As the race into metrozones shows (see separate item), there is a wide variety of service providers in the US that badly need broadband wireless to keep their existing offerings ‘ whether dial-up, wireline or satellite ‘ relevant, and able to survive among the major DSL and cellular operators. But license-exempt wireless has obvious limitations for a larger player that needs to keep its margins healthy, and so licensed spectrum will also be in ever greater demand. Sprint Nextel is the huge winner here ‘ the decision of the US authorities last year to let it keep its combined 2.5GHz holdings after its merger will prove to be one of the pivotal ones in modern US telecoms history, creating a company with the wherewithal to build a network as powerful and broadly spread as those of the Bell operators and large mobile carriers, and so a genuine third force against Verizon and AT&T/BellSouth. The FCC may have given Sprint the raw materials, and spurred it on by insisting on build-out by 2008, but the master stroke has been the operator’s own, in signing up the major cablecos as its wireline and content partners, resulting in a real converged offering.
Clearwire’s 2.5GHz holdings are less extensive and, in some areas, involve less bandwidth than Sprint’s but it is accumulating an impressive network, through license purchase and leasing partnerships, particularly with owners of the former educational broadcasting spectrum ITFS, which falls within the recently restructured BRS band around 2.5GHz. It is also helped by the fact that Sprint has chosen to focus its competitive instincts against the large telcos, not against its 2.5GHz counterpart, and the two operators have even discussed sharing spectrum assets. That has not materialized as yet, but there has been considerable cooperation, including two license swap deals that have increased Sprint’s strength in key urban markets and Clearwire’s in rural regions. The thinking is clearly to bolster each other’s differing business models rather than to conflict with each other, splitting an immature market while the incumbents divide and rule.
Clearwire is raising a huge amount of debt and other funding because it knows that competing in modern telecoms, and maintaining decent margins, is dependent on ownership of one or both of two items ‘ the network asset and the brand. Clearwire has no brand as yet, but its network gives it many options. Even if it never achieves a brand, nor major market share for its own access services, it is almost assured of a good return from partners clamouring to piggyback on its network. Primary candidates in the US would include EarthLink, whose joint venture with SKT, Helio, aims to extend its early MVNO and metrozone activities into broadband wireless access to provide a full triple play; and the satellite operators, DirecTV and Echostar, which need a return path and a mobile-capable network to offer the same spread of data, voice, video and mobile services as the large telcos and cablecos, which are increasingly moving into their television heartland.
With these, Clearwire could build a strategy mirroring that of Sprint Nextel. One or both of the satellite giants would bring it immediate revenue and cashflow, and funding to accelerate build-out. They would also bring content partnerships and other advantages that would help Clearwire’s network, like Sprint’s, carry a genuinely innovative multimedia content service with a strong hope of outdoing the Bellcos’ offerings (although Verizon, AT&T and BellSouth all hold 2.3GHz spectrum, this is in far smaller quantities than Sprint’s 2.5GHz).
A satellite deal would break down the cosy harmony between the 2.5GHz spectrum holders since it would enable Clearwire’s new partner or partners to take on the cablecos head-to-head on the next frontier of services, and therefore a network sharing agreement would likely be off the cards. But this would be compensated for by a guaranteed business model for the Clearwire network, and increased investment in expansion, as well as a potential sale option in the future. And unlike Sprint, Clearwire has already made its technology choices for 2.5GHz, having built out in 26 towns in the US, most recently the Tri-Cities in Washington, and many more in other parts of the world, using the NextNet equipment that it also owns.
Clearwire’s latest funding follows a $260m round of debt funding in August, plus $100m injected by Bell Canada as part of the companies’ 2005 joint venture, and an undisclosed but major funding from Intel. The two major debt offerings have been structured so that they could be doubled in size and it is likely ‘ though Clearwire is notoriously secretive about its activities ‘ that the company has already accumulated over $1bn. Not a massive sum in telecoms, but enough to get large partners to take the company serious, to acquire additional spectrum and support NextNet, and to overshadow all other start-ups in the sector. At the time of the Bell Canada deal last year, it emerged that the Canadian giant’s $100m investment gave it a 12% stake, giving Clearwire a valuation of $833m. A strategic deal with a satellite carrier would increase this significantly and would really bring Craig McCaw’s venture out into the mainstream.