True to all the hype, Motorola and Apple launched their anticipated iTunes phone, with availability not just in the US through Cingular, but also in the UK through most cellular operators except Vodafone and later in September and October in France, Germany, Canada, Hong Kong, Australia, Singapore, Philippines, Argentina, Brazil and Mexico
But Apple missed a great opportunity to shut the market out for the rest of the music phones and, attractive as the device is, and as wide as the launch agreements are, the fact is that the E1 ROKR phone with iTunes does not sport a prominent Apple or iTunes logo and comes with only sufficient capacity for 100 songs.
Our first suspicion is that the small amount of storage capacity set aside for music has been deliberately truncated, which must be due to Apple wanting to preserve sales of its iPod music player range. If this is true, phones will emerge with far grater capacities and Motorola and Apple will have to shift the goalposts.
In our view Apple and Motorola should have gone for broke and either put a hard disk in each phone or enough capacity for the 240 songs that customers can get on a $99 iPod Shuffle. To store 100 four-minute songs, a handset needs about 384Mb – there are inexpensive flash chips out there that could offer 10 times that.
And there is no discussion yet about the operator getting revenue from downloading songs to the device. Instead the only route for songs to get on the phone is via a USB port from iTunes on a PC or a Mac.
While there were concerns that operators would make cellular the only route onto the phone, not having that route at all is to miss the opportunity for customers to hear music while out, have it play into their phones, be identified by centrally held software and then acquire it from iTunes, all in one transaction.
Perhaps we expected too much and it will all unveil later, as more storage gets onto these phones and as the operators have time to get their act together. We know that the ROKR phone (pronounced Rocker) – from comments from CEO Ed ZNDR (pronounced Zander) – will eventually play music videos once the rights and royalties can be sorted out. And that this is down the track somewhere. So this could be, like the iPod before it, a slow release capsule that gradually squeezes the best out of the iPod experience, but on today’s evidence we are not quite so bullish about the phone as we were before the announcement.
The device has the same easy navigation, has a single button music switch, the same sound quality with built in stereo speakers, and will be a pleasure for music lovers,
The price is $249.99 with iTunes pre-installed but needs a two-year commitment to Cingular and comes with includes stereo headphones and a USB cable.
Motorola will commence a global, month long, ad campaign tomorrow with music legends including Madonna, Little Richard, Alanis Morissette, The Bravery, Iggy Pop, Biggie Smalls, Ahmir and Beethoven.
The key questions are now how the initial Motorola-Apple venture will be enlarged upon, not just in terms of the device’s capacity but the partnerships surrounding it. How long will Cingular be the only provider (T-Mobile is already rumored to be planning to launch the device in Europe by Christmas)?
Will other phonemakers be able to license iTunes? (Nokia recently denied Finnish media reports that it would produce an iTunes phone early next year, but to make the Apple platform the leading one in the world, it will need to work with Nokia. After all, the cellphone market is 13 times larger than that for MP3 players in volume terms, and Nokia and Motorola together control almost two-thirds of it).
And, down the line, will Apple decide either to make its own music phone, or become a virtual network operator, or both, thus keeping a greater share of the iTunes revenue to itself, but also taking on the established cellcos and handset makers?
Various analysts are calling for Apple to go it alone, including, most recently, Gene Munster at Piper Jaffray and Albert Lin at American Technology Research. They argue that Apple will get a tiny piece of the $99 per track download fee, since most of this will be split between the handset maker, content owner and carrier. An Apple MVNO with Apple phones would not achieve the volume of a Cingular service, perhaps, but only the content owner and the network owner would need to be compensated, bringing it closer to the margins of the iPod/iTunes combination as well as giving greater prominence to the Apple brand.
‘We question Apple’s motive to partner with Motorola and not make any money when they themselves are a hardware manufacturer,’ Munster said in a research note this week. ‘We believe that if the long term threat to iPods is a cellphone/MP3 player combo, Apple should make its own iPod phone, turning the threat into an opportunity.’ Piper Jaffray research found that 18% of consumers would be interested in an Apple-made cellphone and would be prepared to pay $250 for one.