Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 January 2006

Mobile satellite would do better to work with WiMAX than against it

Among the many false dawns that the wireless industry has seen over the years, mobile satellite services (MSS) has been one of the most disappointing, as the sorry saga of the Iridium venture illustrated. As a competitor to cellphones, satellite’s promise of anywhere access was outweighed by its costs and inability to penetrate walls. As cellular technologies themselves enhance their coverage and indoor penetration, it might seem that the prospects for MSS are bleaker than ever, but that has not stopped the largest US specialist in this area, Mobile Satellite Ventures (MSV) hooking up with Boeing to create a $1bn network ‘ one that could, in theory at least, challenge mobile WiMAX operators in some of their markets, and which is already said to be vying with 802.16 for the affections of Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation, which is looking for a broadband data strand to add to its satellite television services.

MSV will pay Boeing up to $1bn to build three satellites operating in the L and Ku bands, and related ground systems, covering North and South America ‘ the aerospace giant’s largest orbiter deal in a decade. Unlike some previous attempts to use satellite to offer a mobile communications system with far greater reach than cellular, MSV’s project has the advantage of owning radio spectrum too, with a national 1.5GHz license. The system will incorporate technology called Ancillary Terrestrial Component (ATC), engineered by MSV and seen as the great white hope for mobile satellite. This combines terrestrial mobile and satellite communications to support key functionality such as broadband mobile data, and could in theory use a version of WiMAX adapted for the 1.5GHz band as its network technology, although the work on ATC so far has centered on a flavour of CDMA2000. Other options would include Qualcomm’s Flarion technology.

Most MSS players are banking on ATC for their survival, since it addresses the problem of penetrating building walls, the number one constraint on demand for mobile satellite services and one that has kept capex and opex costs high and volume low. MSV appears to be the most advanced in this respect, but it still needs to raise the money to pay for its new satellites. This is where Murdoch is widely rumored to be interested in stepping in, via its DirecTV arm, which broadcasts across the US. Its main rival, Echostar ‘ itself the subject of fevered rumors of a takeover bid from AT&T/SBC ‘ could also be in the running.

All this renewed interest in mobile satellite comes from the increasingly urgent need for service providers to support the mobilized triple play of voice, video/broadcast and data delivered to multiple devices. Hence the enthusiasm of DirecTV, Echostar and Murdoch’s European satellite venture BSkyB for a technology that will give them the return path that their television satellites lack and add mobile data to their mix ‘ keeping them in line with the DSL telcos and cablecos, which are busily adding cellular or mobile broadband partnerships to their portfolios.

These broadcasters are investigating WiMAX actively as a possible solution, but the MSS providers themselves are also looking to make their technology more flexible ‘ and therefore more appealing to such giant partners.This could make them a rival to WiMAX although they could also source WiMAX-type technology for their terrestrial element and boost one of the vendors in this sector. The inclusion of ATCs into the platforms of MSV and its competitors will enable them to support high speed data communications.

There is a long way to go however. Even with ATC, the fixed, indoor capability of the MSS platforms will not match that of WiMAX, and in the mobile world, it will not be enough just to match 3G’s services ‘ they will need to be able to lure customers with unique benefits and applications. As the past has shown, the promise of ubiquitous access is not enough, being of benefit only to a small minority of consumers, mainly those travelling in very remote areas.

The markets in which MSS can thrive have traditionally been niches, but some of these, notably public safety, are undergoing a huge expansion and so will prove a sounder basis for a business model ‘ even under threat from mobile WiMAX and Wi-Fi. The additional 2GHz spectrum that was allocated before Christmas to the US MSS providers ‘ despite arguments from broadband wireless parties that they should be allowed to bid for it ‘ was awarded on the basis that public safety and emergency response services would take priority.

Even with the new dollars flowing from these sectors, and the benefit of additional bandwidth, the MSS players will have to move rapidly to snatch market share from WiMAX and CDMA, since MSV and the others are not promising to have completed their national networks and services until 2008-9. An accelerant could be major cash injection ‘ and commercial impetus ‘ from a partner with the power to market and differentiate consumer and business oriented applications. “Our mission is to create something mass market,” said Eric Swank, MSV’s chief financial officer, on announcing the Boeing deal. “We do see ourselves aligning with a large scale telecom/media player.”

DirecTV would certainly fall into this category, and it needs a partner with radio spectrum, which it entirely lacks. Rupert Murdoch announced at the recent CES consumer electronics show that his company News Corp (DirecTV’s parent) would invest significantly in a broadband wireless strategy in the coming few years, but although the giant has been linked in the past with WiMAX players such as Alvarion, on this occasion there was no hint as to the likely technology or allies. However, even if it chooses to build its own WiMAX network, News Corp will certainly need a partner with spectrum ‘ its proposed budget of $1bn to create its service would not buy much in the way of US bandwidth. This makes it more likely that it would ally with a network owner such as MSV or, even more attractively, Clearwire, using its $1bn to accelerate the build-out of such companies’ systems. It could also create a conventional MVNO with a cellular provider, which would cost about $500m, but it is more likely that DirecTV will look for greater control and expansion scope in its partnership, with an agreement closer to the venture between Sprint Nextel and the US’ leading cable operators. This alliance, which will focus on triple play services using WiMAX and cellular platforms, is far reaching and is a key market factor to which DirecTV needs urgently to respond.

In the MSS world, with the Boeing manufacturing partnership under its belt, and plans to start building its land-based network almost immediately, MSV is certainly in the driving seat in terms of attracting such deals. EchoStar is another candidate to take an interest in MSV, although if it does form a close alliance with AT&T the strategy would more likely revolve around WiMAX and would not be allowed to compete with the telco’s cellular joint venture, Cingular.

Another telco that could make use of the MSV network would be Bell Canada, which owns 20% of the company and has vast rural areas in its home country that require broadband access. Bell Canada, which lags behind rival Telus in the rural west, is also investing in a pre-WiMAX joint venture to launch broadband wireless services in 2.5GHz spectrum, working with Rogers Wireless. (The other main owners of MSV are satellite companies Motient with 48% and SkyTerra Communications with 20%. Motient started life as American Mobile Satellite but renamed itself in 1998 after acquiring the Ardis paging network from Motorola and IBM. It filed for bankruptcy protection in 2002 and having spun off its satellite arm, which joined forces with Bell Canada’s TMI to form MSV. Motient emerged from Chapter 11 in late 2003. SkyTerra, which is controlled by New York investment firm Apollo Management, bought DirecTV’s stake in Hughes Networks last year.)

Over in the 2GHz band, two other MSS providers have been given a boost with the allocation of additional spectrum last month (see inset). TerreStar plans services based on dual-mode handsets from 2007, with its implementation of ATC going live in mid-2008. ICO also plans to go live in 2007. Like other dual-mode handsets, these new generation satellite phones will be based on modified 3G handsets that run on the terrestrial cellular (or, in future, WiMAX) network when they are in urban areas or indoors, but communicate directly with a satellite wherever the terrestrial network does not reach.

The going will be tough for these MSS specialists. They have a legacy of poor performance and, with services still almost two years away, terrestrial-only solutions are closing the gap in terms of coverage more quickly than MSS can bite back with improved indoor and data performance. A major partner such as DirecTV would be a real shot in the arm, but while combining satellite and broadband wireless networks to offer expanded triple play services will be an important trend, the MSS players may well be commercially unable to take advantage, and end up confined to their public safety niche.

BOX ‘ the 2GHz auction

The FCC cast a major lifeline to the MSS providers at the turn of the year when it gave new 2GHz allocations to TMI/Terrestar and ICO, the two remaining players in this band. Cellular carriers such as Sprint had sought the right to bid for shares of the 24MHz chunk of 2GHz S-band spectrum, alongside the satellite specialists. Since it is so close to the 1.9GHz cellular bands in the US, 2GHz could be a valuable expansion band. The spectrum was originally assigned to satellite companies, but many of those licensees went out of business and when only two remained, and failed to meet their deadlines, the licenses were returned to the FCC. They remained earmarked to be reallocated, under new conditions but possibly for no extra charge, to the remaining mobile satellite players, TMI/Terrestar and ICO, but the cellcos were arguing that they should be auctioned, with wireless providers also able to bid. Intel had estimated that such an auction would raise about $9bn.

The key argument employed by the Satellite Industry Association (SIA) to counter this proposal ‘ and one that proved crucial in the wake of the series of 2005 hurricanes – was that, when a disaster affects local wireline or wireless terrestrial systems, MSS networks can provide critical communications capabilities.

On the decision to award TerreStar and Craig McCaw-backed ICO 20MHz each of the S-band frequencies, the former commented: ‘By doing so, the FCC has made ‘2 x 10’ capability ‘ 10MHz of uplink and 10MHz of downlink capacity ‘ possible. ‘2 x 10′ allows enough bandwidth to guarantee robust voice and data services for first responders, underserved areas, and the mobile communications consumer. This order has far reaching ramifications for emergency services and homeland security in the United States and Canada. The FCC order to assign sufficient 2 GHz spectrum to TMI/TerreStar makes it certain that North America can meet its public safety and homeland security communication needs,’ said CEO Robert Brumley.

Although TerreStar and ICO are charged with prioritizing public safety in their build-out plans for satellite/terrestrial hybrid networks in 2GHz, they will also look to address underserved consumer markets, and it will be interesting to see whether there is any tie-up between ICO and the other major McCaw venture, Clearwire, in its 2.5GHz radio spectrum.

The other main contender for the 2GHz licenses, apart from the cellcos Cingular, Sprint Nextel and T-Mobile USA, was European satellite giant Inmarsat. The successful incumbents argued that two providers are enough, pointing to other satellite duopolies such as XM and Sirius in radio, EchoStar and DirecTV in television, and Iridium and Globalstar. Therefore they argued that Inmarsat and the cellcos should be excluded from bidding, in the interest of getting spectrum to TerreStar and ICO quickly to speed their deployment of real world services.