Speculation and controversy are heating up in equal measure as the June 29 date to kick off major US spectrum auctions approaches. The big questions are whether non-telcos will join the bidding, and whether recent rule changes have made it impossible for small players to take part in the auction.
T-Mobile is the most certain big bidder, since its current shortage of spectrum will severely hamper its ability to compete in 3G. Time Warner Cable, which has often referred to its interest in being a mobile carrier, is also tipped to take part, although this could conflict with its joint venture with Sprint Nextel.
The FCC will start auctioning 90MHz of AWS (Advanced Wireless Services) spectrum in 1.7GHz-2.1GHz, covering most of the US, at the end of next month, and initial applications are due by May 10. Participants will not be able to discuss bids with each other, because of a new anti-collusion rule.
According to a new research report from investment bankers Lehman Brothers, non-traditional bidders are highly likely to take part, possibly in partnership with current cellcos, in order to create a stronger route to market for their internet technologies, and this could strengthen the hand of the internet industry ‘to change the negotiating dynamics with the national telecom service providers regarding net neutrality.”
Google and Microsoft have been the internet giants most expected to join the bidding, and Time Warner could also be a candidate, possibly working with current cellco partner Sprint, as ownership of spectrum could accelerate its wireless moves for both its cable and AOL arms (see separate item). Earthlink ‘ likely with financial backing from its strategic partner Google and South Korea Telecom ‘ could also take an interest in acquiring its own spectrum, to step up its recent efforts to create a broadband system independent of the telcos.
Of the traditional players, T-Mobile is expected to spend about $6bn to acquire sufficient spectrum to make a competitive 3G roll-out practical ‘ if it fails to gain sufficient frequencies, it will need to take the riskier strategy of relying largely on non-3G broadband wireless systems, such as Wi-Fi and future bids for 700MHz bands. It is more likely that, in this situation, parent Deutsche Telekom would look to sell off the unit, despite its current impressive growth record.
Verizon Wireless is not in urgent need of additional spectrum, having spent $3bn last year to acquire PCS licenses in 23 markets from NextWave in the latter’s bankruptcy settlement. However, Verizon could spend up to $3bn, Lehman believes, to ensure it stays ahead of its rivals, especially as it is well aware that the other major CDMA carrier, Sprint Nextel, has extensive holdings both in PCS and 2.5GHz bands. Sprint itself, unless as part of its far ranging cableco alliance, is less likely to make a major play for AWS. Sprint officials have said that the current traffic on the company’s network uses only a small percentage of its swathe of 1.9GHz PCS spectrum, which it bought in 1995, despite the capacity leased by its numerous MVNO partners, such as Virgin Mobile.
Cingular also has no real need to take part, claiming ‘the best spectrum situation in the industry’, though it will file for participation and may top up its holdings in a few markets if possible.
Some regional carriers such as MetroPCS and Leap Wireless are also likely to be bidders, but Alltel, the largest regional cellco, and the US’ fifth biggest overall, says it may stay away. Like the spectrum rich giants such as Verizon, it may save its money for future auctions of potentially more attractive spectrum, such as the 700MHz analog television frequencies, which are very appealing for rural access, and so would suit Alltel.
Alltel CEO Scott Ford said in a recent conference call: “We are leaning towards not going to this auction, and we are taking a hard look at those things that are scheduled to come down over the next two or three years because that’s much better spectrum for building out networks.’ Alltel is also likely to be conserving its cash to make further acquisitions in the fall, saying the upcoming auctions have put a temporary halt on M&A activity in the US mobile sector. Alltel expects 2006 revenue of up to $8.02bn, which would be 10% up on 2005. It is close to spinning off its wireline business.
While major regional players may see the coming rounds of auctions as a golden opportunity to stay in the game despite the consolidation of the giants, the hundreds of small US local operators are unhappy with new auction rules that the FCC has introduced in an effort to make the contest more open to small and non-traditional contenders.
Last week, three groups today – the Minority Media and Telecommunications Council, and Council Tree Communications and Bethel Native, both Native American providers – asked the FCC to drop the changes to the small business bidding rules and even to delay the June 29 start of the auction to resolve the issue. Their main problem is that the FCC’s new guidelines, which seek to restrict the ability of large carriers to bid covertly through partnerships with smaller operators, do not just apply to these large companies, but also to ‘designated entities’ (DEs), a small business category eligible for 25% bidding discounts and other benefits at FCC auctions.
‘Adoption of such broadly applicable new rules merely two weeks before the short-form application deadline for Auction 66 is incurably disruptive to the business plans of designated entities, their investors and their strategic partners,’ the three parties stated. They added that the new rules violate a 1993 law designed to foster diversity in wireless telecom licensing.
The FCC recently declined to impose a revenue-based threshold for partnership eligibility in favor of a resale standard to determine whether national mobile carriers and other large telecom firms can join forces with start-ups and entrepreneurs to pursue discounted wireless licenses at the AWS auction and future auctions. The FCC said a wireless carrier that leases more than 50% of its spectrum capacity cannot gain DE benefits through alliances with DE applicants. The commission also extended from five to ten years restrictions on selling DE wireless licenses.