Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 April 2007

Motorola’s Zander plays for time as Nokia’s Kallasvuo shows his acumen

The first quarter of 2007 saw a continuation of patterns familiar from the latter half of last year – Motorola under pressure from its over-commitment to low cost handsets; Nokia striking a better balance between market share and profits; Sony Ericsson storming along; and the Koreans in the doldrums.

Motorola is under the greatest pressure, of course, still fighting off attempts by corporate raider Carl Icahn to join its board and challenge the strategy of CEO Ed Zander. After the initial sparkling turnaround under Zander’s guidance, the success of the iconic RAZR and the creation of a convincing converged broadband roadmap for the infrastructure arm, the past six months have seen a bad hiccup for Motorola. It has failed, so far, to find a worthy successor to RAZR; has gone too far down the ultra-low cost handset route at the expense of margins, and without sufficient market share gain to justify this; its high end phones are being challenged effectively in some markets by Samsung, Nokia and even the impending iPhone; and while the Networks business is shining in terms of strategic decisions and customer endorsement, the efforts in WiMAX, mesh and other key technologies are not yet turning into major revenue.

Zander’s task is to convince the market that this current downturn is a blip in an otherwise strong trajectory – not that the heady ‘year of RAZR’ was a blip in the general stagnation of a US institution that is not adapting quickly enough to the new communications world. We would still favour the former, more optimistic view. Motorola has massive R&D and technological expertise and under new processes and structures initiated by the Zander team, has succeeded in leveraging these better than it did for several years before his arrival. The failure in 3G has been a real problem but the forward path for infrastructure is creative and taps into genuine operator and consumer trends, drawing on Motorola’s own peculiar mix of products, from public safety networks to set-top boxes, to catch the convergence zeitgeist. And while a second RAZR may be too much to hope for, the success of that handset has at least restored the credibility of the Motorola brand in handsets, after various disastrous mis-steps such as missing the early cameraphone boat.

Motorola’s problems are currently too short term to affect customer confidence seriously, we believe (operators understand blips, and sometimes a company that is going through bad times, but with no chance of fading away, can be a good one to negotiate with). But on the shareholder side, there is a very impatient faction that is increasingly vocal. All the advantages listed above will only turn slowly into real recovery and sustained performance, something Zander himself admits, and some institutions are not prepared to wait so long – and are being aggressively wooed by those, such as Icahn, who are demanding more radical change of direction, and even (tacitly) the head of Zander.

Zander told Business Week this week that turnaround “will take us a little time” but claimed: “We’ve got to get back on the horse and start riding again”. He also admitted in another interview that the all-out chasing of market share through aggressive price cutting had been a “major error of judgement”.

Though lackluster, the first quarter results offered some reason to hope, with shares rising 2% in their wake. This indicated that the results had largely met or exceeded expectations (these, of course, severely lowered by recent events and Motorola warnings), and perhaps that investors have the confidence in the company’s basic strengths to give it some time to work out its current problems.

How much time, though, before the more aggressive arguments of Icahn and others win out?

In the first quarter, Motorola reported a loss of $181m on its first sales decline in almost four years, to $9.43bn, about $5.4bn from handsets, which saw a 15% drop in revenue. The handset business also contributed a $231m operating loss, compared with operating earnings of $701m a year earlier. So most of the trouble was arising from the cellphone unit, where the company has lost share to Nokia and Samsung. This is the most worrying factor, since Motorola was pinning hopes on stealing market share from Nokia by chasing the low cost sector – in fact, according to Strategy Analytics, its share fell sharply in Q1 to 19%, from 21.5% in the fourth quarter or 2006. By contrast, set-top boxes and infrastructure were prospering, but despite this, analysts are talking about a two-year period for real turnaround and for Zander’s recent structural changes, plus current development projects, to bear fruit.

Motorola said acquisition costs factored into its operating losses, since it acquired four companies recently – Symbol, Tut, Netopia and Good. It added that second quarter sales will be “essentially flat” compared with the first quarter and it forecast per-share earnings of 2-3 cents before certain items. However, Zander said it would be back in the black by the end of this year as it accelerates its share buyback program (a key Icahn demand), streamlines its product portfolio, introduces more Linux and Java-based phones and carries out the previously announced job cuts. Analysts are dampening expectations, some predicting zero revenue growth for the full year and falls in share price to as low as $15 before the upward trend begins.

Nokia has certainly, so far at least, handled the balancing act between volume and margin more effectively than its main rival, steering clear of ultra-low cost devices and concentrating instead on introducing new classes of product to the middle classes of the emerging economies, in order to achieve revenues and some volume in growth markets, before it will turn its superior logistics and economies of scale to the mass user base. The policy seems to be working – Nokia has an expanding market lead in China, despite the low cost structures of local vendors, and is credited with two-thirds of the Indian handset sector. Through all this, and despite some swing towards low end phones, it reported increased gross margins in its first quarter, compared to Q4 of 2006 (though down by 1% on a year earlier). Overall market share remained unchanged at 36% – a pattern shared with Sony Ericsson, whose margins rose and whose revenues stunned, but which did not repeat recent gains in share, one factor behind its intention to shift slightly towards the lower end this year.

However, Nokia’s Q1 net profit did decline, by 6.6% to $1.21bn, because of falling average handset selling prices and a move, however controlled, towards emerging markets. Revenue was up 4% year-on-year to $13.4bn. A 5% decline in mobile phone revenue was nearly offset by a 28% rise in the sales of ‘multimedia computing devices’, as Nokia calls its N Series of smartphones. Nokia forecast flat growth for the second quarter but talked up further market share gains through 2007.

Sony Ericsson saw net profit more than double during its Q1, thanks largely to strong sales of its camera and music handsets, especially the Walkman phones, in Europe. Net profit rose to $345.6m as revenue grew by 47% to $2.93bn. Handset shipments rose 64%, from 13.3m during the same period last year to 21.8m during the first quarter, the largest year-on-year improvement among the majors. Sony Ericsson now has partnerships with Foxconn, Flextronics and to help take it into the emerging economies, particularly India.

Samsung is likely to be the most direct beneficiary of Motorola’s current pain, with its handset division one of the few bright spots in poor overall corporate Q1 figures, and with its strongest new models firmly targeted at Motorola’s areas of influence. Unlike Nokia, Samsung can attack Motorola in the CDMA space as well as GSM/UMTS.

Fellow Korean LG posted an expected seasonal decrease in handset shipments and flat growth year-on-year, with a total of 15.8m units shipped during the quarter. The company said improvements from its more diversified product portfolio and industry-wide growth in the W-CDMA sector buoyed operating margins. LG has ridden the success of its iconic Black Label Chocolate series, but now the company hopes some of its more premium devices, like the Shine handsets and its digital multimedia broadcast devices, will gain a similar cult following. LG Electronics suffered a $132m Q1 net loss, but mostly because of television sales.

All eyes will be on the giants’ ability to balance growth and profit in the coming year, with two metrics especially vital – gross margin and average handset price. The latter will inevitably decline, and the value of the company will rest in great part on how it offsets this. Nokia is showing the way – even more than Sony Ericsson, which has yet really to test the low cost waters. The average selling price of handsets for Nokia decreased by 13.6% to $121 in Q1, but increase in volume – shipments up 21% to about 91.1m units – meant that revenue still rose. By contrast, Motorola’s handset shipments fell 31% to a mere 45.4m units during the quarter.

It’s a tough comparison, and Nokia’s CEO, Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo, could have been aiming his comments, made during the analyst results call, at his rival Zander. “When it comes to turning up the heat, it’s a question of managing tactically, in the right way, by combining your aggressiveness, market position and margins in the right way,’ he said. Zander, who is more than capable of demonstrating aggressiveness and clever balancing, will be taking these words to heart as he seeks to stave off shareholder revolt and gain sufficient time to make up for the error of judgement over low cost handsets.

The Icahn war of words:

In a letter to shareholders on April 13, Icahn claimed Motorola’s “passive and reactive board” should have been able to help the company avoid recent missteps. Motorola management had previously mailed shareholders with arguments why Icahn should not gain a seat on its board, prompting the billionaire investor’s tirade against the cellphone maker’s governance.

Motorola fired back with a letter defending its board, and Icahn reiterated his arguments. Then Motorola pointed to a study by Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS), a major proxy advisory firm, which ranks Motorola in the top 6.6% of all Standard & Poor’s 500 index companies for corporate governance, in contrast to the weak ratings of American Railcar Industries and XO Holdings, both of which feature Icahn as majority owner and chairman.

“Carl Icahn is new to Motorola and to the industries in which we operate,” the company added in its letter. “We do not believe he is knowledgeable about technology or our business.”