Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 December 2005

WiMAX vendors start to take keen interest in Wi-Fi and metrozones

In the early days of WiMAX, there was a gradual shift of Wi-Fi specialists to embrace the more powerful platform too. In particular, enterprise switchmakers like Airespace and metrozone network providers like Tropos and BelAir saw the opportunity to beef up their offerings. Now there is a reverse movement, with some WiMAX and broadband wireless companies taking a fresh interest in Wi-Fi. In particular, this is driven by the metrozone and consumer broadband markets, where in the coming couple of years, WiMAX will often feed Wi-Fi front ends, at least until its own subscriber units become cheaper or embedded in laptops.

Airspan, one of the WiMAX vendors most open to combining the platform with others ‘ it also recently formed a satellite equipment partnership with iDirect ‘ has joined the Wi-Fi Alliance and is placing increasing store by the citywide mesh boom. It has already provided equipment for a huge planned metrozone to be implemented in Tokyo by Japanese operator Yozan. With Tropos and others coming from the opposite direction – looking to use WiMAX initially for low cost backhaul and then to introduce it into their Wi-Fi meshes for high quality links ‘ the Wi-Fi/WiMAX combination model will become well established and the equipment market very competitive.

Airspan marked its joining of the Alliance with the launch of its AS.NET product line, which integrates Wi-Fi hotzone technology with broadband wireless backhaul. AS.NET can also be sold in a point-to-point configuration, providing broadband backbone for hotspot locations, outdoor coverage access points and DSL switches.

CEO Eric Stonestrom commented: ‘In the very near future, we foresee the widespread combination of WiMAX and Wi-Fi solutions in wireless broadband access networks. AS.NET’s patented RoamNET technology will now allow us to add the dimension of mobility to these networks, providing further impetus to the rollout of broadband wireless.’

While major municipal projects will increasingly use a combination of Wi-Fi mesh and WiMAX, there remains one crucial question mark over the technology ‘ how effectively it really supports voice over IP. This is seen as the critical application for metrozone and broadband wireless service providers in the first year ‘ after which it will likely become commoditized in the consumer sector ‘ but there are very few large scale VoIP networks being used in the real world. Since few data-only public access business models have ever delivered serious profit, VoIP and ‘ in future ‘ video applications will be of paramount importance, and vendors are racing to enhance their voice technologies and reassure nervous would-be operators.

A recent survey found that mobile VoIP was more important than data as the leading driver for metro area Wi-Fi deployments ‘ 50% of service providers and prospective hotzone builders questioned said portable voice was either as important as, or more important than, broadband data. A year earlier, fewer than 10% identified voice as a core application on their hotzones. The survey also found that more than 75% of network operators and service providers now have voice identified as a mandatory requirement for new metro Wi-Fi networks.

This will put pressure on hotzone equipment makers such as Tropos and BelAir to optimize their systems for voice. Most such suppliers have only recently introduced second generation meshes that go beyond data and support full quality of service.

Airspan itself has focused heavily on increasing the VoIP content of its products, acquiring voice specialist ArelNet last year and enhancing quality of service beyond the bare specifications of WiMAX standards.

Some help will also come from vendors that have traditionally focused on the enterprise wireless market, where VoIP is more advanced, but which are now eyeing the rich fruits promised by metrozone build-outs. One example is WLan switchmaker Aruba Networks, which has updated its Mobile Edge architecture with so-called Voice Flow Classification (VFC) capabilities, which monitor and prioritize voice packets being broadcast on the Wi-Fi and reroutes calls to avoid congested areas of the network. These will make voice over WLan suitable for very large voice networks including citywide blankets, the company claimed.

Another is VoIP optimized switch maker Meru, which claims superior quality of service to the 802.11e standard and has also started to target metrozone operators as well as corporations. Its client Azulstar Networks claims the world’s first metro scale voice over Wi-Fi service, adding voice to its 103-square mile hotzone in Rio Rancho, a suburb of Albuquerque, New Mexico earlier this year. The voice element will be added using equipment from Meru. The need to rely on such specialized additional equipment does increase the build-out cost significantly when supporting voice as well as data, and price pressure from free offerings like Skype does not guarantee a good return.

However, as Cisco, Motorola and others ‘ with experience of VoIP handsets and end-to-end networks ‘ take new interest in metrozones, the voice facilities should get ever more robust, and voice oriented enhancements to wireless standards will reduce cost of investing in equipment.