Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 September 2005

Ericsson faces triple challenge, seeks to embrace China and dismiss WiMAX

Ericsson, one of the turnaround stories of the past few years, now faces a new set of daunting challenges to its position as the world’s largest provider of mobile infrastructure. Its share of the UMTS market is less dominant than it was in GSM, it has pulled out of CDMA altogether and although it has made moves towards convergence with a plan to expand its wireline business, this is in very early stages. There are three threats to Ericsson’s position ‘ from traditional rivals that have made more aggressive moves to support the trend to fixed/mobile convergence, such as Motorola and Lucent; from new technologies that could reduce the share of the mobile market commanded by GSM/UMTS, notably WiMAX; and from challengers coming from China.

This week, Ericsson laid out some of its roadmap towards 4G networking. It was largely silent on the first challenge, aggressive about the second, and sought to neutralize the third by forming ever closer alliances with Chinese rivals.

Chief technology officer Hakan Eriksson told an analyst briefing, significantly held in Shanghai, China, that the W-CDMA 3G technology and its future iterations would be the dominant wireless platform in the coming years and provided a robust route to 4G. Although Ericsson joined the WiMAX Forum earlier this year, and is rebadging equipment from Airspan, it has always been, understandably, tentative about 802.16, with its potential to provide an alternative mobile broadband platform alongside UMTS and CDMA2000. If WiMAX achieves significant volumes over the coming years, on a scale to attract Ericsson, the Swedish giant will be coming at the sector as it did at CDMA, from behind, taking on companies that have put serious R&D into the platform, such as Motorola. Therefore it aims to try to pre-empt mobile WiMAX at every turn with the UMTS range of technologies, to ensure the new challenger remains a niche platform and that the network where Ericsson has the greatest market presence, expertise and intellectual property stays in pole position.

WiMAX is ‘not as good as ADSL2+ and cannot compete with HSDPA,” said Eriksson. “The standards for HSDPA began development some 10 years ago while WiMAX was only finalized last summer.”

His main criticism of WiMAX is that the base standards are only specified for the physical and MAC (media access control) layers, while W-CDMA and its ‘3.5G’ extension, HSDPA, are specified across all seven layers of the network model, up to session, presentation and application. This will give them real advantages in supporting interoperability and user roaming from within the standard, he argued.

HSDPA, of course, can leverage the mass installed base of GSM and W-CDMA among mobile operators, but WiMAX has greater potential to support other spectrum profiles and so to appeal to carriers without a 3G license. There will be additional profiles for W-CDMA, in 900MHz, 1.7GHz, 1.8GHz and 2.1GHz, which will bring it closer to CDMA in terms of spectrum flexibility, but much will depend on regulator policies, notably whether WiMAX is allowed into the European 2.5G band, currently earmarked for 3G expansion using UMTS only.

The Ericsson CTO also outlined a roadmap for so-called Super 3G, which will support speeds of up to 100Mbps. Specification work to take place from the middle of next year with a standard slated for mid-2007. This work, spearheaded by Japanese operator NTT DoCoMo, is the most aggressive response by the W-CDMA community to the advent of WiMAX. Just as Qualcomm is incorporating the benefits of OFDM, the technology underlying WiMAX, into its CDMA2000 evolution path, so the 3GPP that controls W-CDMA is looking to do the same, to ensure its networks remain competitive with broadband wireless alternatives ‘ and that its customer carriers do not lose out to challengers from the wireline or start-up worlds.

There are several OFDM-based approaches under consideration by 3GPP, including Super 3G, and the HSOPA technology submitted by Nortel. Super 3G is notable for having heavy involvement from operators. Although, traditionally, carriers only got involved in standards creation at a near-commercial stage, they increasingly seek to control their technologies and ensure these meet their needs. They have become increasingly active in the WiMAX Forum, and apart from the leaders, DoCoMo and Vodafone, many other cellcos are also participating in Super 3G, including Cingular Wireless, Orange, Telecom Italia Mobile, China Mobile, T-Mobile International and TeliaSonera.

They want enhancements that will enable high bandwidth services such as video on demand to be delivered to large number of users, from within an IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) framework, and without dramatic hardware upgrades. The need for protection of investment in W-CDMA will be a limiting factor on Super 3G, and one not suffered by the WiMAX camp, but a strong measure of software upgradeability for 3G ‘ as offered by HSDPA and HSUPA ‘ will be one way to ensure that large cellcos do not get lured away to alternative networks too easily.

Super 3G will be one of the focuses of a new Ericsson agreement with the Shanghai Research Center for Wireless Communication (SRCWC), an influential government backed laboratory in China, which will form part of the Swedish company’s bid to keep the Chinese challengers close and to position itself to address China’s own expected telecoms boom later in the decade.

Ericsson, which already has a partnership with China’s largest supplier of mobile equipment, ZTE, said it will invest $1bn over five years in achieving its goal of winning at least 35% of the Chinese wireless infrastructure business, which it thinks will be worth $10bn-$12bn by the end of the decade.

Mats Olsson, president of the Chinese operations, said: ‘The investment will focus on further expanding our manufacturing capabilities, the continuously rapid establishment of R&D centers, and also significant expansion of our service capacity and capabilities. In addition to this, there will be significant local purchasing for the global market.’

‘Our ambition is to maintain a level of around 35% market share across 3G, and I think we are very well positioned for that. We have obvious critical mass, more mass than anyone else in W-CDMA. We will continue the R&D efforts, we have a strong local presence, and we are deeply embedded in the local telecoms industry,’ said Svanberg.

However, Ericsson will face intense competition in China, from local suppliers ZTE and Huawei and most of its more traditional rivals. Siemens, in particular, stands to gain if one or more operators adopts the homegrown 3G variant, TD-SCDMA, since it helped develop that platform and has put huge resources into R&D in this area. However, TD-SCDMA has come up against performance problems and may, despite government support, be bypassed.

The Chinese government backing for this network represents a broader trend for the Asian superpowers to seek to create and drive their own technology and intellectual property ‘ to reduce their dependence on western vendors and patents – and eventually to export this to the west too and so build up their own global business (see Wireless Watch September 2 2005). Long term, whatever moves Ericsson makes to collaborate with ZTE and others, this will be its greatest challenge.

The large Asian economies are banding together in their quest to become less dependent on US and European vendors. Last week, the governments of China and Japan signed a memorandum of understanding surrounding long term co-operation for the development and standardization of 4G technologies, a move clearly designed to wrest the steering wheel from the traditional US-Scandinavian wireless axis.

More immediately, the Chinese vendors are acquiring the technological expertise and international base to take on Ericsson and others. And they will be one factor making WiMAX a viable contender to W-CDMA ‘ since companies like ZTE and Samsung would find it hard to penetrate far into the installed bases of the western giants in the W-CDMA and CDMA2000 sectors, they will look to use platforms in which they can start on a level playing field or ‘ notably in the case of Samsung’s Wi-Bro pre-WiMAX network ‘ take a firm lead.

Even in traditional technologies, Huawei and ZTE are starting to make inroads in the west, although they often win on price, an advantage that will not be sustainable on its own for the long term without added value and the ability to support competitive edge. Shivers went down the spine of Ericsson and Nokia in June when Vodafone’s chief technology officer, Thomas Geitner, told the Reuters news agency: ‘We’re beginning to use equipment from Huawei in some places’ and even Finland’s TeliaSonera ‘ Nokia’s home customer ‘ has shopped with Huawei. Geitner said Huawei and ZTE can offer savings of up to 30% on similar quotes from Ericsson or Nokia.

Such talk is, to some extent, aiming to pressurize existing suppliers to be more price competitive or offer better credit and payment terms, but 30% is a huge gulf to breach with the current supply chain and production structures. A company as dependent as Ericsson on 3G may well be forced to shift more of its manufacturing to developing nations and to put pressure on its own suppliers, as well as pursuing new markets.

But ZTE, in particular, sees WiMAX as an area where it can dominate rather than engaging in price cutting. Although larger than Huawei in its native country, it has made less of a splash abroad, but this month, it started to reverse that by opening its US headquarters, as a springboard for sales and marketing pushes in the Americas. Based in Dallas, Texas, the new HQ will work closely with another center in San Diego, California, which will serve as the global HQ for ZTE’s WiMAX subsidiary, ZiMAX.

ZiMAX has a major development deal with Intel and claims it will be one of the first vendors to release a WiMAX cellphone. In revenues of $2.6bn, 70% come from wireless infrastructure and handsets, and non-Chinese sales rose by 133% last year, to account for 21% (although nearly all of this is currently in other parts of Asia and Africa). It has little presence in W-CDMA, although it is developing HSDPA and Super 3G, but sees CDMA2000 and WiMAX as its key cards.

Its progress in the US and western Europe will be slow, but its focus on emerging networks such as WiMAX and CDMA450, suited to alternative carriers as well as developing economies, will make it a formidable force by decade end. A combination of WiMAX and Chinese vendors, with their manufacturing efficiencies and rapidly developing technological prowess, will certainly start to dent the margins available in the 3G business, and provide new headaches for the management of Ericsson.

NOTE: 3G roadmap

About 80 operators in about 36 countries have launched W-CDMA networks and the number of W-CDMA subscribers is approaching 30m, according to the UMTS Forum. Most of those networks have been running for 18 months or less, although DoCoMo launched its FOMA 3G network in late 2001 and has more than half of the world’s W-CDMA subscribers.

Some of these carriers already are upgrading their networks to HSDPA, which will initially triple W-CDMA’s data rates to 1-2Mbps, although only on the downlink, and later get up to a theoretical 14.4Mbps. Another upgrade, HSUPA, will follow in 2007, boosting uplink rates.

Current enhancements to UMTS fall within the 3GPP Release 5 specifications, which encompass areas such as HSDPA and IMS. Recently, 3G Americas, a wireless industry group supporting the GSM family of technologies, published a white paper covering progress towards UMTS Release 6 as well as longer term evolution, designed as a statement of confidence in the long term development path for UMTS as a key element in 4G, despite the advent of IP alternatives, notably WiMAX.

Chris Pearson, President of 3G Americas stated, “With wireless data services starting to follow a similar growth curve to that of wireline data, the GSM community has recently focused on the near term evolution to support HSDPA and IMS through 3GPP Rel’5. Yet, UMTS/HSDPA is not an end point, its future evolution will continue to enhance speed, performance and cost for vendors, carriers and customers.”

New Rel’6 features include E-DCH for providing significant uplink data capacity and throughput improvements, which should be incorporated in the HSUPA (High Speed Uplink Packet Access) update; advanced receivers to boost downlink through techniques such as smart antennas; and MBMS to enable more efficient broadcast and multicast services. There is also work underway on Release 7, with the key focus on VoIP, in areas such as reduced latency and more efficient delivery of real time IP services.

Among the key enhancements that will appear in Releases 6 and 7 and pave the way to an OFDM based technology are forward error correction, which the 3GPP has mandated in its multimedia broadcast multicast service (MBMS) standard, and combining radio channels to boost bandwidth. W-CDMA uses a 5MHz wide channel and doubling that would double the bandwidth.

Smart antenna and MIMO (multiple input multiple output) antenna technologies also are being evaluated, both considered essential in Wi-Fi and WiMAX.

Nokia also is pushing what it calls Internet-HSPA, which falls under the 3GPP standards. I-HSPA would provide a direct link from the base station to the internet, bypassing the network for a packet optimized connection. This end-to-end packet structure is similar to what Super 3G envisions but has an even more simplified or ‘flat’ network architecture that is also being developed by Motorola.