Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 December 2005

Pan-European MVNO risks over dependence on EU politics

The rise of Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs) has been one of the key trends of the past few years, with companies ‘ not necessarily from the telecoms world ‘ leasing spectrum and capacity on cellcos’ networks in order to offer own branded services. Some have been very successful and disruptive – either because of their low cost base and no-frills offerings, as in the case of EasyMobile, or their well targeted branding, like Virgin Mobile’s.

But far too many such operators are appearing on the scene, lacking the large scale base required for a low cost model or the strong brand power. This will lead to roll-out delays, failures and consolidation, and achieving a user base of a size to support profitable growth will become increasingly difficult in the busiest markets. One solution may be for smaller MVNOs to band together, to gain stronger negotiating power with the network owners and handset makers and larger target audiences. They could even adopt a common brand, a pattern most common in the US ‘ as the US cable companies are likely to do as part of their complex deal with Sprint Nextel, or as a group of midsized rural operators have been doing for years by buying into the umbrella ‘Cellular One’ label. Now the most ambitious attempt to create a ‘super-MVNO’ is coming from Europe, with the recently launched MVNO Global initiative sending an open letter to Viviane Reding, the European Union Information Society and Media Commissioner, to try to get EU backing as the body looks to improve communications quality and consistency across its broadening territory.

MVNO Global’s aims to become part of the EU’s ‘Lisbon Strategy’ framework which hs the broad aim of turning Europe into the world’s most dynamic and competitive economy by 2010.

‘The global footprint of the MVNO Global venture plans to cover EU25 countries and beyond, performing unified and centralized service platforms. The MVNO Global initiative supports the Single European Information Space concept, by offering affordable and secure high bandwidth communications, rich and diverse content and digital services,” the letter says.

The initiative believes there would be major competitive advantages for operators able to treat the EU as a single territory in the same way that US carriers can. However, there are other groupings with far greater power, budget and influence with the EU taking a similar tack, especially as the new and future EU entrants in the eastern part of the continent open up the prospect of new growth markets. Vodafone, for all its vulnerabilities, remains the best example, with a genuinely international reach and brand, and is now being challenged by alliances of large and midsized cellcos looking to combine their purchasing power, roaming and even some branding, especially when chasing the multinational corporate market. Freemove ‘ led by Orange, T-Mobile, Telefonica and TIM ‘ and the Starmap Alliance are the best examples, although Starmap initiator O2 will presumably change ranks once it is acquired by Telefonica. Then there is the overlapping group of operators that use the NTT DoCoMo i-Mode content delivery system, which it aims to establish as an international brand in its own right.

So the MVNO Global Initiative needs to find a real unique proposition for business and consumer users, more urgently than it needs EU support. Europe is slowly moving away from the situation where companies could make up for halfhearted business models by talking to the right people in Brussels, and we would not want to see it going back that way. The MVNO group needs to devise a plan that uses its would-be broad coverage and resources to deliver something that its rivals cannot, in terms of pricing, services or territory.

It may be taking a rather old fashioned approach to putting itself on the European map, but it does have some interesting ideas. One that could give it a powerful foot in the door of the market is its promise to create a technical platform that would support emergency call services run by multiple operators in a consistent international way. This could support the EU eSafety initiative for pan-European in-vehicle emergency calls and other such initiatives.

But while public safety projects often create an initial presence and revenue stream for operators, virtual or otherwise, they still need an appealing consumer story to generate growth. The most attractive of those promised by MVNO Global is hardly a new or complex idea, but is a key area where conventional networks still leave many users frustrated ‘ roaming. The initiative says: ‘Since MVNO Global customers in all EU countries operate as in a home network, roaming issues are not crucial. Customers are not bored and frustrated with network selection when travelling abroad and voice and data tariffs are consistent and predictable’.

Other services could be closely tied to EU projects. MVNO Global envisages offering cross-border services targeted to small businesses, which are often excluded from cellco’s enterprise offerings, and a centralized content platform to support the EU eContentplus program, which focuses on stimulating the development of digital content and services in areas of public interest such as geographic information and educational content.

Such ideas could give the initiative a unique approach that would make it competitive and distinguish it from the conventional suppliers. But they have the downside of being dependent on the progress of the EU’s own programs, which past history suggests may be slow, tortuous and political. This could leave the group in an awkward halfway house between being a fully commercial operator with the margins they can command and a publicly supported project geared to social change rather than profit. Even in the changing European telecoms world, success will rest on separating these two models rather than confusing them.