Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 December 2020

BT will spend £500m to reduce Huawei presence in its networks

More details have emerged of the UK’s decision to give Huawei limited access to 5G networks, which was announced as we went to press last week. Although the country resisted US pressure to bar the Chinese vendor from 5G altogether, its Supply Chain Review decided to exclude “high risk vendors” from core networks; to cap the amount of RAN inventory they can supply at 35%; to limit the amount of Internet traffic per year that can pass through their equipment, also at 35%; and to restrict the amount of fiber-to-the-premises (FTTP) network equipment, such as GPON or DOCSIS 3.x, they can supply, again to 35%.

Those high risk vendors were not named, but since ZTE does not have a UK customer, it was clear who will be affected. Operators have three years to comply.

Although a full ban was not inflicted, even these rules will create challenges for three of the four UK MNOs – O2 is the only one not to be a Huawei customer. It is estimated that Huawei has supplied about 44% of current UK wireless equipment, and so that will need to be reduced.

Vodafone hit out at the caps, with Nick Read saying that, if emulated by other European regulators, they could delay its full 5G roll-out by 2-5 years. Indeed, the caps idea does seem to veer away from decisions made on the grounds of national security – if Huawei is really believed to use its equipment to enable Chinese spying, it would be illogical to allow it into any part of the network. Quota systems suggest a trade balance motivation, artificially restricting how much a certain country or vendor can sell into the market.

BT said it would cost it about £500m ($658m) over five years to implement the recommendations, though CEO Philip Jansen, speaking on the operator’s earnings call last week, did say he welcomed “the clarity provided by government around the use of certain vendors in networks across the UK and agree that the priority should be the security of the UK’s communications infrastructure”.

Uncertainty over what policies would be adopted have been a significant dampener of 5G procurement and roll-out in many markets, especially in Europe, where governments have been conducting reviews of security risks and the presence of Chinese equipment in their 5G networks.

Analyst James Ratzer at New Street Research wrote in a client note: “The main contributor to this £500m cost is the need to swap out existing Huawei 4G equipment at sites where BT wants to deploy 5G, particularly in urban areas. This swap-out is necessary because BT, in common with all other European telcos, is deploying a non-standalone (NSA) 5G network, which relies on the 4G network for key management and control functions. BT’s exposure to Huawei 4G though is one of the highest in the sector.”

Huawei is also a significant fiber equipment supplier to Openreach, BT’s wholesale fixed-line company, though the firm also uses Nokia gear, and recently began the process of selecting a third FTTP technology vendor, with Adtran rumored to be the frontrunner.

Vodafone UK, despite being one of the first European operators to add Huawei to its supplier list about 15 years ago, has lower exposure to rip-and-replace costs than BT because it shares its UK network with O2, which is not a Huawei customer, and Vodafone does not use Huawei in London. According to New Street, that should keep them within the 35% cap, though if other European markets follow the UK precedent, Vodafone would be more vulnerable, as some of its subsidiaries are heavy users of Huawei equipment in 4G.

Vodafone said it will have to spend €200m ($220m) over five years to phase Huawei out of its core networks in its European operations, though this does not affect the UK. Given the precedent set by the UK, and the comments from the EU, it seems likely that most European government will adopt the policy of keeping “high risk vendors” out of core networks will allowing them at least some access to the RAN (the biggest percentage of MNO spending and so the most important to have a price-competitive supply chain).

A year ago, Vodafone said it would hit the pause button on any more investment in Huawei core equipment until it had clarity on the outcome of European security reviews. In its earnings update shortly after the UK decision was announced, group CEO Nick Read welcomed the distinction that the authorities had made between the core and the RAN.

In the latter, Vodafone is a significant user of Huawei kit and Read has called on regulators in other European countries not to impose the caps on RAN equipment that have been announced in the UK, since that would increase Vodafone’s rip-out bill considerably. He said the UK business is already in compliance with those caps, but that would not be the case in all its markets. “We do not advocate a quota-based approach,” said Read. “In non-sensitive areas, Huawei is an important supplier reflecting its high quality technology. RAN quotas would disrupt customers, drive higher prices and delay roll-out of 5G by 2-5 years given our limited operational and financial resources.”

The company’s Australian joint venture with Hutchison, VHA, has already suffered from a complete ban on Chinese 5G equipment, imposed there very soon after the USA placed Huawei on its entity list last spring – VHA was a single-supplier Huawei shop for 4G and had started its 5G procurement too, but now faces the dual challenge of selecting a new vendor without delaying its 5G roadmap too drastically, and replacing at least some of its Huawei 4G base stations to allow for smooth deployment of 5G Non-Standalone..

Vodafone repeated the calls of other MNOs – and the US government (see separate item) – to facilitate a more diverse supply chain. It is supporting open RAN initiatives, notably with an invitation to tender for RAN equipment across its whole European footprint, with specs based on work by Telecom Infra Project (TIP) and the ORAN Alliance. It is also in trials in the UK and Ireland with two open RAN suppliers, Mavenir and Parallel Wireless.

But while Vodafone and others are keen to support alternative vendors and move towards a more open, price-competitive ecosystem, they will not allow any equipment near their mainstream macro RANs until they are fully confident in its levels of performance and resilience, and the vendor’s ability to provide full support – and those demands will only rise with 5G. Read’s comments reflected this, when he said, as part of his argument against restricting Huawei:  “We too want vendor resilience and balancing but these things take time.”

Worst off is Three UK, the smallest MNO, which had decided on Huawei as its sole 5G RAN supplier, replacing its 4G vendor Samsung, but will presumably now need to procure most additional kit elsewhere (its core supplier is Nokia).

It has already been engaged in a rip-and-replace programme to substitute Huawei equipment for Samsung and had aimed to replace 40% of RAN inventory by the end of 2021. One of the challenges for operators deploying Non-Standalone 5G – which allows 4G and 5G base stations to be managed by one 4G core – is that it is far easier to implement this if the 4G and 5G base stations are from the same supplier.

Most operators have, therefore, stuck with their 4G vendor for at least the first phase of 5G, but Three had decided to make its swap at this early point, presumably hoping to avoid any vendor changes in future phases of 5G. Now, instead, it may have to replace some of its new Huawei gear, or at least mount a procurement process for a new supplier, which could delay its roll-out by many months. Sources at the MNO claimed it can carry on with its planned deployments for 2020 before it reaches any caps.

Two senior Three UK technology executives have left the company recently, leading to speculation that this was because of the decision to adopt a single-vendor strategy and select Huawei, despite the risks of government restrictions. Phil Sheppard, who effectively performed a CTO role, and Graham Marsh, former director of core technology, have both departed. Marsh, who was also linked with a successful decision to move quickly to a cloud-native core with Nokia, has founded a new company called Infinite Potential.

With the decision, UK prime minister Boris Johnson seemed to be trying to tread a line between capitulating to US demands for a full ban – which would have created fury among MNOs, which want a price-competitive supply chain and to be able to keep existing investments in Huawei kit – and angering the Trump administration too much, especially when the UK is eager for a post-Brexit trade deal.

The UK’s National Cyber Security Centre, which came up with the recommendations that underpin the new policy, also stressed the need to diversify the range of equipment vendors in 5G and to support open interoperable platforms that could lower barriers to new entrants.

The European Union has published recent guidance that Chinese vendors should not be banned, but instead all countries and operators should set stringent security targets and precautions regardless of their suppliers. The EU member states have been requested to implement the suggested security measures by April 30.

But some of Europe’s MNOs are turning away from Huawei. Orange France announced Nokia and Ericsson as its 5G suppliers last week, with Nokia focusing on the western and south east regions, and Ericsson in the north east, south west and Ile de France. Orange has long-standing relationships with both vendors but has also used some Huawei kit in the past. It has not ruled out using Huawei in its other European markets.

February 2020:

Nokia had ended 2019 on a difficult note, having acknowledged cost/performance issues with its 5G chip platform, and switched direction to a new set of system-on-chip (SoC) designs from multiple partners including Marvell, Intel and Broadcom. Later instalments of the retrospective will examine how Nokia has responded to its latest crisis, with a new CEO and a shift away from ‘end-to-end’ networks to a more mobile-centric strategy. While its financials are still struggling, it has shone in several ways despite the difficult year, notably in the growth of its software business, and its leadership of the buoyant private cellular networks segment. In the first quarter of 2020, the markets were more concerned with recent 5G setbacks, however, and Nokia was just starting to show how it would seek to restore investor and customer confidence in the year ahead.