Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 October 2005

Nokia and Ericsson claim GSM450 will support $5 ARPU

Operators can make a profit on charging consumers just $5 a month for mobile services, if they use the 450MHz spectrum, according to Nokia. Such a pricing level, combined with the emerging breed of sub-$100 handsets, will make cellular services far more viable for large sections of the population in developing economies. With that huge potential market in mind, as well as the increasing use of 450MHz spectrum in eastern Europe and rural areas, Nokia and Ericsson are to develop an implementation of GSM for this band, seeking to prevent CDMA450 from taking a monopoly position in an increasingly valuable frequency.

The 450MHz band, which has been vacated in many countries by the analog mobile telephony services, is attractive to operators because it can support very large cell sizes ‘ requiring about 16 times fewer base stations to provide similar coverage in similar terrain, compared to 1.8GHz, for instance. This makes it cost effective to build out sparsely populated rural areas that may be economically non-viable to cover with 3G (see Wireless Watch October 7 2005).

In developing economies where high bandwidth services may not yet be required, it can also be an option for more populous areas, allowing voice and basic data to be delivered very cost efficiently and justifying the $5 ARPU quoted by Nokia.

Much of the early activity in 450MHz has been in south east Asia and eastern Europe, though there is also interest in Africa and Latin America. The only technology on offer until recently was CDMA450, which was upgraded last year to provide a 2.5G CDMA2000 option. Companies like Lucent, Ericsson and, most successfully, ZTE, offered 450MHz CDMA equipment and Qualcomm went so far as to buy up spectrum, through its majority owned affiliate Inquam, to ensure the proliferation of CDMA450 and the related CDMA-PAMR.

Other options have been emerging as the spectrum has become more actively used round the world. Flarion and Siemens developed a 450MHz version of Flash-OFDM, which was widely expected to be adopted by T-Mobile when it acquired a national German license, but whose fate is now uncertain following Qualcomm’s acquisition of the start-up. And IPWireless promised a 450MHz implementation of the broadband wireless technology, UMTS TDD.

However, a GSM450 platform from Nokia and Ericsson is a far more credible alternative to CDMA450 and shows how this spectrum band is now expected to take a major role in growth markets such as Africa, rather than remaining, as was once expected, in a niche of rural access. The Scandinavian giants may also have been spurred into action by the willingness of the Swedish regulator to allow 3G operators to buy up 450MHz licenses and use these to deliver services to rural areas. This move, echoed in Finland, would effectively break the GSM/W-CDMA monopoly of western Europe for the first time, with the regulator prepared to be flexible on the previous European insistence that only W-CDMA could be used to deliver 3G, provided the users covered by the 450MHz network did not suffer a lower quality of offering.

Faced with CDMA at their back door and the risk of losing many high growth emerging markets, Nokia and Ericsson have responded with initiatives that could stem the Qualcomm tide, and also prolong the life of GSM technologies as the mainstream networks migrate to W-CDMA. “The GSM450 frequency can provide a way of giving consumers and operators a choice in taking full advantage of the affordability of GSM technology,” said Soren Petersen, senior vice president of Nokia Mobile Phones.

“Ericsson GSM 450 will particularly help to bring mobile services to remote areas previously considered not feasible to cover,” Ericsson stated. “Better coverage with lower operating costs is one result of the new technology.”

GSM networks currently operate at frequencies of 900MHz, 1.8GHz and 1.9GHz. Nokia and Ericsson have developed some products in the 450MHz frequency in the past, but never marketed them actively. In future, GPRS, EDGE and even 3G implementations could be made for 450MHz, and GSM450 base stations can work alongside those in higher frequencies. Ericsson base stations and Nokia handsets should be available in mid-2006.