Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 September 2005

Nokia takes key role in Eclipse, in a new thrust for mobile Java

Nokia is clearly no longer just a handset maker. It knows that high margins and true influence over the industry rely on software and it has worked assiduously over the past three years to create a series of frameworks to challenge Microsoft as de facto standards, as the enterprise and home markets go increasingly mobile. Its efforts have focused on creating software architectures that are no longer confined to its handsets but can be openly licensed; on building relationships with developers that rival those of the Windows giant; and on forming key alliances with companies such as IBM, in order to push its technologies into the heart of the enterprise, thereby also driving uptake of its high end smartphones.

The latest step in this complex process, and one that epitomizes Nokia’s radical change of culture of the past year, is to take the lead in the first mobile-oriented activity within the influential Eclipse Foundation, which creates open source Java tools and is increasingly laying claim to being the most important software developer community outside Windows/.Net. Nokia, which announced limited support for Eclipse a year ago, now becomes a board member and lead developer, heading up all the activities to bring the Eclipse technologies to the mobile Java world.

The move reflects Nokia’s belief that Java, with its ability to span platforms from large servers to mobile and embedded devices, is the best way to break the Windows/Visual Studio .Net stranglehold. It increasingly sees Java and the upper layers of software ‘ such as its Series x0 user interface frameworks ‘ as more important would-be standards than the individual operating system, and has embraced Linux alongside the Symbian OS that it dominates, and which it once set up as a ‘Windows killer’ in the mobile world. A shift towards OS neutrality inevitably throws a keener light on interfaces and tools, and so Java has moved more firmly center stage in Nokia’s strategy, as has open source. It is not long since the Finnish giant kept its technologies tightly closed and would not license them to third parties, let alone place them in an open source process, but like its friend IBM, it sees the opportunity, by letting go tight control, of gaining wider influence and wrongfooting Microsoft.

Nokia has been putting an increasingly number of activities into the open source process, including its joint development of a mobile browser with Apple. Eclipse represents a new extension of this behavior and a sign that Nokia feels sufficiently confident to bid for a Microsoft-style position in mobile Java, which will underpin so many enterprise IT strategies in the coming years.

The Eclipse Foundation was originally set up by IBM in 2001 with $40m in seed money and a substantial donation of code, but was widely accused of being a ploy to sell its own software. However, once the giant spun the group off in 2004, it has rapidly become a focus for Java innovation that threatens to overshadow work by Java owner Sun and its associated groups. However, this is the first time that Eclipse has had a mobile company among its directors, giving Nokia the opportunity to lead this work as the Foundation adapts to the growing importance of small devices in its enterprise focused world.

The key Eclipse software is a framework for plugging in third party components so that different tools, including modellers and code editors, can be combined in a single user interface. Companies involved in Eclipse can also reach out to Java programmers using the increasingly popular Eclipse integrated development environment, which will be a key motivation for Nokia as it tries to build up a developer community to rival Microsoft’s.

Eclipse is now the dominant Java tools platform and the Foundation has 91 members, including most of the enterprise software majors, who felt free to join once it was no longer part of IBM but an independent non-profit body (though still heavily influenced by its original parent). It has unified most of the Java software industry, with the notable exception of Sun itself ‘ even Sun ally Oracle, which remained cool, has become more supportive this year. But Eclipse has addressed one of the key problems for Java, the way that it has been bogged down by its semi-open standards processes and a failure by Sun to unite the community. It has achieved critical mass on the tools side, and so offers to provide the most important weapon in the fight against Microsoft .Net, a common development environment into which all tools companies can plug their products. Availability and enthusiasm of developers for a platform can influence a company’s choice of back end server architecture and middleware, and so is vital to the major vendors.

This is a lesson that has been learned on the big platforms, and that Nokia has taken to heart in mobility. In the mobile world, Java has suffered even more from fragmentation among different interests and implementations than in its enterprise and desktop incarnations. There has been steady progress towards a more unified approach, which is essential to mass adoption of the platform outside the specialized smartphone arena. But this progress has been made via strong actions by powerful players, rather than through the Sun-driven Java Community Process. Most notably, a year ago Nokia and Vodafone joined forces to create a uniformity initiative to ‘simplify mobile Java standards by defining the next generation, open standards-based mobile Java services architecture specifications’ (see Wireless Watch August 26 2004). Taking Eclipse into the mobile world is another way to address the issues that hold Java back, and to counter the mobile implementations of Microsoft’s highly unified platform, Visual Studio.

Sun is competing for Java developer attention through its NetBeans open source project and is seeking to attract developers to that framework as an alternative to Eclipse, but it looks largely isolated, and is under pressure to accommodate Eclipse in the wider interest of its Java platform, rather than split the sector between two developer communities.

Nokia’s expanded activity within Eclipse will initially center on contributing code and developers to accelerate support for multiple tools within a single framework for J2ME. The phonemaker will donate several components of its existing Java development tools technology, as well as working to develop new software to introduce tools for the creation of both applications for both core J2ME profiles, Mobile Information Device Profile and Connected Device Configuration. Nokia also will use Eclipse tools widely in its own tools portfolio and contribute to existing Eclipse projects. “We plan to use the Eclipse platform significantly going forward and use it to build our mobile tools on top of it,” said the president of the Forum Nokia developer organization, Heikki Koivu.

Nokia’s involvement will bring together two communities of developers of about the same size, at 2m. All this should make it more easy and attractive for Java programmers to develop interesting applications for Series x0 (which is licensed by other phonemakers such as Siemens/BenQ, and which Nokia aims to establish as a de facto standard). It will also ensure that Nokia has the strongest say over how mobile Java frameworks evolve, as these become more strategic to enterprise oriented vendors such as IBM and Oracle.

“We’ll be putting people and resources into leading the Eclipse open source project,” said Heikki Koivu, director of developer platform tools for Forum Nokia. “What we’re after is to bring efficiency to developers and make them more competitive. In the end, we hope that introduces an increased number of all types of applications. We’re expecting to see impact across all fields.”

A recent study by Forrester Research estimated that the Eclipse platform is used in half of all IT organizations that use Java, and as many as 75% of Java development teams. Eclipse also does work with C++ tools and is expanding its remit into web tools.

“The battle to be the leading development tools integration framework – at least, outside the Microsoft sphere of influence – is over, and Eclipse has won, even if some vendors have not yet conceded,” Carl Zetie, a Forrester analyst, wrote.