Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 April 2006

T-Mobile close to UMA roll-out, Cingular prefers SIP

Amid rising carrier urgency about launching Wi-Fi/cellular roaming services, the UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access) technology has grabbed a definite headstart in terms of profile, especially in Europe, with the enthusiastic backing of Motorola and Nokia and a score of operator trials. Now UMA is set to be tested in earnest as several carriers look to announce commercial services in the coming months. Success, especially the timely availability of handsets, will be essential if UMA is to become a long term element of the mobile operators’ strategies, rather than just a stepping stone to broader convergence platforms like IMS (IP Multimedia Subsystem), which unlike UMA are built around the increasingly dominant SIP standard.

While Europe has been the main trialling ground for UMA, and boasts its first live service, BT Fusion in the UK, the first great showdown between the UMA and SIP options will take place in the US, where T-Mobile USA and Cingular are taking opposite approaches.

UMA – which was created in 2004 by Kineto Wireless, large vendors like Ericsson and Alcatel, and carriers like BT and Cingular ‘ is now part of the 3GPP standards family. Kineto claims it has been involved in about 15 RFPs (requests for proposals) that specifically call for UMA systems in the past six months. BT was the first to launch a UMA service (Fusion) and TeliaSonera and T-Mobile USA are likely to be next in line. The latter will see UMA as valuable in tying together its cellular and its extensive hotspot networks, as it is one of the cellcos most reliant on multiple networks for its next generation services.

“We are on the verge of carrier deployments of UMA,” Citigroup analyst Daryl Armstrong wrote in a recent research note. “As a rule, carriers that lack meaningful wireline assets seem to be most interested in deploying this technology.”

However, other carriers believe IMS is now sufficiently evolved to enable them to bypass UMA. Notable among these are the CDMA operators, and original UMA supporter Cingular, which will now base its multinetwork convergence plans on SIP. It claims UMA no longer has a major time to market advantage over IMS/SIP and will launch its first IMS-based application this year.

A critical issue will be handset support, of course. There are currently no formally announced IMS phones, although several vendors ‘ notably Nokia, Motorola and Samsung ‘ have launched devices with UMA support. Some operators complain that these are overpriced, however, especially for markets such as some African states, where 3G is not built out and carriers are looking to use unlicensed spectrum and Wi-Fi for quicker, lower cost launch of data services.

Most of the impetus behind Wi-Fi/cellular convergence has come from cellular network players so far, but now the WLan specialists are getting in on the act, especially for the enterprise and business traveller bases. Recently, the Wi-Fi Alliance agreed to a joint certification program with the CTIA focused on dual-mode handsets, and last week corporate WLan supplier Trapeze demonstrated hand-off between its systems and a cellular network, using a Windows Mobile handset.

Trapeze is using appliances from start-up DiVitas Networks to let any Microsoft Windows Mobile 5.0 handset roam seamlessly from a cellular to a Wi-Fi network, without any involvement by the cellular service provider. While UMA is largely a tool for the cellcos, allowing them to counter the onslaught of wireless VoIP by supporting Wi-Fi, such moves from the WLan community are more threatening, offering a route to convergence that cuts the cellco out of the equation, and the revenue share.