Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 October 2005

Eastern Europe epitomizes new choices for 3G operators

Whatever the merits of the broadband wireless technologies versus 3G and HSDPA, operators that have invested in 3G spectrum and networks are hardly likely to switch to a new technology for their next generation services. However, there is an increasing recognition by large cellcos that they may achieve improved margins and cost per bit if they implement an alternative network alongside 3G (where the regulator allows).

This can be for two, apparently contrasting, reasons. One is to deliver premium services and offload some heavy duty traffic from the precious 3G frequencies ‘ for instance with a dedicated mobile television network or a broadband wireless system constructed for a location with high bandwidth demands, such as a business park. The other is to use a more cost effective platform than 3G where the location does not justify an expensive system. This may be because it is too sparsely populated to deliver a return on the dense base station configurations required by 3G, or because it contains many low value users.

The latter will become increasingly common as operators break down their walled gardens and allow subscribers to roam freely on the internet, and worse, are forced to enable this for a flat rate charge. While some users will remain high value because they will purchase the premium services offered for extra charges by the carrier, others will use a great deal of bandwidth on VoIP and internet services that bring no revenue to the cellco. There will be rising interest in seeking to offload some of this unprofitable traffic on to lower cost networks and spectrum ‘ ironically, where Wi-Fi and the low end of the WiMAX ranges can become the cellco’s friend. In the 3G operator’s ideal world, everybody would stay within the walled garden, paying for data by time or megabyte. With that situation no longer possible, supporting a combination of cellular and IP technologies will actually prove more economically sound than clinging to 3G alone in many cases.

Eastern Europe is one of the best examples of this new fluidity in network choices among the 3G community. The major cellcos all operate in at least some countries in the region and see it as a source of strong growth, yet they are not as firmly tied to W-CDMA as in the western countries because they have not yet undergone major build-outs, and regulators tend to be more flexible. So we are seeing some of the broadband wireless technologies being adopted as complements to 3G, and in some cases, we suspect, they may be substitutes. Not that WiMAX is the only contender. Indeed, since it has, as yet, no profile for 450MHz, it is excluded from one of the key growth areas in eastern Europe, where licenses for this spectrum are being rapidly allocated because of its propagation qualities and potential to cover sparsely populated areas cost effectively.

This is where the Flarion Flash-OFDM technology has scored its first major commercial deployment, with T-Mobile in Slovakia. But the German cellco, which has one of the most complex technology roadmaps, embracing Wi-Fi, HSDPA, Flarion, UMTS TDD and potentially WiMAX, is certainly keeping its options open and looking to select the right network for each individual market. Therefore, in the same week as going live with the Flarion roll-out, it also announced the commercial launch of a services based on IPWireless’ UMTS TDD broadband wireless technology in the neighboring Czech Republic.

Also demonstrating the rapid development and technological complexity of this region, Orange chose the same week to announce its own plans in Slovakia, also centered on UMTS TDD.

Since Flarion – maker of the Flash-OFDM broadband wireless technology and recently acquired by Qualcomm ‘ signed with Siemens to codevelop a 450MHz version of the platform, it has been expected to sell the solution to T-Mobile, a major Siemens customer and holder of 450MHz spectrum in Germany and other countries. Flarion’s first commercial roll-out in Europe has finally been announced, with T-Mobile deploying Flash-OFDM in 450MHz in Slovakia.

The German cellco, which is also testing Flash-OFDM in higher frequencies in the Netherlands, has an advanced multi-network strategy in Europe and the US. It is looking to broadband wireless technologies to complement its 3G systems by supporting high bandwidth applications, extending reach into sparsely populated areas and even expanding into enterprise and fixed wireless applications. It has built an extensive network of Wi-Fi hotspots in the US and Europe and is using IPWireless UMTS TDD equipment across the Czech Republic and now Flarion in Slovakia. It has also been rumored to be interested in using Flash-OFDM in its national holdings of 450MHz licenses in Germany.

From this week, the T-Mobile Slovakia service is available in parts of the capital Bratislava and in 19 other cities. It will take the carrier into fixed and portable services and enable it to offer broadband access to underserved regions. ‘By launching our Fast Internet service using Flash-OFDM technology, we are making a giant leap in increasing the lagging broadband internet penetration in Slovakia,’ said Robert Chvatal, CEO of T-Mobile Slovakia. ‘We want to provide a broadband internet choice also outside of big cities and increase the choice beyond DSL and cable.’

The 450MHz spectrum is increasingly in the spotlight because of its ability to support large cell sizes and, therefore, cost effective coverage of sparsely populated areas. In particular, it has been licensed for broadband wireless and cellular use in eastern Europe, Scandinavia and many parts of Africa and south east Asia. The main technology in the band is CDMA450, but now Flarion and IPWireless have implementations for the frequency and Ericsson and Nokia last week announced initiatives to develop GSM450. So far, there is no indication of a WiMAX profile for this band. The new importance of 450MHz is the main short term opportunity for Qualcomm’s platforms ‘ now with the two-pronged attack of CDMA450 and Flash-OFDM ‘ to gain a beach head in the European market from which it has been excluded by the uniform adoption of GSM.

But IPWireless also plays in the 450MHz space, and it is gradually gaining favor with tier one cellcos, mainly in eastern Europe. Its technology once seemed like a natural fit for UMTS license holders, since most of them gained TDD (unpaired) spectrum, well suited to broadband data applications, along with their primary FDD allowances. UMTS TDD, mainly backed by IPWireless and UTStarcom, but part of the 3GPP standards, offers the packet-based and data optimized strand of the platform, which is deployed in unpaired spectrum, with separate uplink and downlink But in reality, UMTS TDD has mainly been used by last mile providers of fixed wireless services, such as UK Broadband or Germany’s AirData, and has only recently gained ground in the mobile world, notably in Japan, where spectrum has been dedicated to the TDD platform, and now with Orange and T-Mobile.

Orange is testing the solution in four cities in France and now in Slovakia, and is also reported by Merrill Lynch to have unannounced trials in Romania and Poland. The various projects show the different uses to which a 3G operator may put broadband wireless, as described above. In France, the likely aim will be to provide a parallel network for premium services such as enterprise offerings. In eastern Europe, the objective will be to provide cost effective coverage for rural or low income areas, and possibly to bypass 3G altogether in some regions.

The Slovakia trial network will operate in the 1.9GHz UMTS spectrum and promises peak speeds of 5Mbps in a 5MHz unpaired channel. Orange is also testing HSDPA, with a view to assessing how well the two networks inteoperate, which offers the best raw performance and cost per bit, and so whether a hybrid system, with different access networks in different locations, would be viable. There is also the opportunity, in a country where many regions have low broadband penetration, to offer fixed access services too, to generate higher ARPU and greater customer control through a fixed-mobile convergence platform. While HSDPA may evolve to provide this capability (see separate item), initially UMTS TDD would be a more viable platform, but could be converged with the 3G services as they use the same frequencies.

‘Both alternatives have their advantages. They enable high transfer and low latency rates that will compete with fixed line broadband,’ said Dana Prekopov’, technical director of Orange Slovensko.

T-Mobile is also looking to offer fixed-mobile convergence for data and video as well as voice, with its deployment of UMTS TDD in the Czech Republic. The German giant said it intends to convince its subscribers that there is ‘no reason to keep fixed lines’, and further strengthen its position as the number one operator in the republic.

The launch in capital Prague featured demonstrations of streaming TV and music, videoconferencing, enterprise web collaboration tools, online gaming and very high speed internet. The service, branded Internet 4G, is available for €24 for 512Kbps and €34 for 1Mbps. T-Mobile will extend the service to 85 cities and the bulk of the population within one year. It will offer subscribers a dual-mode, dual-band PCMCIA card that will allow access to the TDD network and also the current cellular network, based on EDGE, which will be upgraded to 3G and HSDPA over time.

It boasts that its plan makes it the first tier one mobile operator in the world to commit to a national end-to-end mobile IP network based on next generation technology.

‘Internet 4G gives our subscribers full connectivity to work and play on the go, and provides a connection that’s fast enough to replace the home fixed connection,’ said Roland Mahler, managing director of T-Mobile Czech.

When T-Mobile announced the Czech trial in May, it stressed that it remained fully committed to building its 3G network in the country, with the more usual FDD version of UMTS. Despite these positive noises though, T-Mobile has been one of the slowest European cellcos to roll out 3G, claiming it will wait (as long as the regulators will let it) until the technology is robust and demand proven. The adoption of a data-oriented overlay in a key growth market will increase speculation that T-Mobile finds the business model for conventional 3G lacking.

Some important wins in the mobile arena will fuel claims by all the broadband wireless technologies ‘ TDD, Flash-OFDM and WiMAX ‘ that W-CDMA is inadequate to deliver the whole set of services that mobile operators need to offer if they are to fend off wireline or start-up operators with all-IP systems. If the cellcos had spent fewer billions of euros on the spectrum and networks for W-CDMA, it would be acceptable to their business planners and shareholders to confine the technology to just part of a patchwork, but that is a hard call to make when those shareholders will be calling for clear ROI on the 3G investment before the carriers start talking about multi-network strategies.

IPWireless has been working to increase the appeal of its technology to tier one cellcos looking for a parallel, all-IP network for convergence or overlay applications. In August, it extended the IP core features in its products, bringing some of the capabilities of an IP core to the UMTS air interface.

The new release of IPWireless’ technology should appeal to such service providers by offering some features of an IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) ‘ the key software for managing the all-IP network and the basis of a promised new generation of wireless services ‘ immediately in a 3G network. These include full operator control of packet prioritization and QoS on a service-by-service basis, for more efficient network usage and a better customer experience. Premium corporate, VoIP, gaming or video applications can be assigned the optimum network resources and will not be impacted by network congestion, while latency insensitive applications are held back. ‘This allows operators to charge more for premium services while still exploiting mass market demands,’ said IPWireless

The packet prioritization platform inspects all the packets on both the uplink and downlink and works with the network scheduler to prioritize these packets based on operator defined preferences in the network management system. Operators can prioritize packets based on both the type of service, as well as the type of user.

This is the kind of move that WiMAX vendors will need to make, to ensure their platform is attractive to the largest mobile operators. Recent announcements by Lucent and Alcatel on the IMS front were a major boost, but all the broadband wireless technologies are in a race to fill the cellco’s need for a parallel network and a stepping stone to fixed-mobile convergence and all-IP.