Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 February 2006

Earthlink boosts its rainbow broadband approach with Google and satellite

Earthlink, the US’ second largest internet service provider, knows that its success depends on using any means at its disposal to circumvent the incumbent network operators ‘ traditionally a very difficult business model to build in the country. Its attempts to shift smoothly from its huge, but now dying, dial-up business to DSL have been thwarted by the control of the DSL lines by the Bell operators. Rather than give up, like many CLECs, it has instead amassed a rainbow of network options to compete with them on other turfs ‘ most importantly its recent focus on municipal Wi-Fi, which has now led it to join forces with the ubiquitously disruptive Google. Other technologies in its portfolio include VoIP, peer-to-peer, broadband wireless, the Helio MVNO venture with SKT, and now possible alliances with the satellite TV operators. This shows a company that is certainly not short of ideas or aggression, but may be spreading itself too thinly in terms of expertise and capex investment. Certainly, Wall Street continues to value the company largely against its dwindling dial-up business, and the Google deal may be the sign that Earthlink will finally concentrate its efforts, or at least its publicity, on one or two key strategies, and even, some observers believe, could spin the municipal Wi-Fi initatives off altogether to increase their value.

The most important ally in Earthlink’s multipronged attack on the telcos to date has been Korea’s SKT, with which the ISP has a joint venture that has already spawned the Helio MVNO (Mobile Virtual Network Operator), which leases capacity on Sprint Nextel’s CDMA network and aims to attract 3m subscribers, or about 2% of the US wireless market, by 2009, with $2bn in annual revenue by that time. It is likely that the venture will extend its technological platform, particularly to take advantage of SKT’s experience in Korea with trialling the pre-WiMAX Wi-Bro technology, which is also under trial at Sprint Nextel. Given Earthlink’s existing deployments of WiMAX-class technology in California, we are likely to see an enhanced relationship with Sprint Nextel in its 2.5GHz broadband wireless spectrum and a broadband data service from Earthlink and/or Helio in 2007.

In the more immediate future, though, Earthlink is relying on two new partnerships to bolster its efforts to build a national, mobile triple play broadband service. These are the satellite operators and Google, and both alliances have significance beyond the initial revenue projections. The satellite deals are conventional ‘ Earthlink can offer DirecTV or EchoStar programming as part of its service bundles ‘ but they show the ISP’s need to become a full triple play communications provider, and they could also become part of the satellite companies’ growing patchwork of partnerships to fill in the gaping hole in their services, left by the lack of a return path network. Both companies are looking to build or lease a broadband wireless network ‘ possibly as a joint effort ‘ and could join forces with an ISP such as SKT-Earthlink, especially one looking to ambitious spectrum deals of its own. Already, there is talk of Helio and DirecTV collaborating on a mobile television service using WiMAX-type networks, possibly from Clearwire (a deal involving Sprint could cause conflict of interest between DirecTV and the telco’s existing venture with the major US cablecos).

And the talent of the company for smart partnerships is seen in Helio’s first major deal, with insanely popular social networking service MySpace. Helio will flagship its impending launch this spring with the exclusive deal and some exclusive handsets to support the offering, which should appeal to Helio’s target teen market. The MySpace Mobile On Helio will leverage the devices’ capabilities to keep MySpace members connected to their network through mail, bulletins, profiles, blogs and photo galleries, Helio said. MySpace has an estimated 55m users, and MySpace.com is the second most viewed web site in the US, behind only Yahoo and ahead of Google, and accounting for 12% of all online advertising.

Like the SKT partnership, many of the real fruits of the satellite tie-ups lie in the future and are currently speculative. Of more short term significance is Google and Earthlink’s rapidly accelerating push into municipal metrozones, which it sees as valuable to its business model on several fronts. Most obviously, building a metrozone boosts its revenues in giving it control of the networks that are set to open the next new wave of internet uptake, by providing low cost access ‘ especially in those cities that are looking to improve digital inclusion with low cost laptop or library schemes, for instance. Also, Earthlink can lease the metrozone network to other providers and WISPs ‘ something it is already doing with some of its broadband wireless investments, even subletting capacity to rival AOL. The metrozones will generally be used by the municipal authority itself for applications such as public safety and administration, giving Earthlink an iron hold on that customer base.

And of course, these networks are independent of the local incumbent telco and provide an alternative to its services, with no reliance on its DSL lines. Earthlink is not even looking to use telco lines for backhaul, relying on wireless where possible. It has already won five city projects, working with Motorola and others, and is already moving beyond simple Wi-Fi mesh, to use a combination of mesh networks from Tropos and Motorola’s MotoWi4 broadband wireless system for backhaul and future WiMAX capabilities. The first two projects will be the much vaunted Philadelphia metrozone and another in Anaheim, California.

One of the highest profile metrozone projects has been in San Francisco, mainly because one of the bidders was Google, which proposed commissioning a network at no cost to the city, and offering basic services (best effort 256Kbps) at least, for free to the consumer. This showed how the metrozone concept could be a threat to the telcos by supporting very low cost competition to their networks, with revenues driven by alternative business models, largely taken from the internet not the telecoms world (in Google’s case, increased internet usage drives its online advertising and location services revenues, as well as its brand and likely uptake of some of its applications).

However, while there has been much excitement about the possibility that Google would build its own network and even invest in fiber to ensure that its services were the most prominent in the emerging metrozones, the search engine company clearly has no experience of running telecoms services and would rather, presumably, work with a partner that has. Earthlink, which is also bidding for the San Francisco project, was an obvious candidate, with both companies focused on helping stimulate expansion of internet usage beyond the traditional telco model. Google has no hostility to the carriers per se, provided it can persuade them to focus heavily on offering its applications rather than those of rivals such as Yahoo, but it knows that there is a huge user base that is not yet turned on to high cost 3G or broadband wireless services, but which it could lure to its adverts by offering low cost access channels over which it had total control. (Microsoft, of course, has the same notion, though so far it is focusing on getting low cost access into the Windows client through techniques such as spontaneous mesh software. However, expect it to start bidding for metrozone partnerships, or even for its own licensed spectrum, soon.)

While Google focuses on quantity rather than quality, offering best effort services for free to large numbers of users, Earthlink has an approach that could complement its new partner’s, concentrating on faster access, premium services, business offerings with full quality of service, and on leasing capacity to other ISPs, supported by the Motorola Canopy Wi4 backbone it is creating across its major cities. Their bid proposes two levels of service in which Google provides a free, advertising-supported service, and EarthLink provides a higher-grade, no-ad service for a $20 monthly fee. The free service would run at about 300Kbps, slower than most DSL lines, while the higher end service would operate at about 1Mbps.

The network would require EarthLink to install about 1,500 radio transmitters – made by Tropos – on light poles across the city. It would cost $6m-$7m to install and $15m for maintenance, upgrades and billing for the next 10 years, according to Don Berryman of EarthLink’s municipal Wi-Fi division. Most of that would come out of EarthLink’s pocket, Berryman said, but Google would help pay for the initial installation. The revenue split has not yet been detailed.

The current excitement about metrozones in the US may finally persuade investors to re-evaluate Earthlink, which appears to be pushing all the telecoms hot buttons right now. However, it must be careful not to overplay its hand and to ensure its various partnerships can work together. It knows it needs to be bold to compensate for the decline of its dial-up business and compete with other big names such as AOL ‘ which is considering a broadband wireless platform for its service, but has made no concrete moves yet. The municipal networks effort, despite its high profile, seems mainly a tactical response to a fairly short term need to reduce dial-up churn. It will deliver footprint rather than margin in this area, and in the profitable areas, Earthlink will be competing for paid-for, high quality services with the telco networks, rather than opening up new frontiers with free access like Google. It will be the combination of the metrozone services with other offerings such as the Helio MVNO and future broadband wireless and television options that will make Earthlink really disruptive, and enable it to leave its dial-up legacy behind as quickly as possible.

BOX ‘ the bidders in San Francisco

The Earthlink/Google/Motorola/Tropos combination looks the most likely to win the San Francisco project and to be a blueprint for other major city bids, with both key partners looking to create a coast to coast network (presumably bad news for WFI, Google’s original equipment partner, though). Of the six remaining contenders, the other heavyweight option is SF Metro Connect, a group consisting of Cisco (with its new metro mesh architecture), IBM and SeaKay. Also in the running are MetroFi, which also offers a network free to the city, Communication Bridge Global, NextWLAN and Razortooth Communications.

Cisco and IBM are teaming with SeaKay, a non-profit technology consultancy based in San Francisco. The group would be supported through corporate or private sponsorships.

Local company MetroFi proposes a service similar to the one it currently provides to Santa Clara, Sunnyvale and Cupertino. It offers a free, advertising supported service as well as a no-ad service – for the same download speeds – for about $20 a month.

NextWLAN, of Los Gatos, California, proposes that a system of Wi-Fi equipment be installed indoors – into DSL lines at $100 a pop – rather than outside, as the others have proposed.

San Francisco-based Razortooth would charge subscribers $5 per month for basic services that would be available at community Wi-Fi ‘stores’ around the city.

South San Francisco’s Communication Bridge Global proposes a network that would split its revenue with the city 80:20.

BOX

Since its dial-up business went into decline and it started to face significant churn in its traditional base, Earthlink has experimented with almost every form of broadband available.

2003: Offers CDMA 1xRTT data access to existing customers through an alliance with Verizon Wireless
2003: Signs deal with Vonage to offer paid-for VoIP
2004: Trials broadband over powerline
2004: Conducts first pre-WiMAX trials in northern California cities
2004: Launches SIP-based file sharing network called SIPShare to boost internet usage through peer-to-peer services
2004: Offers free SIP-based softphone VoIP services, similar to Skype
2004: Plans BlackBerry MVNO for business customers
2005: Launches Helio MVNO service as first product of SKT joint venture. To include its own VoIP offering
2005: Forms municipal metrozone division and wins several key deals including Philadelphia project
2006: Allies with Google in San Francisco metrozone bid
2006: Offers bundled services with DirecTV and DISH