The past year has been full of stories of large US telcos seeking to obstruct the spread of subsidized or free broadband access through municipal metrozones. Not only did these projects introduce unwelcome cut price competition just as the Regional Bell Operators (RBOCs) were investing heavily in their networks, but they brought a new and disruptive set of players into telecoms ‘ the internet community, with their open networks and advertising revenue streams, as represented by Google. But large telcos know when they are beating their heads against walls, and 2006 should be the year when they pay less attention to backing anti-municipal broadband legislation, and instead try to take control of the metrozone sector themselves. This may throw up fewer legislative obstacles to municipal deployments, but it will also accelerate the process of refocusing these projects away from their original social goals.
The pattern is familiar from Wi-Fi hotspots. Initially on the defensive against a technology that could support portable voice and data access at flat rates, thus threatening DSL and 3G in some situations, the large carriers quickly realized that they could not stem the tide of demand, but they could at least snatch a good share of the revenues. Thus western European public Wi-Fi is increasingly in the hands of the incumbents, while T-Mobile and SBC/AT&T are both highly successful in the US market.
Now the RBOCs are turning their attention to metrozones, which because of their blanket coverage can be a real threat to 3G networks while users stay within the metro area. It is notable that one of the five contenders shortlisted last week to provide the high profile San Francisco metrozone is MCI, soon to be owned by Verizon. This would take this Bell operator out of its core territory, one of the key reasons for the expansionist incumbents, freed from their old territorial confines, to explore metrozones and other wireless access options. By contrast, cellco Cingular did not bid to supply the San Francisco network, but instead took the regressive approach of trying to convince the city authorities that such a system would not be necessary once 3G was available. That might be true if, like Google, another bidder for the deal, Cingular proposed to offer basic services free of charge on its network.
The fact that advertising-driven Google can offer to build and run the network at no cost to the city, as well as offering a base 100Kbps service for free, puts it in the front running position to win the San Francisco contract, but we can be sure Verizon/MCI will be looking for other opportunities too, even as it continues to fund anti-municipal lobbying in the state and federal legislatures.
MCI, through its Skytel division ‘ which is seeking a new raison d’etre as its core paging business declines ‘ has already shown strong interest in metrozones and was engaged earlier this year in a project, with Tropos, to blanket downtown New Orleans, activity put on hold by the hurricanes. MCI said in March that it would aim to establish a national metrozone footprint and a new brand. Like Earthlink, it sees a chain of citywide wireless networks as a relatively simple way to expand its broadband business and for future parent Verizon, the strategy could help it fill gaps in wireline coverage, expand into new territories and neutralize the attack of non-telco challengers such as Google.
‘SkyTel views metro scale Wi-Fi mesh networks as an important new technology with great business potential,’ said Bruce Deer, president of the paging unit, in a statement earlier this year. ‘Bringing broadband access to areas where it was previously unavailable or unaffordable is a major objective for us.” MCI would use Wi-Fi initially but has been active in WiMAX trials, looking to expand on the two-way paging platform it operates in 900MHz spectrum and to make use of its extensive fiber backhaul capacity to enhance the economics of its roll-outs, compared to rivals that have to lease backhaul.
IBM, which sees metrozones as a key opportunity for its integration business in 2006, has seen a significant change of attitude from the major US telcos in the past few months and has been approached by two large providers, both looking for help in designing a metrozone technology and business framework that could then be proposed to municipalities in their areas. For instance, Qwest ‘ one of the most aggressive anti-municipal operators ‘ Time Warner Cable and Sprint all made proposals for the Minneapolis citywide network project, although the shortlisted candidates are Earthlink and local player US Internet.
IBM believes the initial reaction to metrozone projects was ‘kneejerk’ and the telcos and cablecos have now realized they must risk cannibalizing their DSL business in order to keep control of an unstoppable force ‘ and prevent companies like Earthlink turning themselves into serious competitors, should they create a large enough chain of metrozones, something that is well within the ISP’s sights at the moment.
The municipalities are more open to telco involvement too, IBM comments. They do not wish to be service providers themselves, and in some cases are taking warnings to heart that they need experienced communications companies to ensure they run their systems effectively and with the maximum ROI. Between the lines, the early idealism of the municipalities like Philadelphia, focused primarily on building networks in order to bridge the digital divide, is being squashed under the realism of budgetary pressure, taxpayers’ concerns and the overriding interest of improved public safety. ‘More mature business models’ tend to omit talk of intangible improvements to the city’s image, and free access (even in the Google model this will only apply to the most low grade services); and focus on greater efficiency for public services, partnership with private industry, and better ROI.
The Philadelphia model, which sparked much of the debate on municipal broadband, was undoubtedly sketchily thought out and idealistic, and has since been shifted in scope to consume fewer tax dollars. But it embraced many of the key reasons why telecoms should sometimes not be left entirely to the private sector ‘ notably, that access is becoming a basic utility and needs to be guaranteed for all, which means a measure of public intervention. The new-look municipal networks will be private, profitable systems under another name, and so will attract the large providers and integrators, no doubt resulting in more mature and sophisticated services ‘ for those who can pay for them. Providers that do not rely on access charges for revenue, such as advertising-driven internet players, will be the best hope for low cost or free services, but even these will have to fight off the large telcos now, and the briefly glimpsed dream of universal access achieved through subsidized public city networks will be largely snuffed out in 2006.
Box: San Francisco
There are five companies shortlisted to provide the San Francisco metrozone, from an original list of over 30 bids. Along with Google and MCI/Skytel, the other companies shortlisted are ISP Earthlink, which is seeking to build its broadband base through metrozone build-outs; MetroFi, which already operates citywide networks in Cupertino and Santa Clara, California and would also offer free access to users who tolerated advertising; and Hewlett Packard, working with mesh specialist Tropos.