Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2006

Even WiMAX supporters boost HSDPA for the multi-network world

In previous 3GSM conferences, WiMAX has been largely unmentioned, or at least dismissed by the big cellular players as a sideline. This year, WiMAX was more prominent on the agenda in its own right, with specialists like Alvarion on show, Motorola noisy about its forthcoming Moto Wi4 platform, and with product announcements from the likes of Alcatel and Samsung (see separate items). It was also more clearly on the minds of its detractors, with something of a concerted effort to talk up the abilities of HSDPA to beat WiMAX at its own game. And increasingly, there was a focus on accelerating advanced mobile adoption by applying key performance and usability advances not just to one platform, but to many. This was clear among large convergence suppliers, such as Nortel (see separate item), which is enriching both its WiMAX and W-CDMA architectures in similar ways; and even some companies heavily associated with 802.16, such as Intel and PicoChip, were announcing advances that will actually enhance the ability of HSDPA to compete with it. WiMAX detractors took this as a sign that there will be no role for 802.16e as the cellular networks will evolve quickly to match its performance, even in areas such as indoor penetration and fixed data rate. But in fact, it shows the industry growing up. Carriers will choose a network for different reasons, not least the spectrum they have managed to get access to, and vendors will need to spread their options so they can support any of these choices.

With 802.16e and HSDPA emerging in similar timeframes ‘ and no doubt with similar hiccups along the way ‘ they are both seeking to take on the qualities of the other. The WiMAX community is focused in the short term on its strengths in personal broadband ‘ often laptop or PDA based ‘ and fixed/mobile convergence, but is focusing R&D efforts on supporting high speed mobility like the 3G platforms. Conversely, HSDPA is building on a base in inherently mobile applications and handsets, but is ploughing resource into improving fixed and indoor performance so that it can also become a converged platform.

The 3G community was keen to support its preferred technology. According to Carl-Henric Svanberg, Ericsson’s CEO, WiMAX will be useful for fixed operators to add an element of portability but will not compete with mobile networks because of its limited coverage. “Why would you want something only somewhere, when you can have something everywhere?” he asked, a point echoed by Tom Phillips, chief government and regulatory affairs officer for the GSM Association, who said: “Over 80% of the world’s population has GSM coverage, but I don’t think that’s true for WiMAX.’ Vodafone CEO Arun Sarin ‘ who has admitted the company will need to drop its UMTS-only stance, especially for new economies ‘ was back on his traditional stance too. “If we can get ubiquitous wireless broadband coverage [with HSDPA], WiMAX will be a far less interesting thing when it turns up here in 2008-2009,’ he said.

One way that companies on this side of the debate look to reduce the disruptive impact of Wi-Fi and WiMAX is to try to appropriate the laptop and PDA, traditionally the home of the semi-mobile, data-oriented IP networks, for cellular connections. Although there are laptop cards for W-CDMA, the higher data rates of HSDPA make it a more viable option to provide an alternative to Wi-Fi and WiMAX. Intel, usually the biggest proponent of the newer networks, is keen to play in all wireless networks and at 3GSM, it joined with the GSMA in an initiative to stimulate uptake of cellular connections in laptops. The partners will collaborate to develop guidelines for integrating 3G modems and SIM cards into laptops, enabling automatic connection to both 3GSM networks and Wi-Fi/WiMAX networks around the world, using the same SIM card technology used by mobile phones today. Again, the emphasis is not on an either-or situation, whatever the stalwarts of both camps say, but on enabling as many consumer and operator choices as possible using consistent basic technology.

“Our goal is to ensure that in future, every notebook will be SIM ready,” said Rob Conway, CEO of the GSM Association. “This development brings the advantages and pervasiveness of the GSM platform to the notebook market, where this year sales of more than 60m laptops are forecast worldwide.’

On the base station side, another chipmaker more commonly associated with WiMAX than 3G is PicoChip, the UK-based start-up that provides Intel’s 802.16 base station design and has just announced new funding from AT&T. In Barcelona PicoChip ‘ which despite its recent success in WiMAX is really focused on software defined, multi-network base station architectures ‘ announced capabilities that will enhance the ability of HSDPA to go up against WiMAX, especially in terms of the 3G networks’ traditional Achilles’ heel, indoor penetration.

The chipmaker showed off a new femtocell 3G base station reference design for use in home or small offices, which the company said could be an alternative to Wi-Fi and Unlicensed Mobile Access (UMA) ‘ the cellular/Wi-Fi convergence technology ‘ for fixed/mobile convergence and taking the wireless link indoors. The PC2808 modem reference design supports HSDPA and will be software upgraded also to support the emerging high data rate uplink specification, HSUPA.

‘Cellular operators realize they need to counter the threat of competition from those gearing up to offer UMA or voice over Wi-Fi,’ said Rupert Baines, vice president of marketing. Importantly, such emerging technologies will allow customers to use existing cellular handsets. The femtocell base station supports cellular calls locally, and then uses broadband, typically DSL or cable modem, to carry traffic to the operator’s core network. Significantly, it will operate with all existing handsets rather than requiring customers to upgrade to expensive dual-mode devices.

All this indicates that WiMAX and HSDPA are becoming real and are squaring up against each other, even though the successful vendors will be those that support a range of choices for the operators and consumers.

BOX ‘ Outdoor Wi-Fi

Broadband wireless will rely on a patchwork of different networks, but one that is unlikely to play a major role will be outdoor Wi-Fi (except in the particular world of municipal mesh). Although WISPs have used outdoor Wi-Fi to offer broadband access, the failure of specialists in extended range WLans, such as Vivato, shows what a niche this is, and the technology is increasingly being eclipsed in price/performance by other options. Even the emerging 802.11n fast Wi-Fi standard, which will operate at up to 600Mbps (eventually) indoors, looks rather more humdrum outside, at a likely 40-50Mbps. This is because Wi-Fi cannot, when outdoors, take advantage of the data rate enhancements of MIMO. These rest in part on spatial multiplexing, which uses multipath reflection to produce multiple data streams that carry different information in parallel over the same frequencies. In outdoor spaces, there isn’t enough multipath reflection close enough to a transmitter to provide that advantage (except, perhaps, in dense urban meshes). Similarly, the 40MHz wide channels that give 802.11n another of its performance hikes only work when the airspace is clear, which is unlikely outdoors.