Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 December 2005

Spoiling tactics may have fatally delayed 802.11n agreement

The most recent meeting of the IEEE in Vancouver produced no progress on the 802.11n fast Wi-Fi standard, and key members such as Airgo admitted it could now be tough to achieve their aim of completing a specification by March 2007. This could be playing right into the hands of the Enhanced Wireless Consortium (EWC), a breakaway group of companies led by the main Wi-Fi chipmakers, which is coming up with its own specification and could well beat 802.11n to the post.

Although the formation of the EWC earlier this year ‘ just as it seemed the various proposals before the IEEE could finally be converged – was a major factor in the delays that are now afflicting that process, the Consortium uses time to market as the main justification for its activities. Intel, a key mover in the EWC, used the same arguments ‘ with rather more credibility ‘ in UltraWideBand when it took the WiMedia proposal out of the standards body to avoid the gridlock between two battling factions within the IEEE. With its backers in EWC, which include Broadcom, Cisco and Atheros, it is also claiming it can get a usable standard to market more quickly than the IEEE, which is essential since there are already many products available that offer proprietary extensions to support 802.11n-like speeds of well over 100Mbps. And the demand for these is growing for applications such as in-home digital networks.

The EWC is correct that the IEEE badly needs to reform its processes in order to speed up standards creation in line with market demands ‘ or risk all wireless platforms being decided by powerful de facto standards groups. But it is ironic that the EWC was formed just when it seemed that 802.11n was avoiding the problems of its UWB sister standards, with the two main contenders agreeing to bury their differences and devise a converged proposal. This should now be presented at the next meeting in January but could well face competition in the commercial market from an EWC platform that is attracting major backing from chipmakers ‘ keen to dilute the early advantage of start-up Airgo, whose technology is set to be core to the 802.11n proposal ‘ and the vital consumer electronics manufacturers, which hold the largest key to Wi-Fi growth in their hands.