The Clearwire engine gathers further momentum, with the US start-up’s key ally, Bell Canada, completing phase one of its network roll-out in Canada, through its joint venture with Rogers Wireless. The much anticipated deal between Clearwire and one or both US satellite broadcasters ‘ which have been open about their need for a broadband wireless network ‘ has not yet materialized, but even without that boost, the Craig McCaw-led company is creating a network of partners that enable it to punch above its weight in the telecoms world.
The first result will be a network spanning much of north America and Mexico by the end of 2007, all based on equipment from NextNet, Clearwire’s equipment subsidiary. The main components will be the company’s own build-out in the US, currently largely in suburban areas and smaller cities; the Inukshuk venture, which will cover over 100 urban and rural markets in Canada by 2008; and the NextNet-based system of MVS in Mexico. Roaming deals are in place, and Clearwire is also rapidly expanding its acquisition of spectrum, and launching its first commercial services, across Europe and other areas. Plus, it will soon launch its VoIP service, hosted by Bell Canada and aiming to increase its ARPU in the business sector, in particular. Other advances will be the introduction of smaller NextNet subscriber units, including PCMCIA cards, which should stimulate uptake and usage by offering a portable, personal broadband service; and an increasing presence in public safety, where the company offers a specially designed mobile system for emergency vehicles.
This rosy outlook raises two questions in our minds ‘ how long before the major carriers start getting aggressive about Clearwire, and how much does the company really need to move to WiMAX?
The provider has, so far, remained on cooperative terms with the other major holder of 2.5GHz spectrum in the US, Sprint Nextel, and the two have carried out two major spectrum swaps to streamline and better focus their holdings. Sprint is unlikely to turn against Clearwire, and could even look for a broader spectrum sharing deal or an MVNO agreement, since it has bigger rivals to worry about, and the companies are, perhaps deliberately, targeting different business models and demographics. But the Bellcos will be different ‘ already the two companies are head-to-head in some territories in Florida and Clearwire provides a real threat to their broadband dominance, particularly once it mobilizes the subscriber units to support true personal broadband. Provision of a personal connection ‘ rather than a household or office one – that can be carried about with the user has been shown to be a major advantage when competing for dial-up migration with fixed line operators, as the success of bundled fixed line/Wi-Fi subscriptions and of some early mobile broadband operators, such as Unwired Australia in Sydney, have demonstrated. So there is a real prospect of Clearwire seizing significant market share, particularly in areas where there has not yet been significant shift from dial-up to broadband.
Does Clearwire need to move to WiMAX? Since it owns its equipment maker, the pressure to adopt a standard in order to have a choice of vendors and foster price competition is not relevant, although it raises its own challenges in terms of keeping manufacturing and supply costs low. But early adopters of the nomadic WiMAX standard, 802.16e, may find that they have to compromise on some of the functionality of their proprietary mobile products. Navini has bit that bullet and is promising to migrate its Ripwave platform to 802.16e at an early stage, but Clearwire/NextNet, while professing support for the WiMAX roadmap, has been far more hesitant about any timescales, and several Clearwire executives have publicly urged the market not to overhype the new technology. As long as the NextNet technology is thought to offer its parent, and other partners such as Inukshuk, a competitive edge, there will be no rush to move to WiMAX ‘ a situation that could leave the largest American broadband wireless systems outside the 802.16 fold, if Sprint Nextel does not pick WiMAX for its own 2.5GHz build-out, with consequent negative impact on WiMAX’ volumes and credibility.
Until 802.16e can become a truly international mobile network, Clearwire’s roaming deals in Canada, Mexico and elsewhere will give it greater spread than WiMAX in the early days, and allow it to choose the right time for its business to migrate to standards, rather than ramroading it into a hasty move that might compromise on its competitiveness.
The Inukshuk service:
Inuksuk, the 50:50 joint venture of Bell Canada and Rogers Communications, has completed phase one of its planned national roll-out. This first stage offers the service, branded as Portable Internet by Rogers ad Sympatico High Speed Unplugged by Bell, to 5m households and 40% of the population, providing 1.5Mbps downlink and 256Kbps uplink for Can$49.95 a month.
The initial 20 territories are Greater Vancouver, Victoria, Red Deer, Calgary, Edmonton, Whitehorse, Greater Toronto Area, Barrie, London, Windsor, Kitchener-Waterloo, Hamilton, Ottawa, Gatineau-Hull, Quebec City, Greater Montreal Area, Charlottetown, Halifax, Fredericton and St. John’s.
Once complete, the network will cover more than 40 Canadian cities and 50 rural and remote communities, and two-thirds of the population. Bell Canada and Rogers expect to spend $200m on the total build-out in their combined 2.5GHz spectrum holdings, which cover the whole of Canada except Manitoba and Saskatchewan, home to about 30m Canadians.
Bell and Rogers will each have the right to use 50% of the network’s total capacity, but will compete against each other using their own sales and marketing staffs.
The Bell-Clearwire alliance:
Bell Canada announced last September that it would buy Clearwire’s 50% stake in NR Communications, an investment house run by McCaw’s long time associate Nick Kauser, which set up a joint venture, Inukshuk Internet, in early 2004 with Canadian telcos Microcell and AllStream, to build a national service in 2.5GHz spectrum, using the NextNet Expedience pre-WiMAX kit since acquired owned by Clearwire. AllStream subsequently sold its stake to its partners and Microcell was acquired by Bell rival Rogers Wireless.
These two telcos will now jointly build and manage the new network but the new transaction will give Bell full control of NR, in which it took a 50% stake, alongside a $100m investment in Clearwire, in March ‘ and so the majority stake in the new-look Inukshuk.
The original Inukshuk three-way venture has launched services in a few test markets but now progress is being stepped up significantly. Bell Canada and Rogers pooled their wireless broadband spectrum holdings into the joint venture, Rogers contributing its entire spectrum holdings in the 2.3GHz, 2.5GHz and 3.5GHz bands, while Bell Canada provided its holdings in the 2.3GHz and 2.5GHz bands. Inukshuk already held about 98MHz of 2.5GHz spectrum across Canada.
Inukshuk will operate the network on a cost recovery basis, with Bell Canada and Rogers each having the rights to use 50% of the network’s total transmission capacity.