Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 November 2005

Swedish regulator deals blow to technology neutrality

The coming months will offer stronger indications of whether the European Union will become a technology neutral zone when it awards new 3G licenses, or stick to its traditional policy of mandating certain platforms ‘ notably W-CDMA ‘ for these valuable bands. The resulting policies will have far reaching impact on the value of the spectrum and the chances for non-cellcos to enter the mobile market along with alternative technologies like WiMAX. A small blow to their hopes was struck last week when Swedish regulator PTS refused to let 3G carriers use CDMA450 instead of W-CDMA in certain sparsely populated territories, where it is hard to gain return on investment in dense 3G networks.

This is not a key indicator of how Europe will go ‘ the Scandinavian countries, homes of 3G giants Ericsson and Nokia, are naturally among the most hostile to network neutrality. But it does remove for now the prospect of a CDMA technology infiltrating a W-CDMA market in Europe (a few areas, such as Finland, have allocated 450MHz licenses recently for additional networks, but not as a replacement for building out 3G).

In June, PTS said it would consider a petition to use 450MHz technologies in rural areas by Hutchison and Vodafone (now selling its Swedish unit to Telenor, perhaps partly because of the adverse decision). This raised the prospect that major operators might use 450MHz technologies ‘ mainly CDMA but IPWireless and Flash-OFDM are also options – actually to replace 3G in their roll-out roadmaps, breaking the uniformity of GSM and its successors that Europe has guarded so carefully.

The ability to gain return on investment on 3G systems is increasingly doubtful in some areas, as cellcos face new competition from broadband wireless combined with looming deadlines to bring 3G services to 95% or more of the populations of many countries. The long signal range and spectral efficiency of 450MHz systems make coverage of a sparse population more cost effective than with the dense base station patterns needed for W-CDMA.

In Sweden, it was estimated that Vodafone and Hutchison could save about $400m between them by using the 3G version of CDMA450 instead of W-CDMA for rural areas. One option was to lease an existing network run by Nordisk Mobiltelefon, which holds 450MHz spectrum, and which said it would spend about SKr300m to upgrade to CDMA EV-DO and so support the applications required by the two giants.

Vodafone and Hutchison are cooperating on building a 3G network in areas outside major cities in Sweden. It is estimated that to complete their coverage obligations they will need a further 2,000 rural base stations, but using CDMA450, this number could have been reduced to about 140.

TeliaSonera, which is building out 3G with Tele2, opposed the idea, saying it would amount to an anti-competitive subsidy for its rivals. PTS seems to have taken on board its arguments ‘ which will be repeated on a massive scale across the EU in the coming year, as 3G operators will argue that their huge investment in their licenses should mean that alternative companies are not allowed into their back yards. PTS said that all three 3G carriers must continue to use W-CDMA, arguing that it is not currently possible to cross this with other technologies without adverse effects for the consumer, particularly in terms of handset availability. However, the operators were given one concession, with PTS reducing the requirement regarding signals from the base stations in certain areas so the carriers can reduce the number of base stations for the remaining roll-out by up to 25%.