Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 December 2005

The latest on RIM

With Nokia, Microsoft and now Vodafone fighting for the mobile push email market, the chances of Research in Motion retaining its market leadership for long are very limited. But the popularity of its BlackBerry system and its large installed base still make its legal problems of concern to many enterprises, and last week saw further twists in the convoluted saga.

With the odd accidents of timing that have beset this story, the US Patent and Trademarks Office (PTO) rejected one of the key patents at issue in the fight with NTP, just a day after a federal judge ruled against RIM.

The judge invalidated the settlement made last year between RIM and patent holder NTP, an agreement that RIM later backed away from, a move that could in theory allow NTP to enforce an injunction awarded before that deal, stopping sales of BlackBerry. Although RIM says it has a workaround ready that would bypass the disputed intellectual property, the confusion around BlackBerry’s fate can only hasten the shift of the enterprise and government sectors towards systems based on more stable platforms, such as open systems or Windows. Not that there is likely to be an immediate shutdown for BlackBerry, even if US District Judge James Spencer makes a final ruling against RIM, not least because the US federal government has filed papers arguing that the service is essential to government functioning and therefore cannot be allowed to shut down.

Moreover, the PTO has already issued a preliminary judgment that invalidates all eight of the NTP patents and has now confirmed this ruling on one of them, though ironically, its final decisions could come too late to prevent an injunction and a subsequent lengthy process to get it overturned.