role in any government becomes more critical by the day. Chairing the regulatory body of the most powerful and influential country in the world is even more imperative at a time of not just a global health crisis, but a personality crisis for the USA.
Among all the hysteria, the most pressing question is whether a new FCC will immediately set about reinstating net neutrality regulations? Given the widening digital divide in the US – one which the pandemic has highlighted on an embarrassing scale despite Pai’s proclamations that he closed the gap – a Title 2-type legislation will likely be first blood for the next FCC chair, or something pretty close to it.
While Joe Biden has been quiet on the net neutrality front so far, a spokesperson for the president-elect recently said: “As Barack Obama’s VP, Joe Biden was proud to push for net neutrality and see the FCC take direct action to keep the internet open and free for all Americas.” There have been some reservations about Biden’s net neutrality stance given the sizable checks his presidential campaign received from Comcast, among others, but then again so did Obama’s, so this is really a non-argument.
What about technology trade relations – is there any chance of a Biden-era FCC looking to quickly repair ties with China? Unfortunately, most of the damage is irreparable, after Pai spent much of his tenure driving Huawei out of US mobile network infrastructure – subsequently spreading spying fears that triggered copycat network equipment switch-outs the world over.
Our hope is that the next FCC chair takes a more forward-looking approach than partisan Pai, who quickly gained a reputation for looking over his shoulder – seemingly more intent on undoing the work of his predecessor Tom Wheeler than in encouraging organic innovation.
Currently in the running for the role are existing FCC commissioners Jessica Rosenworcel and Geoffrey Starks, both Democrats who consistently voted against Pai’s policies. Of course, Biden can choose to appoint from outside the agency instead of promoting an existing FCC commissioner, with a few law firm contenders being floated such as Anna Gomez of Wiley Rein, and Edward Smith of DLA Piper.
Biden himself has not been particularly outspoken on technology and communications policies during his campaign trail. However, the vice president-elect, Kamala Harris, is reported as having close ties to Silicon Valley that could put the nerves of technology giants at ease after four years of hounding under the Trump administration. That said, we don’t expect some sort of happy ending here, with pressure mounting on Amazon, Apple, Facebook and Google in the form of a 449-page congressional report from the House Judiciary Committee detailing a plan to prevent these four companies becoming even more powerful over the next four years.
The data practices of these very companies is why Republican FCC commissioner Mike O’Rielly had his nomination for FCC chair pulled, after he voiced “deep reservations” about whether the FCC provided any “intentional authority” over the matter of Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. This long-held law essentially protects social media platforms from being sued due to user-generated posts.
Here, Pai played to Trump’s tune by agreeing to investigate Section 230 after the President’s incessant and baseless claims that social media platforms were censoring posts to influence election results. However, Biden and Trump do at least share common ground that Section 230 should be revoked, with Biden describing tech giants as “propagating falsehoods they know to be false” in relation to Section 230 – while pointing to European data privacy regulations as setting the bar.
There is, however, a Republican in the running. In the dying days of the Trump administration, the Senate Commerce Committee has pushed through the nomination of Nathan Simington as a member of the FCC. Simington was the author of the infamous brief sent by the Department of Justice to the FCC demanding investigation into Section 230 – fueling concern about the possible rewriting of Section 230.
Despite political differences, Rosenworcel and O’Rielly had been working for years on repurposing the 5.9 GHz band for WiFi. That the work took so long is indicative of the tensions that have riven in this area of spectrum and the tug of war between the WiFi and cellular camps. But now with the recent compromise for handing over some spectrum to cellular V2X connectivity, the FCC seems to have come down to one page, with Rosenworcel praising her erstwhile colleague O’Rielly, who has now left, for his contributions and movement towards a common position where both sides could derive some comfort.
“He deserves real kudos for his commitment to this subject and the fact we’re even here today is due in large part to his persistence and his belief that we need to find a way forward that updates true safety operations and also makes it possible to expand the use of unlicensed services in the 5.9 GHz band,” said Rosenworcel in a recent statement.
While Pai has no place in a Biden-led FCC, his value to the Republican party might see him reassigned in another legal role. However, his inside knowledge of US communications laws could prove invaluable to a big technology company, so we could potentially see Pai return to his Verizon days – with a significant pay rise.