Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 December 2020

O2 UK adds new O-RAN trial, while AT&T is cautious on timescales

By Wireless Watch Staff

It’s been a busy couple of weeks for open RAN architectures. The US regulator, the FCC, said open RAN architectures would be eligible for its ‘rip-and-replace’ programme, which provides support for smaller carriers to remove Huawei or ZTE equipment from their networks.

However, the agency did not mention any specific suppliers, though the sort of rural and regional providers which have commonly bought Chinese gear could be a strong target for emerging open RAN platforms. These are not deemed ready to power heavily loaded, ultra-resilient macro networks – unless heavily customized like Rakuten’s roll-out – but they are already playing a significant role in trials and deployments for more localized platforms such as rural extensions or enterprise and indoor networks.

For instance, Telefónica’s O2 UK is the latest subsidiary of the Spanish group to test open RAN technology, following trials in Spain and parts of Latin America. The company is working with UK and Irish service provider Vilicom and RAN software vendor Mavenir to implement 4G or 5G small cells in areas of poor in-building coverage.

The pilot involved integration and operation of open RAN infrastructure for indoor mobile connectivity for O2 business customers over a connectivity-as-a-service (CaaS) network platform from UK service provider Vilicom. This infrastructure was developed by Vilicom in partnership with US cloud software developer Mavenir aligned to the JOTS Neutral Host In-Building connectivity model.

JOTS (Joint Operators Technical Specification Forum) is a UK body set up in 1999 to develop common specifications for infrastructure shared by the country’s mobile operators.

CTO Brendan O’Reilly said: “O-RAN integrations such as this are an integral part of our commitment to deliver the best network experience for our customers, where they need it most.” The test platform will be connected to the live network next year.

Though not a big name in the O-RAN world, Vilicom already provides indoor connectivity for the three Irish MNOs – Eir, Three and Vodafone – at Dublin airport. It says CaaS “streamlines operations, rapidly reducing the cost and space requirements of in-building 4G and 5G public and private mobile connectivity for the UK’s industries and businesses”.

O2 has already worked with Mavenir, DenseAir and WaveMobile in O-RAN and CaaS trials for rural UK areas.

But the gap between the greenfield, indoor and rural market, and the huge challenges of a macro 5G RAN, remains an issue for the open community, in terms of how quickly they will be able to achieve critical mass. The biggest risk is that the timing will be off – that the time to address operators’ doubts over issues such as performance trade-offs or integration costs will be too long to meet the 5G roll-out deadlines of the key telcos.

AT&T’s president of technology and operations, Scott Mair, weighed in on the debate at an investor conference last week, saying: “We believe that open RAN is going to be a good benefit for us, and we actually plan to implement it in our network. We think it’s really a good technology that will become available. But it’s not going to happen overnight. It’s going to take some time.”

Of course, much of the initial code and architecture used by the O-RAN Alliance came from AT&T, which devised a technology called xRAN inhouse and then open sourced it to an industry body, which subsequently merged with the China-centric Cloud-RAN Alliance.

Mair believes that, once it is mature, open RAN could reduce AT&T’s capex and opex spending by opening up the supply chain and adding a new layer of automation on top of existing network management systems.

Mazin Gilbert, AT&T’s VP of network analytics and automation, enlarged on that theme by outlining how the operator would incorporate AI and machine learning into open RAN automation technologies such as the RAN Intelligent Controller (RIC).

Speaking at LightReading’s recent O-RAN event, he said: “There are beautiful, huge opportunities for vendors, start-ups and companies to be creating these machine learning or AI applications” and moving towards the long-held goal of closed-loop automation in the RAN. But he echoed Mair’s caution on timescales, adding: “This journey of going to open RAN is not going to happen overnight,” and proposing a timeframe of 3-5 years.