As the major operators’ plans to deploy end-to-end IP networks and the IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) approach reality, a flood of acquisitions and reorganizations will take place among their key equipment suppliers. Small and large vendors with proven expertise in all-IP will be an attractive target as all the majors seek to put themselves in a leading position for the expected boom of 2006-8.
Some vendors have their eyes on start-ups to bolster their technology armory, with the latest reports surrounding Motorola and all-IP CDMA company Airwalk; others are looking for larger prey, with troubled Marconi likely to be on the auction block; still others would benefit from searching for possible acquirers in order to capitalize on their strengths. Among these we would identify Nortel, whose current reorganization around IP networks may not be enough to put it back in the front line of vendors, despite its platform strengths.
Motorola said in March that it was looking for future investments and acquisitions in core technologies, particularly small companies that could plug gaps in its range as it seeks to compensate for weaknesses in its 3G performance, and take the lead in converged IP networks. Three-year old AirWalk, which has raised $8m in first round funding, would fit the bill because it claims the industry’s first ‘integrated voice and data IP base station transceiver (BTS) and base station controller (BSC) system’ for CDMA. ‘Our system is totally IP-based from end to end, not just on the backhaul,’ said CEO Serge Pequeux. ‘Our competitors are still selling legacy network equipment.’
Other vendors will look to boost their all-IP roadmaps with more ambitious purchases, with Marconi the best chance to snap up strong technology and some good clients, probably at a bargain price, given the company’s recent financial turmoil and its failure to secure part of the multibillion pound 21st Century Network project at its largest customer, BT. China’s Huawei has been widely tipped to bid for Marconi to accelerate its expansion into western markets, but Ericsson is now being widely rumored to be taking an interest too.
This would make sense for the Swedish giant, which despite its recent turnaround, is looking vulnerable in the converged networks world because it has only small presence in wireline systems (about 3% of its revenues), has pulled out of CDMA, made only token gestures towards WiMAX, and has seen its huge market share in GSM become less impressive in 3G. Marconi would bring it technology and expertise in wireline and converged systems, notably well respected optical and fixed access systems. It would also bring knowledge of BT’s legacy voice networks, which would help Ericsson deliver its portion of the 21CN project, the Intelligent Node softswitch. Winning a key role in this massive program, which is also likely to be a template for other large operators, was a major boost for Ericsson in its bid to move beyond cellular-only providers towards converged carriers. While Ericsson is a long standing supplier of TDM voice equipment to BT, the core TDM voice network is built around Marconi System X technology, and BT needs to upgrade this user base to all-IP.
Marconi has been enhancing its own all-IP strategy, which will be essential to make it attractive to purchasers. Last week it outlined its IMS roadmap for fixed-mobile convergence, claiming the lowest cost of ownership of the available solutions even though it is coming in rather late compared to the well regarded IMS suppliers, including Ericsson itself.
Nortel is another equipment maker that has had its share of financial troubles, and has been the subject of takeover rumors, notably concerning Cisco. The Canadian company has undergone a reorganization, in readiness for an assault on the IP market where it should be in a strong position technologically, with its advanced IMS ‘ the focus of a joint venture with IBM ‘ and its strong tradition in convergence. It has divided its products along customer lines ‘ carrier and enterprise ‘ rather than platform type, and aims to increase its share of the latter market and chip into Cisco’s dominance. The Enterprise Solutions and Packet Networks unit will be headed up by Steve Slattery, and the Mobility and Converged Core Networks arm by Richard Lowe. This ends the separation of the mobile operations and combines them with core networks technologies.
Nortel already has huge presence in carrier IP networks, with a market leading position on 21% share, followed by Siemens on 14% and Cisco on 7% (dell’Oro figures). In Layer 2-7 switches, it is in second place to Cisco, but with a huge gap ‘ 4.4% to the giant’s 71%. And Nortel wants to fill in gaps in its enterprise and metro area network, notably edging in alongside Cisco and Juniper in switches and routers. In this sector, Cisco has 75% market share, with Juniper second on 16%. Another area where Nortel has respectable standing is mobile infrastructure, where it ranks fifth with 10.2%, behind Ericsson’s 28.8%, followed by Siemens, Nokia and Lucent. But the Canadian contender’s share has been falling and needs to be rejuvenated through selling mobility as part of a converged offering ‘ an area where it should be able to claw back some points from its Swedish rival. Customers moving from traditional PBX exchanges to converged networks have also been identified by Nortel as a major opportunity to grow is already robust business, in which its 11.7% is third behind Avaya on 17.6% and Siemens.
With all these opportunities, and some very advanced R&D programs, including its OFDM-based submission to the 3GPP project, Nortel still has to find the financial stability to be able to exploit its advantages before stronger rivals catch up. This situation makes it a natural acquisition target, as we have analyzed before, for a large vendor seeking a kickstart in convergence ‘ whether Cisco as a route up to the carrier market, or IBM to bolster its all-IP integrator activities.
Whatever Nortel’s fate, the next two years will see significant consolidation in the converged systems market, and some shifts in the market shares of the major players.
Nokia’s fixed-mobile convergence
Nokia is stepping up its activities in fixed-mobile convergence and said its VoIP server is already in trials, targeting wireline telcos that want to mobilize their services, and so opening up a new market for the Finnish company.
The company said its Fixed Mobile Convergence solution offers fixed, mobile and hybrid operators an evolution to next generation networks, enabling wireline operators to offer new services and connectivity within the fixed network domain.
Jussi Ilmarinen, director of convergence sales and marketing, said: ‘Fixed operators can leverage their competitive advantage by rolling out VoIP on top of broadband, while adding mobility to differentiate their offering. They can also modernize their networks with a solution that provides a smooth evolution path to multimedia services. At the same time, mobile operators can implement VoIP and thereby transform their existing network and voice services into a unified offering across mobile and broadband domains.’
Nokia has signed a memorandum of understanding with Brazilian carrier Telemar to begin trials of the Fixed Mobile Convergence platform. Telemar operates the largest fixed network in South America, with around 15m subscribers, as well as the Oi branded mobile network, which currently caters to around 8m subscribers.
The trial uses a Nokia end-to-end solution for unified core and converged access networks, as well as Nokia terminals providing multimedia and VoIP services for both mobile and fixed customers. The Nokia unified core includes the IMS for voice calls and multimedia services, the VoIP Server, and the MSC Server System (MSS). The agreement also includes testing of the Nokia Unlicensed Mobile Access (UMA) solution for extending fixed broadband networks.
IMS interoperability
Critical to the future success of IMS deployments will be interoperability between different operators’ networks. The GSM Association, which represents carriers using GSM and W-CDMA technology, has started a series of trials in Europe and Asia to ensure that SIP and IMS based services will work together and avoid roaming problems that have dogged some other advances such as MMS messaging.
The latest round of GSMA-led tests focused on ensuring the compatibility of systems that handle IPv6, billing, performance management and inter-hub connectivity. They followed on from successful tests of IMS applications, such as voice instant messaging, video sharing and gaming, which were completed in February.
As part of the initiative, initially started in Europe, the GSMA brought together key players from the mobile network operator, GRX carriers and vendor communities. Those participating in the European trial, which is led by TeliaSonera, include mobile operators Vodafone, Orange and KPN. TeliaSonera International Carrier and KPN are also involved as GRX carriers along with Cable & Wireless and France Telecom.
All the GRX carriers have now developed hubs to support IMS interworking and, as part of the testing, have successfully achieved and demonstrated hub-to-hub connectivity including interworking between IPv6 IMS systems and between IMS IPv6 systems and IMS IPv4 systems.
Ericsson, Nokia and Siemens have been actively involved with the trials and the Nokia 6680 handset was used for video sharing applications. The past six months has also seen the expansion of the GSMA’s IMS testing programme into the Asia Pacific Region, involving China Mobile, CSL, Hutchinson HK, SingTel, Smart, SmarTone-Vodafone and Vodafone KK as well as GRX carriers Aicent, Belgacom and Cable & Wireless.
Additional tests are planned to test technologies and standardized mobile services like those of the Open Mobile Alliance.
All-IP in the enterprise
Convergent networks are rapidly becoming the norm in the enterprise market, according to a new Economist Intelligence Unit survey, which estimates that almost 25% of global businesses now employ an IP communications platform.
In a sign that global service providers may be making an impact with their managed IP services strategies, the survey found that almost half of all businesses consider converged services a key factor in meeting their goals and that new and emerging services are likely to see a rapid increase in take-up over the next three years. For 45% of the executives surveyed, convergence is ‘important’ or ‘critical’ to achieving their strategic IT and business objectives, while only 4% view it as ‘unimportant.’
It said, until recently, companies mainly saw converged platforms as a way to reduce network cost, but there is now far greater emphasis on how to use convergence to innovate and add value, particularly to improve customer service. Improved security was also perceived as a bonus.