Rising operator pressure in Europe has helped effect a change in patent policies at standards body ETSI.
Only a few weeks after a group of cellcos, led by Vodafone, T-Mobile and Telef’nica, calling on the European Commission to protect them and their customers from huge royalty bills by addressing ETSI’s practises on patent recognition, the standards body has changed its rules, a move that has satisfied the EU and ended an ongoing antitrust probe.
The European Commission had been investigating ETSI on antitrust grounds and the cellcos’ activities had stepped up the pressure. ETSI has now changed its policies on patent disclosure to prevent “patent ambush” in setting industry standards, the Commission said in a statement.
Patent ambush occurs when a company hides the fact that it owns intellectual property rights crucial to a standard and then discloses its claims once the standard is adopted. Sometimes, the ETSI members could, with full knowledge, have chosen alternative technologies that would be cheaper for vendors and end users, said the EC.
“It is crucial that standard setting bodies establish rules which ensure fair, transparent procedures and early disclosure of relevant intellectual property,” European Union antitrust chief Neelie Kroes said.
The ruling goes to the heart of the raging debate over how intellectual property rights should be respected without allowing standards to be hijacked by patent holders charging high royalties ‘ which can deter vendors from adopting a platform at all. Qualcomm is at the center of many such complaints and the subject of antitrust claims from Broadcom and other chip rivals in the US and Europe.
However, Qualcomm ‘ while making healthy revenues from its iron control of the CDMA-based technologies ‘ has not made a secret of its policies or sought to mislead standards bodies (although many parties are concerned that it may suddenly produce patent claims related to WiMAX, since it has been gathering OFDM-related intellectual property of late).
The ETSI change of rules could be a template for other standards bodies. It is crucial that such organizations develop a widely supported and workable system whereby intellectual property claims are made upfront or not at all, at various stages of the process, and where royalty levels are more precisely defined than in the standard, vague policy of ‘reasonable and non-discriminatory’ charges.
The cellcos’ own proposal to the EU made the issue clear. They claimed that intellectual property terms should be agreed before a standard is even set, and stated: ‘Cumulative patent royalties or ‘patent stacking’ can raise the licence burden to an extent unbearable to our industry. IPR licence fees have become a commercial issue that is limiting the industry’s ability to continue to drive down costs. The issue has the potential to limit competition through direct and indirect impact on pricing.’