How much should we read into companies joining industry groups in support of specific technologies? Not always too much ‘ after all, the Flarion Alliance numbered about 25 big name members from Philips to Sun in its heyday but only had a couple of commercial customers when it was acquired this year by Qualcomm.
However, these alliances can be an interesting indicator of the way that operators and vendors are thinking and the complexity of the choices they are now making. So Sprint Nextel, the poster child for the WiMAX vendors with its planned 2.5GHz national roll-out and trials with Motorola and Samsung, has joined the UMTS TDD Forum, which supports a WiMAX alternative for mobile broadband.
And what of several Korean majors joining the FLO Forum – which supports Qualcomm’s Forward Link Only OFDM-based multimedia delivery platform – just as they seemed set to devour the child they helped give birth to. Samsung and the Korean telcos, whose support was crucial in enabling Qualcomm’s CDMA to become a viable alternative to GSM, have recently been devising their own alternatives to platforms controlled by the US chipmaker, from mobile WiMAX to the WIPI content delivery system, a replacement for Qualcomm Brew. And they have been expected to focus on the Digital Media Broadcasting (DMB) standard for mobile television roll-out, rather than taking an interest in MediaFLO, the TV system based on FLO.
Yet Korea Telecom Freetel, Samsung and two other Korean companies, EBS and MSYS, have joined the list of FLO supporters, whose total number is now 25. KT itself and LG are already members.
Meanwhile, the Global UMTS TDD Alliance ‘ which backs the time division variant of the UMTS standard, as mainly promoted by IPWireless and UTStarcom ‘ has added two of its most high profile commercial adopters, T-Mobile Czech Republic and Maxis of Malaysia to its membership, bringing its list to over 50. However, the real catch in its latest recruitment drive is Sprint Nextel. Although Nextel had announced a UMTS TDD trial in June, this was widely expected to be sidelined post-merger as the combined operators focus on WiMAX trials for their 2.5GHz spectrum.
Joining the Alliance at this juncture suggests that Sprint Nextel is at least maintaining its interest in UMTS TDD for certain applications or markets ‘ or seeking to prevent WiMAX suppliers becoming complacent. In fact, TDD is an odd choice for Nextel, which had also successfully trialled Flarion Flash-OFDM, given that neither it nor Sprint uses UMTS technologies already. Although TDD runs as a standalone system, its appeal in the mobile arena is often to W-CDMA carriers that have TDD spectrum and can integrate the two networks. The internal customer trial is running in Washington DC and is due to kick off shortly in parts of Virginia and Bethesda, Maryland.
All these activities may merely represent operators keeping their options open, or vendors maintaining a watchful eye on potentially competitive technologies. But they indicate that the next generation of mobile communications will not rest on just one or two homogeneous platforms, but on a patchwork held together by software and carrier alliances. The burden of expectation being placed on mobile broadband will only be borne by casting aside the religious approach to technology ‘ which has already marred the European move to 3G ‘ and taking a best of breed approach that will, in turn, drive new and innovative alliances of its own.