Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 February 2006

Start-Up Watch: xG brings low power technology to market but needs to work with other platforms

Much discussed wireless start-up xG Technology is preparing to bring its technology to market, targeting telecoms equipment vendors as licensees. The xMAX platform offers a very low power physical layer design that could run multiple standards, including WiMAX, in the MAC (media access control) layer.

The company has appointed the London office of Credit Suisse as a strategic advisor to increase international profile and approach equipment vendors, and said its first products will be ready to license in the second quarter.

xMAX is a patented modulation and encoding technology that allows broadband signals to be transmitted at very low power on already used parts of the spectrum. As such, it falls into a similar category as UltraWideBand (UWB), which can also coexist with other radio transmissions without interference because of its low power levels, though the full exploitation of that potential is currently hampered by regulatory limitations on UWB. These have left UWB largely confined to the short range personal area network market, although like xG, UWB backers believe there will be opportunities to combine its physical layer approach with multiple MACs ‘ not just the WiMedia standard devised for PANs, but possibly others like WiMAX and 60GHz multimedia networks.

In a head-to-head, UWB, despite its restrictions, clearly comes with far better backing than xMAX, with the weight of the Intel/Texas Instruments/Sony/Philips-led WiMedia Alliance behind its most popular implementation. But xG says it takes a very different technical approach that will make its technology appealing to vendors targeting different markets to those of UWB, because xMAX can potentially boost the data rates of any wired or wireless communications. ‘It is not a compression technique, but rather a synergistic mix of two well established communication approaches that dramatically improves spectrum utilization,’ is the official explanation. These two approaches are flash signalling, which transmits wideband data at power levels well below the noise floor, and an encoding system called Index-N, which reduces sideband emissions and boosts data rate. xMAX can be incorporated into any system that uses RF transmissions, including DSL and coax cable as well as wireless, though fixed wireless equipment makers will be the first targets.

Spectral efficiency and use of very low, long range frequencies ‘ regulator willing ‘ could enable indoor coverage of a metropolitan area such as London with just two base stations, rather than 160 for WiMAX or several thousand for Wi-Fi, claims xG.

‘Our initial focus will be to offer an alternative technology within the fixed wireless market before turning our attention to 4G mobile market, where the constraints of range, interference, spectrum allocation and throughput have not yet been overcome,’ said Rick Mooers, executive chairman of xG Technology, in a statement.

With the announcement of intention to come to market for real, the company seems to be getting more aggressive about positioning xMAX as an alternative to other technologies such as WiMAX and even, in future, W-CDMA. However, with so much vendor R&D and operator investment already committed to those platforms and their future roadmaps ‘ and with xMAX, beyond a couple of demonstrations, largely unproven and certainly not approved by most regulators ‘ it would be more prudent to revert to the approach taken by the founders in their initial presentations of xMAX to analysts last July. At this time, it was put forward as a spectrally efficient, physical layer invention that could be combined with other systems to boost their performance in certain markets, or could be run alongside them in multifunction products.

Lack of large OEM interest has stalled many a technically brilliant invention, even one that had caught the eye of the operators ‘ Flarion Flash-OFDM was a good example before it was snapped up by Qualcomm, and xG may need to find a similar white knight capable of taking xMAX into the mainstream, even as a political gambit in the increasingly intense wars to dominate the broadband wireless and fast in-home wireless network sectors, perhaps for a vendor excluded from the current UWB race.

One hope for xG, but one that will rely on a cooperative rather than a confrontational approach, is the increasing trend to mix and match physical and MAC (media access control) layers of the network, rather than tie them inextricably together as the IEEE standards, which govern both layers, tend to do. For instance, there is significant R&D focused on running a WiMAX or WiMedia MAC on a 60GHz PHY, while there is likely to be a harmonized UWB-based PHY supporting multiple protocols such as Bluetooth and FireWireless. xG said in July that its low power PHY could run a WiMAX MAC, for example, and so support a range of new applications, and new price/performance points, for the technology. Although it has created a MAC for the purpose of demonstrations, its preference is to license its PHY technology and let companies run their own MACs on top. Founder Joseph Bobier sees an especially good fit with the 802.16 MAC, which he believes to be extremely well designed ‘ but closely coupled to its own PHY. ‘We could become a subset of WiMAX and we’d be very open to that,’ he told Wireless Watch. ‘We were forced to develop a MAC layer for the showcase and we are using a stripped down WiMAX MAC.’ Certainly, a PHY that was optimized for lower frequencies could have a clear appeal to the WiMAX community, which is keen to shift its technology into areas such as 700MHz, which will support long non-line of sight distances and good economics for mobility and so appeal to large carriers. A cooperation to this end with xG ‘ perhaps driven by a WiMAX supporter like Intel ‘ would be a far safer route to market than taking on the 4G community single-handed.

BOX ‘ the technology

Headed up by inventor, founder and president Joseph Bobier and CEO Mats Wennberg, formerly head of the Nordic area for Microsoft, the US/Sweden-based company has created an intellectual property platform called xMax, which at first glance has resemblances to UWB, in that it uses such low power that it operates below the spectral floor, but delivers very high data rates, up to 40Mbps. However, its techniques are different to the rapid succession of pulses used by classic UWB and it can operate at longer ranges (up to 15 miles). It claims to deliver broadband rates in narrow bands without interfering with other spectrum users.

Its secret is its own xG Flash Signaling, which transmits data at power levels up to 100,000 times below FCC limits (and, it claims up to 10,000 times below that of UWB). Unlike other wireless technologies that move as much power as possible from the carrier into the information bearing sidebands, xMax does the opposite, using the Flash Signalling technique to keep sideband information carrying to just 1% of total power. The method takes a narrowband carrier at any frequency and modulates a single RF cycle to create a very brief, low power signal. This merely coordinates the sender and receiver, while the actual data is transmitted in a wideband Flash Signal out of band, but at power levels that are lower than those permitted by regulators for unintentional out of band emissions.

The technology only needs a narrow segment of unoccupied spectrum (1MHz to 100MHz depending on application can be supported) within any band to deliver broadband data rates, which makes it viable for use in sub-1GHz frequencies. Although these are ideal for wireless networks because they support long range and high mobility, they are normally divided into very small segments, limiting the services that carriers can deliver and forcing them up to the higher bands. Here, far more base stations are required to cover a given area, raising costs.

xG is targeting its technologies at operators facing this well known conundrum and hopes that their need to cram more and more data into low frequency pipes will attract them to xMax and, in turn, lead them to put pressure on OEMs to make the all-important manufacturing deals that will decide, ultimately, whether an interesting technology can achieve commercial market uptake.

There are three modes of operation for xMax. The first is normal mode, where it shares spectrum with other occupiers but well below FCC requirements for out of band emissions, so that interference is not created. The second mode is aimed at Europe, where intentional out of band emissions are not allowed at all, and so the signal is reshaped to ensure that it falls in a predictable place. The third option suppresses the carrier and just sends out the flash signal, which supports lower data rates (25% lower) but improves battery life.