As the telecoms majors fix their sights on mobile WiMAX, the biggest revenue stream in the first year will come from the fixed technology operating as a backhaul option for Wi-Fi hotspots and hotzones, enterprises and 3G carriers. Although the attention of the WiMAX Forum has shifted away from early interest in point-to-point backhaul towards point-to-multipoint and access, many WiMAX vendors remain heavily focused on distribution uses, including Redline and Aperto. For relatively short distance backhaul requirements, WiMAX is likely to provide a low cost option that will see strong opportunities as the cellcos’ needs explode, but it will certainly not have the field to itself. The microwave backhaul specialists are determined to dominate a market that is really starting to mushroom with the advent of 3G, while other parties are also looking to replace the conventional leased T1 option, including cable, ‘wireless fiber’ and new approaches to tower layout.
Whatever the solution, the demand is rising steadily. Enterprises are looking to replace expensive T1 lines or to have redundant back-up networks, and this is boosting pre-WiMAX providers like TowerStream as well as established telecoms service providers. Hotspots and the growing breed of municipal hotzones are also looking for backhaul options that are more powerful than DSL but less costly than T1 multiples. But the biggest opportunity lies with the cellular carriers, which are facing a huge hike in backhaul capacity because of the smaller cells typical of 3G networks, and the increased bandwidth required by new applications.
A typical GSM operator deploys one or two 2Mbps backhaul connections per cell site, which is clearly insufficient for data intensive 3G applications. Many carriers believe between four and eight E1s will be needed for each 3G base station, and up to 16 once the HSDPA upgrade is implemented too. Cingular believes its backhaul costs will rise by 25% once it deploys HSDPA on a wide scale.
Of course, few carriers have a clear idea of how rapidly the usage of their data services will rise and so how much backhaul capacity will really be needed. Apart from lower operating costs, microwave options such as WiMAX and proprietary platforms have the added attraction of greater flexibility when bandwidth usage is unpredictable or fluctuating. The new breed of microwave backhaul systems ‘ such as the Harris TruePoint 4000 ‘ are software configurable in terms of the operating bandwidth, modulation and frequency, so that changes in the network usage do not require a hardware upgrade to the backhaul, and capacity is more easily scalable.
All of this means the 3G operators represent a huge market opportunity. Xtend Networks, which believes cable operators should start to poach T1 business (as Cox Communications, in particular, is starting to do), estimates that the sector is worth $20bn over the next five years in the US alone. Backhaul spending among US wireless carriers totals about $2.1bn, or about 11% of opex budgets, a figure that will rise to as much as 25% once data services are fully deployed (US figures are lower than many other countries because the major cellcos tend to be owned by wireline carriers with their own backhaul infrastructure).
As a global average, about 18% of cellco’s opex now goes on backhaul leasing and maintenance, and the figure increases threefold once the network is all-3G, according to Nortel. The situation is improved by moving to packet-based backhaul, notably IP, which can aggregate more traffic per leased line, but the combination of owned wireless lines and IP switching can have a dramatic effect on opex, bringing backhaul down to under 10% of the total if spectrum is owned (operators that are not using all their spectrum can even lease capacity to enterprises or other players to add a new revenue stream.)
Many large cellcos that have relied mainly on T1 connections are now looking at wireless alternatives, including Sprint Nextel, which is expanding its network not just because of its merger and upgrade to CDMA EV-DO, but also because it will be building a parallel pre-WiMAX network in 2.5GHz.
Vodafone is to build its own broadband wireless backhaul network to replace leased lines at most of its 8,000 base station sites in the UK. Like all 3G operators, Vodafone is facing mushrooming backhaul requirements and is under increasing pressure, as it sees its more optimistic hopes of 3G return on investment dissolving, to cut operating costs in order to preserve margins. Vodafone currently leases backhaul lines from BT and some smaller fixed line providers such as Kingston Communications. The operator’s original 1985 license terms barred it from building its own fixed infrastructure links, whether wired or wireless, but this ban was lifted in 2002. The UK cellcos have been moving rapidly towards wireless backhaul, partly because BT’s leasing charges remain high by European standards. T-Mobile (then One-2-One) and Orange were encouraged by Ofcom to build their own microwave backhaul networks when they entered the UK market in the mid-1990s, and were given some spectrum to support this, as a way to stimulate competition to BT. Orange relies on wireless for 90% of its backhaul capacity.
The holding of spectrum is a significant advantage, which Vodafone will not have ‘ Alcatel, which claims 35% market share of cellular wireless backhaul equipment, estimates that microwave options are 40% cheaper than leased lines if the carrier rents its spectrum, but 80% if the frequencies are owned, on average.
In the UK, backhaul leasing costs are based on distance, and range from typically range from £2,000 for less than 10 kilometers, to £6,000 for 30 kilometers. About half the sites will require the longer lines, making a total cost to a company like Vodafone about £32m a year for just one country, a sum that will grow with greater data requirements, multiple backhaul links per base station and the introduction of HSDPA. If a microwave network of the scale and robustness required by a cellco takes five years to break even, and typically has a working life of 10 years, the lure is, of course, five years of ‘free’ backhaul or about £150m in savings. In the US, a cell site fed by four T1s can cost an average of $1,600 monthly, while a microwave link might cost $100,000 upfront for equipment, license and installation and then a minimal amount to operate.
Carriers including Sprint and Cingular are looking to cut cost and improve efficiency by redrawing the network architecture ‘ and a popular strategy these days is to create aggregation points that draw in traffic from individual cell sites. One way to reduce backhaul costs is to consolidate cell sites and feed them with a wireless or wired backhaul pipe that is equivalent to 10 T1s, for instance, rather than several sites with three T1s. Higher capacity equipment is generally cheaper to maintain.
Some vendors are reporting demands for huge capacity products. NEC, for instance, offers a microwave top end product that delivers the equivalent of 16 OC-3 fiber connections or over 1,300 T1s. ‘We see in certain geographical areas now, there are places where planners want to see 16 T1s or even a DS3 [44.756Mbps] worth of capacity at each cell site,’ says the company.
Aggregation is the basis of the business model for FiberTower, which uses 155Mbps wireless radio links to combine traffic from multiple towers to central exchange points, whence it is forwarded via leased fiber optic links to the local telephony switch. FiberTower is investigating the potential of point-to-point WiMAX for some applications.
The company is building a backhaul system from scratch, dedicated to enabling wireless base stations to avoid T1s. Importantly, new microwave radios can be added in just a few days, compared to months for copper lines. It says its system, which it runs on behalf of tower owners and their tenants, reduces service outages by 50-60% for lower costs than leased T1 lines. Each exchange point takes in traffic from 15 to 20 towers, thereby eliminating the need for multiple T1s at each cell site. ‘What’s attractive certainly in the conversations that we have had with [carriers] is that it’s really prohibitively expensive to bring high capacity to every cell site in the US,’ says the company.
FiberTower recently has raised a fourth round of funding worth $150m, one of the largest of the year, and bringing the company’s total backing to $225m. Its major backers include three tower majors, with Crown Castle leading the new round alongside existing investors SpectraSite and American Tower (as well as various VC firms).