Sprint Nextel’s choice of WiMAX for its next generation network may have confirmed the status of 802.16 as the premier mobile broadband challenger to the UMTS/LTE roadmap, but some technologies and companies retained allegiance to more niche options. Now, the acquisition of IPWireless by WiMAX cheerleader NextWave, and Qualcomm’s purchase of TeleCIS’ 802.16 system on chip assets, indicate that these alternatives to WiMAX have thrown in the towel, setting the whole industry on course to support WiMAX and/or LTE – with Qualcomm’s EV-DO Rev C as a third horse and Wi-Fi as a complement – for the OFDM-based next iteration of wireless networking.
It is already easy to forget that WiMAX was, only a few years ago, just one candidate among several potentially viable technologies to underpin the OFDM mobile broadband future. ArrayComm’s iBurst looked like the most spectrally advanced, and is still supported as a niche platform by Kyocera, but its creator saw the way the wind was blowing in broadband wireless and took the 802.16 shilling. IPWireless was promising a technology that could exploit existing spectrum assets – the TDD strand of the UMTS allocations as well as 3.5GHz – and provide a TDD, data-focused stepping stone to LTE. But rejection by Sprint and failure to secure sufficiently large contracts from its flagship clients such as Orange pushed IPWireless, the only real proponent of the TD-CDMA standard, into the hands of NextWave, which is likely to use the base technology to enhance its WiMAX offering and provide closer integration with emerging LTE systems (see below and Wireless Watch April 16 2007).
Flarion’s Flash-OFDM was another strong player, but failed to gain major vendor support as an independent offering, partly because it remained tied to the 802.20 standards effort – once the key focus of truly mobile broadband development, but strangled by politics and the widening remit of 802.16 into mobility. This led to Flarion’s stunning $600m acquisition by Qualcomm, for incorporation into that company’s advanced but stubbornly non-WiMAX OFDM roadmap (and an abortive attempt to resurrect 802.20 as a major standard under the CDMA giant’s influence). But Qualcomm has been making gradual concessions to the fact that it can no longer hope to set up an alternative to WiMAX that is under its direct control, despite its efforts with Flash-OFDM (the third generation of EV-DO, Rev C or UMB, will appeal mainly to existing EV-DO users, and there are some doubts, expressed by CDMA vendors like Nortel, as to whether UMB will actually ever be commercialized). So the chipmaker needs to apply its famous engineering talents and its evolving intellectual property business models to technologies it cannot control so firmly, as it has already done in UMTS. It is promising early LTE silicon, and with the purchase of the 802.16e development assets of TeleCIS it is pointing the way to its own WiMAX and multimode WiMAX/CDMA/Wi-Fi chipsets (although it has not officially said it will use its new 16e jewels for WiMAX).
The multimode handset is a particularly important market for Qualcomm as it has proven differentiation in integrating multiple radios into a compact package. It is also a crucial weapon in retaining control of the CDMA handset vendor base, as these companies will be looking to reduce their risk in the face of the possible – though probably exaggerated – decline of CDMA. One way will be to combine CDMA with other technologies in handsets and other devices, aimed at the rising breed of operators that are prepared to support more than one network in the battle to deliver new services. Sprint, of course, is the most prominent early example, and will be looking to Motorola, Sanyo and others to deliver CDMA/WiMAX devices. Currently, these phonemakers are looking to specialists like Beceem for the WiMAX silicon – Sanyo recently joined Samsung and Motorola in sourcing Beceem 802.16e handset chips. Qualcomm would clearly prefer to supply the whole system, not just the CDMA component, and with the TeleCIS assets and its own OFDM efforts, is gearing up to do so.
TeleCIS has been one of the technologically impressive WiMAX chip start-ups, but – in contrast to Beceem, Runcom and others – has not attracted major customers yet, despite an ongoing relationship with Samsung and SKT, and an early focus on Wi-Bro. The company has been in the forefront of vendors claiming that the current fixed WiMAX standard should be exploited for portable devices such as laptops, in order to kickstart the use of such products even before the 802.16e mobile standard is widely available.
TeleCIS uses performance enhancements such as MIMO and Diversity Combining space-time coding, on a single-chip design to boost signal gain while keeping power consumption low.
It is this, rather than WiMAX specifically, that Qualcomm says has attracted it to buy the company’s 16e development assets (TeleCIS itself will retain its existing product for 802.16-2004, the TCW 1620 Fixed/Portable SoC, maintaining its argument that there is a market for this platform for at least a few years, in the lucrative laptop/business traveller device sector, that will thrive independently of 16e and will bridge the gap to fully mobile WiMAX). Qualcomm says it acquired TeleCIS’s engineering unit for its “mobile broadband system knowledge and SoC design experience”, and that these would be applied to multiple R&D initiatives including Rev C and LTE. A spokesperson would go no further, in terms of WiMAX, than to reiterate previous statements by CEO Paul Jacobs and others, that Qualcomm would produce WiMAX chips should it see sufficient demand and business case, and that it already possesses significant technology and IPR that could give it a speedy entry into the 802.16 market.
We believe these statements to be disingenuous and insiders hint at WiMAX products in an advanced state of readiness. Like Motorola, Nortel and the other multi-technology wireless majors, Qualcomm can take advantage of the converging technical paths of LTE, WiMAX and UMB to support all three standards with relatively little extra R&D investment, and it has certainly taken a leading role in mobile OFDM development with technologies like Flarion and FLO. Qualcomm may be a proud and stubborn company, but it is not a stupid one, and would not bite off its nose to spite its face by clinging to its opposition to WiMAX purely for political reasons. There seems no reason not to include 16e in its roadmap now, especially with a view to supporting multimode handsets for vendors serving some of its key operator customers, such as Sprint and KT. Nor does there seem sufficient reason to choose TeleCIS, of all the OFDM-oriented clever start-ups around, if it is not interested in enhancing its specific WiMAX skills with a view to creating an SoC for 16e. As a bonus, this could also reduce the chances of the stronger WiMAX specialists, such as Beceem and Runcom, following in Qualcomm’s own footsteps and gaining a major position in the wireless industry through an upstart technology.
Expect Qualcomm WiMAX or multimode handset chipsets in 2008 ‘
As for IPWireless, the $100m acquisition (which could go up to $235m depending on performance) by NextWave does not officially lead to the death of its implementation of TD-CDMA, as its new owner says it will continue to offer the technology, which is in use in networks in Japan, the UK, eastern Europe and elsewhere. However, as with Qualcomm and Flarion, the main aim of NextWave will be to harvest advanced technology elements from the IPWireless system to incorporate into its own roadmap, which has so far been based on WiMAX. NextWave will now have to make decisions about whether to pursue a pure WiMAX strategy, incorporating elements of TD-CDMA and Wi-Fi to differentiate its implementation; whether to support multiple networks for different applications, or create a semi-proprietary but high performance hybrid; and whether the resulting network should remain purely to support its own services, or be offered to the open market in future.
In its early years, NextWave could be defined categorically as a service provider, although its first attempt to create a US business collapsed when it failed to pay for vast swathes of PCS spectrum it had acquired, forcing it into bankruptcy protection and a series of compromise agreements with the FCC and the major acquirer of its spectrum assets, Verizon. However, it kept its holdings in 2.5GHz, and emerged from bankruptcy protection with a new plan focused on offering high performance broadband wireless and mobile internet services on this, using “certain emerging fourth generation wireless technologies and devices” – which so far has translated into its own implementation of WiMAX. It then acquired substantial holdings in AWS spectrum in last year’s US auction, and also has frequencies in other countries such as Germany (through a venture with Inquam Broadband, formerly an associate company of Qualcomm). But its insistence on creating its own broadband wireless chip and network platform, which it confidently refers to as ‘WiMAXplus’, has blurred the distinction between its roles as operator and vendor, suggesting its medium term business model may be closer to that of Qualcomm – where NextWave co-founder and CEO Allen Salmasi was a member of the executive team, and which has been an investor since 2001 – than of a conventional provider.
This WiMAXplus platform promises to support mobile internet and web 2.0 services better than any other pre-4G system, the company boasts, and it claims that this will give clear differentiation to the services it can deliver to consumers and businesses – a differentiation only possible through complete design control of the network. Acquisitions such as IPWireless, chipmaker Cygnus, embedded multimedia software company PacketVideo, Wi-Fi company GO Networks, and equipment developers Advanced Technology Group and Network Solutions Group, could all add multimedia and other functionality to the homegrown platform, which NextWave says will tweak WiMAX for better support of key applications such as high volume mobile VoIP and real time video.
“A key design objective of our products and technologies is to improve the ability of mobile WiMAX to cost effectively handle the large volume of network traffic that we believe VoIP telephony, high speed web surfing and next generation wireless multimedia applications such as high resolution streaming video, high fidelity streaming audio and interactive real time gaming will generate,” the company said in its 2006 IPO filing.
But designing a network purely for internal use in the early stages of a company’s life, and having to source a non-standard set of equipment, is a very expensive option at a time when most operators are looking to buy commoditized hardware and gain competitive edge through software – and even more complex now the company has WiMAX, Wi-Fi and TD-CDMA elements, which will require integration into a common platform to ensure that NextWave has a unique network, not a fragmented set of support and R&D challenges. Clearwire had the same internal debate, initially aiming to control its technology destiny by owning the NextNet products, but then offloading these to Motorola as part of last year’s investment by the handset giant and Intel. For Clearwire, what had started as a means to roll out broadband wireless without waiting for WiMAX standards and to gain services edge, had become an expensive and slow route towards the economic advantages of a standardized platform.
NextWave may face the same problem – or may be aiming to create an equipment unit sufficiently attractive to sell to a company such as Motorola in future – unless its real aim is to become a vendor. In this case, given its relatively late entry and limited resources, differentiation of the platform becomes critical and the investment in advanced enhancements such as TDtv more justifiable. Like Qualcomm, NextWave may be aiming to acquire spectrum primarily to generate early cashflow from services and to develop, test and showcase the technology before offering it on the open market – something Qualcomm has done on various occasions, notably with its MediaFLO television network and its investments in the 1990s in 450MHz operators around the world, and most famously when it created networks and acquired some licenses for early CDMA networks, before handing over this business to Ericsson after their first major patent infringement war. This approach of buying spectrum in order to kickstart a technology may also be considered by vendors such as Intel, especially when it comes to the 700MHz auctions in the US and elsewhere. This will be highly attractive spectrum for mobile broadband and so supporters of WiMAX and LTE will be keen to snap it up, with NextWave possibly a high bidder again.
Indeed, this is where another similarity with Clearwire becomes apparent. Craig McCaw’s latest brainchild focused heavily on public safety in the early days, in order to target relatively low hanging fruit and to gain access to additional spectrum, on which commercial services might be added later. Two years ago, Clearwire used the skills of its NextNet subsidiary in emergency response systems to win a hugely important agreement to provide the network for a major US emergency response project prototype in New York (this was the GUARD or Geospatially-Aware Urban Approaches for Responding to Disasters program, a collaboration between Rosettex Technology & Ventures Group, with Thirteen/WNET, Raytheon, NextNet, KenCast and Grey Island Systems). Apart from revenue, this deal provided proof of a key McCaw concept – that the underused 2.5GHz ITFS spectrum previously allocated in the US to educational broadcasting could become the basis of a national broadband wireless network and that the initial build-out would often be driven by public safety. Clearwire leased 2.5GHz frequencies from metro broadcaster Thirteen/WNET, as it has done from many other educational broadcasters, which were permitted by the FCC in 2004 to use spare capacity for other purposes. ‘Spectrum availability has long been one of the greatest obstacles to effective emergency communications,’ said Bill Baker, president of Thirteen/WNET.
Now NextWave is pursuing a similar path. One of its reasons to be attracted to IPWireless was the latter’s recently won $500m contract with Northrop Grumman to provide New York City’s broadband public safety wireless network. NextWave considers that IPWireless’ technology is ideal for public safety applications and this will enable it to target 700MHz spectrum – not just by bidding for commercial licenses, but via the potentially cheaper and easier route of the portion of that band that will be set aside for public safety systems.
In public safety, it is less important that NextWave supports standards, although many agencies will insist on them, and the same is true if it keeps its system for its own networks and does not sell it on the open market. If it aims to become a vendor, it will have to choose a system that large numbers of customers want – Flarion and IPWireless itself have shown the dangers of going out on a technological limb. Even on its own networks, it will need to source handsets and sign roaming deals, difficult if it has a one-off technology (it should look to the Nextel example, and remember that, despite its public safety ambitions, it does not have the ‘killer app’ that push to talk gave Nextel’s unique iDEN system). It has two real choices – to combine its various assets, notably the mobile TV acquisitions, into a standards compliant but enhanced implementation of WiMAX, and abandon TD-CDMA; or adopt the original IPWireless approach of presenting TD-CDMA as a stepping stone to LTE. Since it would be fairly impractical either to build out TD-CDMA – the only such system in the US – or wait for LTE, in this case it would likely aim to produce one of the first combined WiMAX/LTE platforms, a goal shared with most major vendors and likely to be very important to operators, but which we would doubt NextWave has the resources to create without major partners.
In the end, then, the chipmakers and systems vendors are finally accepting that WiMAX and LTE (with UMB) are the future, and rather than fighting that, they need to develop or acquire ecosystem technologies to ensure their implementations of the standards are clearly differentiated. Qualcomm, for all its coyness, is likely to come up with a hotshot WiMAX offering at some stage; NextWave is a less certain quantity, but the eventual progress of the IPWireless platform will be an interesting one to watch.
Texas Instruments:
Long before the standards are finalized, chipmakers are gearing up for LTE, as the roadmap is accelerated under pressure from WiMAX challenges and impatient carriers. Texas Instruments will be looking to make an early entry in handsets to try to steal back some of the first mover advantage Qualcomm has been snatching in 3G. On the infrastructure side too, the Texas giant is looking to the pre-4G future, announcing a development ecosystem to support LTE and LTE/WiMAX prototypes.
The platform combines TI’s wireless infrastructure DSPs, an optimized software library, and ATCA/AMC cards from Mercury Computer Systems, STx and Axis Communications, in a bid to reduce OEMs’ time to market once LTE starts to be commercialized from 2008.
Using its TMS320TCI6482 and TMS320TCI6487 DSPs, TI has created a series of designs leveraging system level benchmarks. These illustrate various system architectures to support UMTS/HSPA, WiMAX and LTE. The software library harnesses TI’s existing WiMAX Wave 2 compliant library, with a range of LTE-specific algorithms, indicating the large degree of overlap between the two standards.
The partnership with UK-based Axis focuses on the smaller company’s multichannel multichannel OFDM digital radio and RF solutions, which support MIMO and AAS smart antenna systems. Axis has created its current platform for WiMAX and will now adapt it for LTE, using TI’s analog devices in modulator and other functions.