Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 December 2005

Wi-Fi takes pragmatic approach to end standards split

The Wi-Fi community is proving more pragmatic than its counterpart in UltraWideBand. In both technologies, an Intel-inspired consortium has broken away from the IEEE standards efforts to propose an alternative and heavily backed platform. But while the UWB players within the IEEE 802.15.3a taskgroup have failed to unite their forces, leaving their leader, Freescale, in a difficult dilemma, the various Wi-Fi parties look set to come to an uneasy agreement.

Intel, Broadcom and others set up the Enhanced Wireless Consortium (EWC) earlier this year, threatening to bypass the 802.11n efforts to create the next, fast Wi-Fi standard. The spectre of UWB, where Intel’s WiMedia Alliance took its technology to another standards body, ECMA, to be ratified, hung over the market. However, the two factions within the IEEE process were far closer to agreement in Wi-Fi than their equivalents in UWB, and have now apparently agreed not only to come up with a converged proposal themselves, but to embrace EWC too, rather than let it sideline the IEEE again.

The EWC now says its proposals are ‘substantially aligned’ with the IEEE’s working group, which could allow a mutually agreed submission to be made by January. However, there is little doubt that the EWC proposals will make up the dominant part of this ‘mutual’ platform when it is unveiled. This would rob some key contributors to the original converged proposal ‘ bringing together the efforts of formerly warring factions TGn Sync and WWise ‘ of their power, in particular smart antenna specialist Airgo, on whose MIMO array technology the IEEE efforts were increasingly converging.

Like Freescale over in UWB, Airgo will be able to adapt its technology to support an EWC-inspired specification set, but will lose its driving role, and therefore ‘ as a start-up now up against giants like Intel and Atheros ‘ much of its market advantage. Freescale has to make the same decision over whether to support the ECMA-ratified WiMedia standard or go it alone with its Direct Sequence UWB technology, but at least it is a major chipmaker which could still carve out significant market share, even in a market where it is not setting the rules. If 802.11n emerges as a technology that does not draw significantly on Airgo, there will be strong pressure on early Airgo adopters such as Linksys and Belkin, which have incorporated its smart antenna chipsets into their ‘pre-n’ fast Wi-Fi products, to change supplier, or at least to put price pressure on Airgo. Standards-based markets are a volume game, and the main way for minnows to survive against the giants is to have a decent period of time when their proprietary technology leads the game, and then to claim intellectual property revenues on the eventual standard. A rapid agreement on 802.11n will benefit consumers by accelerating availability of low cost, certified products, but it will be at the cost of the market, once again, falling under the control of a few giants.